It Takes a Village: A Case for Including Extended Family Members in the Joint Oversight of Family-based Privacy and Security for Mobile Smartphones

Overview

• Conducted a user study with 19 parent-teen dyads to understand the perceived benefits and drawbacks of using a mobile app for co-managing mobile privacy, safety, and security within families
• Found that participants saw value in extending app use to other family members (siblings, cousins, grandparents) to bring expertise and protect older adults and children from risks
• Participants expressed concerns that co-monitoring by extended family could cause interpersonal conflicts, suggesting more control over privacy features to share with only trusted family members

Plain English Explanation

The researchers wanted to understand how families felt about using a mobile app that would allow parents and teenagers to jointly manage privacy, safety, and security on their devices. While the main focus was on parents and teens, an interesting finding was that participants thought the app could be useful for the whole family, including siblings, cousins, and grandparents.

Participants felt that involving the whole family could help protect younger and older members from online risks by bringing in the necessary expertise. However, they were also worried that having extended family members monitoring each other could cause tensions and conflicts within the family. To address this, participants suggested having more control over the privacy features to only share the app with trusted family members they were comfortable with.

Technical Explanation

The researchers conducted a user study with 19 parent-teen dyads to explore the perceived benefits and drawbacks of using a mobile app for co-managing mobile privacy, safety, and security within families. While the primary goal was to understand the use case for parents and teens, an emerging finding was that participants saw value in extending the app to other family members to bring expertise and protect vulnerable members.

Participants expressed concerns that co-monitoring by extended family could create interpersonal conflicts. To address this, they suggested having more control over the privacy features to only share the app with trusted family members.

Critical Analysis

The study provides valuable insights into the potential benefits and challenges of involving extended family members in co-managing mobile privacy and security within families. While the idea of bringing in broader family expertise is compelling, the researchers rightly identified the risk of increased tensions and conflicts that could arise.

One limitation of the study is the relatively small sample size of 19 parent-teen dyads, which may not capture the full range of family dynamics and perspectives. Additionally, the study focused on perceptions and did not actually implement the app with extended family members, so the real-world impact on family relationships remains to be seen.

Further research could explore design approaches that better balance the need for family-wide oversight with individual privacy and autonomy. Engaging a more diverse set of families, including those with different cultural backgrounds and family structures, could also yield additional insights.

Conclusion

This study highlights the complex trade-offs involved in developing technology to support family-centered approaches to online safety and security. While there is potential value in extending oversight to the broader family network, the researchers identified legitimate concerns about the impact on family dynamics that need to be carefully considered. Ongoing collaborative design with families will be crucial to balance these considerations and create solutions that truly empower families to protect their digital well-being.