Co-designing Community-based Sharing of Smarthome Devices for the Purpose of Co-monitoring In-home Emergencies
0
🔎
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Conducted 26 co-design interviews with 50 smart home device owners
- Explored the perceived benefits, drawbacks, and design considerations for a smart home system that enables co-monitoring with emergency contacts outside the home
- Participants felt such a system could help ensure personal safety, safeguard against material loss, and provide peace of mind
- Participants also expressed concerns about privacy, overburdening others, and potential threats like unauthorized access and security breaches
- Recommendations provided for designing technologies that facilitate co-monitoring while mitigating risks
Plain English Explanation
The researchers spoke with 50 people who own smart home devices to understand how a system that lets people outside the home monitor the home could be helpful, but also concerning. Participants thought such a system could help keep them safe, protect their belongings, and give them reassurance that someone would respond quickly in an emergency. However, they also worried about their privacy being invaded, burdening others with monitoring duties, and hackers being able to access the system.
To address these concerns, participants suggested the system should let people have flexible and detailed control over who can access what, as well as backup features in case something goes wrong. The study shows that while peer-based monitoring of smart homes for emergencies could be beneficial, it can also be challenging to implement in a way that works for everyone. The researchers provide recommendations for designing technologies that enable this kind of co-monitoring while minimizing the risks.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted 26 co-design interviews with 50 smart home device owners to understand their perceptions of the benefits, drawbacks, and design considerations for a smart home system that facilitates co-monitoring with emergency contacts outside the home. Participants felt such a system could help ensure their personal safety, protect them from material loss, and give them peace of mind by enabling quick response and verifying potential threats. However, they also expressed concerns about privacy, overburdening others, and other threats like unauthorized access and security breaches.
To address these concerns, participants designed for flexible and granular access control, as well as fail-safe backup features. The study reveals the potential advantages and difficulties of peer-based co-monitoring of smart homes for emergencies. Based on the insights, the researchers provide recommendations for designing technologies that enable this type of co-monitoring while mitigating the associated risks.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the design considerations and user perceptions around enabling remote co-monitoring of smart homes for emergencies. However, it is limited in scope, focusing only on 50 smart home device owners. Further research may be needed to understand the perspectives of a broader range of users, including those who do not currently own smart home devices.
Additionally, the study does not delve deeply into the technical feasibility and implementation challenges of developing a secure and privacy-preserving co-monitoring system. More research may be needed to address these technical concerns, as explored in "It Takes a Village: The Case for Including Extended Family in the Design of Eco-Feedback Technologies" and "Evaluating the Impact of Community Oversight on Managing Mobile Privacy".
Conclusion
This study highlights the potential benefits and challenges of developing a smart home system that enables co-monitoring with emergency contacts outside the home. While participants saw value in such a system for ensuring their safety and providing peace of mind, they also raised significant concerns about privacy, burden on others, and security risks. The researchers provide recommendations for designing technologies that facilitate this type of co-monitoring while mitigating these risks, which could inform future work in this area. Further research may be needed to explore the technical feasibility and explore alternative approaches, such as those discussed in "From Parental Control to Joint Family Oversight", "Co-Ops: A Mobile App for Community Oversight of Privacy", and "Towards Collaborative, Family-Centered Design for Online Safety".
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
0
Co-designing Community-based Sharing of Smarthome Devices for the Purpose of Co-monitoring In-home Emergencies
Leena Alghamdi, Mamtaj Akter, Jess Kropczynski, Pamela Wisniewski, Heather Lipford
We conducted 26 co-design interviews with 50 smarthome device owners to understand the perceived benefits, drawbacks, and design considerations for developing a smarthome system that facilitates co-monitoring with emergency contacts who live outside of one's home. Participants felt that such a system would help ensure their personal safety, safeguard from material loss, and give them peace of mind by ensuring quick response and verifying potential threats. However, they also expressed concerns regarding privacy, overburdening others, and other potential threats, such as unauthorized access and security breaches. To alleviate these concerns, participants designed for flexible and granular access control and fail-safe back-up features. Our study reveals why peer-based co-monitoring of smarthomes for emergencies may be beneficial but also difficult to implement. Based on the insights gained from our study, we provide recommendations for designing technologies that facilitate such co-monitoring while mitigating its risks.
Read more4/17/2024
📉
0
It Takes a Village: A Case for Including Extended Family Members in the Joint Oversight of Family-based Privacy and Security for Mobile Smartphones
Mamtaj Akter, Leena Alghamdi, Jess Kropczynski, Heather Lipford, Pamela Wisniewski
We conducted a user study with 19 parent-teen dyads to understand the perceived benefits and drawbacks of using a mobile app that allows them to co-manage mobile privacy, safety, and security within their families. While the primary goal of the study was to understand the use case as it pertained to parents and teens, an emerging finding from our study was that participants found value in extending app use to other family members (siblings, cousins, and grandparents). Participants felt that it would help bring the necessary expertise into their immediate family network and help protect the older adults and children of the family from privacy and security risks. However, participants expressed that co-monitoring by extended family members might cause tensions in their families, creating interpersonal conflicts. To alleviate these concerns, participants suggested more control over the privacy features to facilitate sharing their installed apps with only trusted family members.
Read more4/17/2024
🤷
0
Exploring the Landscape of Ubiquitous In-home Health Monitoring: A Comprehensive Survey
Farhad Pourpanah, Ali Etemad
Ubiquitous in-home health monitoring systems have become popular in recent years due to the rise of digital health technologies and the growing demand for remote health monitoring. These systems enable individuals to increase their independence by allowing them to monitor their health from the home and by allowing more control over their well-being. In this study, we perform a comprehensive survey on this topic by reviewing a large number of literature in the area. We investigate these systems from various aspects, namely sensing technologies, communication technologies, intelligent and computing systems, and application areas. Specifically, we provide an overview of in-home health monitoring systems and identify their main components. We then present each component and discuss its role within in-home health monitoring systems. In addition, we provide an overview of the practical use of ubiquitous technologies in the home for health monitoring. Finally, we identify the main challenges and limitations based on the existing literature and provide eight recommendations for potential future research directions toward the development of in-home health monitoring systems. We conclude that despite extensive research on various components needed for the development of effective in-home health monitoring systems, the development of effective in-home health monitoring systems still requires further investigation.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Examining Caregiving Roles to Differentiate the Effects of Using a Mobile App for Community Oversight for Privacy and Security
Mamtaj Akter, Jess Kropczynski, Heather Lipford, Pamela Wisniewski
We conducted a 4-week field study with 101 smartphone users who self-organized into 22 small groups of family, friends, and neighbors to use ``CO-oPS,'' a mobile app for co-managing mobile privacy and security. We differentiated between those who provided oversight (i.e., caregivers) and those who did not (i.e., caregivees) to examine differential effects on their experiences and behaviors while using CO-oPS. Caregivers reported higher power use, community trust, belonging, collective efficacy, and self-efficacy than caregivees. Both groups' self-efficacy and collective efficacy for mobile privacy and security increased after using CO-oPS. However, this increase was significantly stronger for caregivees. Our research demonstrates how community-based approaches can benefit people who need additional help managing their digital privacy and security. We provide recommendations to support community-based oversight for managing privacy and security within communities of different roles and skills.
Read more9/5/2024