Plan-Seq-Learn: Language Model Guided RL for Solving Long Horizon Robotics Tasks

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in performing high-level planning for long-horizon robotics tasks, but existing methods require access to a pre-defined skill library.
• The paper proposes a new approach, called Plan-Seq-Learn (PSL), that uses motion planning to bridge the gap between abstract language and learned low-level control, allowing robots to solve long-horizon tasks from scratch.
• PSL achieves state-of-the-art results on over 25 challenging robotics tasks, outperforming language-based, classical, and end-to-end approaches.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores how we can use the vast knowledge of large language models (LLMs) to help robots solve complex, long-term tasks. Traditionally, robots have been programmed with a set of pre-defined skills, like picking, placing, and navigating. But this can be limiting, especially for tasks that require fine-grained control or a combination of many different skills.

The researchers propose a new approach called Plan-Seq-Learn (PSL). PSL uses the high-level planning capabilities of LLMs to guide a reinforcement learning (RL) agent, which can then learn the low-level control needed to execute the plan. This allows the robot to solve complex tasks from scratch, without needing a pre-determined set of skills.

The key innovation is the use of motion planning to bridge the gap between the abstract language of the LLM and the actual robot controls. This allows the robot to adjust its behavior in a fine-grained way, tailoring its actions to the specific task at hand.

The researchers show that PSL outperforms other approaches, including language-based, classical, and end-to-end methods, on a wide range of long-horizon robotics tasks. This suggests that combining the strengths of LLMs and RL could be a powerful way to enable robots to tackle increasingly complex real-world challenges.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces Plan-Seq-Learn (PSL), a modular approach that uses motion planning to connect the high-level planning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) with learned low-level control policies.

The key components of PSL are:

1. Language Model: An LLM is used to generate high-level plans for solving the given task, drawing on its vast knowledge of the world.

2. Motion Planner: A motion planning module translates the LLM's abstract plan into a sequence of concrete actions that the robot can execute.

3. Reinforcement Learning (RL) Agent: An RL agent is trained to learn the low-level control policies needed to carry out the motion plan, allowing for fine-grained adjustment of the robot's behavior.

The researchers evaluate PSL on over 25 challenging long-horizon robotics tasks, including manipulation and navigation scenarios. They find that PSL achieves state-of-the-art results, outperforming language-based, classical, and end-to-end approaches with success rates over 85%.

This work demonstrates the potential of combining the strengths of LLMs and RL to enable robots to tackle complex, long-horizon tasks from scratch, without requiring a pre-defined set of skills. The use of motion planning to bridge the gap between abstract language and low-level control is a key innovation that allows for fine-grained control and adaptation to the task at hand.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to using LLMs for high-level planning in long-horizon robotics tasks. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations and areas for further research:

• The current implementation of PSL still relies on some pre-defined skills, such as navigation and object manipulation, which could limit its generalization to completely novel tasks.
• The motion planning module in PSL is based on a classical algorithm, which could be less efficient or flexible than learning the motion planning itself.
• The paper focuses on simulation experiments, and the performance of PSL in real-world settings with additional uncertainties and constraints remains to be explored.

Additionally, one could question whether the reliance on motion planning is truly necessary, or if the RL agent could learn to connect the LLM's high-level plans directly to low-level controls. This could potentially simplify the overall architecture and reduce the need for hand-engineered components.

Despite these caveats, the paper makes a significant contribution by demonstrating the potential of combining LLMs and RL for solving complex robotics tasks. As the field of large language models as generalizable policies continues to evolve, this work highlights the importance of bridging the gap between abstract language and grounded, embodied control.

Conclusion

The paper introduces Plan-Seq-Learn (PSL), a modular approach that leverages the high-level planning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to guide reinforcement learning (RL) agents in solving long-horizon robotics tasks. By using motion planning to bridge the gap between abstract language and low-level control, PSL outperforms language-based, classical, and end-to-end approaches on a wide range of challenging scenarios.

This work demonstrates the potential of combining LLMs and RL to enable robots to tackle complex, long-horizon tasks from scratch, without relying on a pre-determined set of skills. As the field of large language models as generalizable policies continues to advance, the insights from this paper could help pave the way for more versatile and capable robotic systems that can adapt to a wide range of real-world challenges.