From Parental Control to Joint Family Oversight: Can Parents and Teens Manage Mobile Online Safety and Privacy as Equals?

Overview

• The paper explores the tensions around online safety, privacy, and smartphone usage in families, and how parents and teens can collaborate to manage mobile privacy and security risks.
• The researchers developed a mobile app called CO-oPS that allows groups of users to co-monitor the apps installed on each other's devices and the privacy permissions granted to those apps.
• The study involved 19 parent-teen (ages 13-17) pairs to understand their current approaches to managing mobile safety and app privacy, and to evaluate the CO-oPS app.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers wanted to understand the challenges families face when trying to ensure online safety and protect privacy on smartphones. They created a mobile app called CO-oPS that lets a group of people, like a family, see what apps are installed on each other's devices and what permissions those apps have.

The researchers then had 19 parents and their teenage children use the CO-oPS app and share their thoughts. They found that both parents and teens often don't pay much attention to online safety or app privacy when installing new apps or granting permissions.

When using CO-oPS, the participants liked how it made it easier to see what was happening on each other's devices and talk about it. However, they were less interested in using features that would allow them to hide apps from each other or send messages within the app.

The study revealed some challenges with families trying to manage online safety and privacy together. Parents were generally more open to this collaborative approach, but teens felt it wasn't their place to monitor their parents, even though they thought their parents lacked the technical expertise to monitor themselves.

The researchers provide recommendations for how to overcome these challenges and help families work together more effectively to ensure online safety and protect privacy on smartphones.

Technical Explanation

The researchers developed the CO-oPS mobile app to enable community oversight of privacy and security on smartphones. CO-oPS allows a group of users, such as a family, to co-monitor the apps installed on each other's devices and the privacy permissions granted to those apps.

The researchers conducted a study with 19 parent-teen (ages 13-17) pairs to understand their current approaches to managing mobile safety and app privacy, and to evaluate the CO-oPS app. They found that both parents and teens often gave little consideration to online safety and privacy before installing new apps or granting privacy permissions.

When using CO-oPS, participants appreciated how the app increased transparency into one another's devices in a way that facilitated communication. However, they were less inclined to use features for in-app messaging or to hide apps from one another.

The study revealed key themes related to power imbalances between parents and teens that made co-management challenging. Parents were more open to collaborative oversight, while teens felt it was not their place to monitor their parents, even though both often believed parents lacked the technological expertise to monitor themselves.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several limitations to their study. First, the sample size was relatively small, and the participants were predominantly White and middle-class, which may limit the generalizability of the findings.

Additionally, the study only examined the use of the CO-oPS app over a short period. Longer-term usage may reveal different patterns of adoption and usage. The researchers also note that the app's design and functionality could be further refined based on the insights gained from the study.

While the researchers provide recommendations for overcoming the challenges identified, it's unclear how effective these approaches would be in practice. Addressing deep-seated power dynamics and trust issues between parents and teens may require more extensive interventions than what can be achieved through a mobile app alone.

Future research could explore more inclusive, community-based approaches to co-designing online safety solutions that better account for the diverse needs and perspectives of families. Integrating input from extended family members or co-designing with community stakeholders may also help to create more effective and widely accepted solutions.

Conclusion

This study sheds light on the complex challenges families face in collaboratively managing online safety and privacy on smartphones. While the CO-oPS app shows promise in increasing transparency and facilitating communication, the researchers identified significant barriers related to power dynamics and trust between parents and teens.

The insights gained from this study can inform the design of more effective collaborative, family-centered approaches to ensuring online safety and protecting privacy. Addressing these challenges is crucial, as families navigate the evolving landscape of mobile technology and digital risks.