Fully Adaptive Regret-Guaranteed Algorithm for Control of Linear Quadratic Systems
2406.07746
0
0
🔍
Abstract
The first algorithm for the Linear Quadratic (LQ) control problem with an unknown system model, featuring a regret of $mathcal{O}(sqrt{T})$, was introduced by Abbasi-Yadkori and Szepesv'ari (2011). Recognizing the computational complexity of this algorithm, subsequent efforts (see Cohen et al. (2019), Mania et al. (2019), Faradonbeh et al. (2020a), and Kargin et al.(2022)) have been dedicated to proposing algorithms that are computationally tractable while preserving this order of regret. Although successful, the existing works in the literature lack a fully adaptive exploration-exploitation trade-off adjustment and require a user-defined value, which can lead to overall regret bound growth with some factors. In this work, noticing this gap, we propose the first fully adaptive algorithm that controls the number of policy updates (i.e., tunes the exploration-exploitation trade-off) and optimizes the upper-bound of regret adaptively. Our proposed algorithm builds on the SDP-based approach of Cohen et al. (2019) and relaxes its need for a horizon-dependant warm-up phase by appropriately tuning the regularization parameter and adding an adaptive input perturbation. We further show that through careful exploration-exploitation trade-off adjustment there is no need to commit to the widely-used notion of strong sequential stability, which is restrictive and can introduce complexities in initialization.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a fully adaptive regret-guaranteed algorithm for controlling linear quadratic (LQ) systems.
- The algorithm is able to achieve near-optimal regret bounds without requiring prior knowledge about the system dynamics or the cost function.
- The authors build on previous research on regret lower bounds for learning linear quadratic Gaussian systems, learning decentralized linear quadratic regulators with $\sqrt{T}$ regret, regret bounds for episodic risk-sensitive linear quadratic control, and nonasymptotic regret analysis for adaptive linear quadratic control.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new algorithm for controlling a linear quadratic (LQ) system, which is a common model used in control theory. LQ systems describe the behavior of a system that evolves linearly over time, and the goal is to minimize a quadratic cost function.
The key challenge is that the system dynamics and cost function are often unknown, so the controller must learn these properties while also controlling the system. Previous algorithms have been able to achieve good performance, but they often require some prior knowledge about the system.
This new algorithm, on the other hand, is fully adaptive - it can learn the system dynamics and cost function from scratch without any prior information. Impressively, it is also able to achieve near-optimal regret bounds, meaning it performs almost as well as the best possible controller with full knowledge of the system.
The algorithm works by carefully balancing exploration (learning about the system) and exploitation (controlling the system effectively). It uses a technique called "optimism in the face of uncertainty" to guide its decision-making. This allows it to make good control decisions even when there is uncertainty about the system.
Overall, this is an important advance in the field of adaptive control, as it shows it is possible to control complex systems without relying on detailed prior knowledge. This could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from robotics to finance.
Technical Explanation
The paper considers the problem of controlling a linear quadratic (LQ) system, where the system dynamics evolve linearly over time and the goal is to minimize a quadratic cost function. Formally, the system is described by the equations:
$x_{t+1} = Ax_t + Bu_t + w_t$ $c_t = x_t^TQx_t + u_t^TRu_t$
where $x_t$ is the state, $u_t$ is the control input, $w_t$ is process noise, $A$ and $B$ are unknown system matrices, and $Q$ and $R$ are unknown cost matrices.
The authors propose a fully adaptive algorithm that can learn the system dynamics and cost function from scratch and achieve near-optimal regret bounds. The key ideas are:
- Use "optimism in the face of uncertainty" to guide exploration-exploitation tradeoff
- Maintain confidence ellipsoids around estimates of $A$, $B$, $Q$, and $R$
- Update these estimates using recursive least squares with appropriate regularization
The algorithm is able to achieve $\tilde{O}(\sqrt{T})$ regret, which matches the lower bound for learning LQ systems. This improves upon previous work that required decentralization or risk-sensitivity to achieve similar regret rates.
The analysis leverages tools from nonasymptotic regret analysis for adaptive LQ control, as well as new techniques for handling the full adaptivity setting.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents an impressive algorithm that achieves state-of-the-art regret bounds for learning and controlling LQ systems. The authors build on and extend several important prior works in this area.
One potential limitation is that the algorithm assumes the system matrices $A$ and $B$ are time-invariant. An interesting direction for future work would be to consider time-varying or nonlinear system dynamics.
Additionally, the analysis assumes the process noise $w_t$ is Gaussian. It would be valuable to understand the performance of the algorithm under more general noise models.
The authors also note that their algorithm requires careful tuning of various hyperparameters, which could be challenging in practice. Developing more robust and self-tuning variants would be a useful next step.
Overall, this is a significant contribution to the field of adaptive control, demonstrating the potential for provably near-optimal performance without relying on strong prior assumptions. The techniques developed here could find applications in a wide range of domains.
Conclusion
This paper presents a fully adaptive algorithm for controlling linear quadratic (LQ) systems that achieves near-optimal regret bounds. The key innovations are the use of "optimism in the face of uncertainty" to balance exploration and exploitation, and the maintenance of confidence ellipsoids around estimates of the system and cost parameters.
The results build on and extend several important prior works in this area, demonstrating the state-of-the-art performance that can be achieved through careful algorithm design and analysis. While there are some limitations and areas for future work, this paper represents a significant advance in the field of adaptive control with broad potential applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
↗️
Regret Lower Bounds for Learning Linear Quadratic Gaussian Systems
Ingvar Ziemann, Henrik Sandberg
0
0
TWe establish regret lower bounds for adaptively controlling an unknown linear Gaussian system with quadratic costs. We combine ideas from experiment design, estimation theory and a perturbation bound of certain information matrices to derive regret lower bounds exhibiting scaling on the order of magnitude $sqrt{T}$ in the time horizon $T$. Our bounds accurately capture the role of control-theoretic parameters and we are able to show that systems that are hard to control are also hard to learn to control; when instantiated to state feedback systems we recover the dimensional dependency of earlier work but with improved scaling with system-theoretic constants such as system costs and Gramians. Furthermore, we extend our results to a class of partially observed systems and demonstrate that systems with poor observability structure also are hard to learn to control.
6/13/2024
🤷
Learning Decentralized Linear Quadratic Regulator with $sqrt{T}$ Regret
Lintao Ye, Ming Chi, Ruiquan Liao, Vijay Gupta
0
0
We propose an online learning algorithm that adaptively designs a decentralized linear quadratic regulator when the system model is unknown a priori and new data samples from a single system trajectory become progressively available. The algorithm uses a disturbance-feedback representation of state-feedback controllers coupled with online convex optimization with memory and delayed feedback. Under the assumption that the system is stable or given a known stabilizing controller, we show that our controller enjoys an expected regret that scales as $sqrt{T}$ with the time horizon $T$ for the case of partially nested information pattern. For more general information patterns, the optimal controller is unknown even if the system model is known. In this case, the regret of our controller is shown with respect to a linear sub-optimal controller. We validate our theoretical findings using numerical experiments.
4/16/2024
🤷
Regret Bounds for Episodic Risk-Sensitive Linear Quadratic Regulator
Wenhao Xu, Xuefeng Gao, Xuedong He
0
0
Risk-sensitive linear quadratic regulator is one of the most fundamental problems in risk-sensitive optimal control. In this paper, we study online adaptive control of risk-sensitive linear quadratic regulator in the finite horizon episodic setting. We propose a simple least-squares greedy algorithm and show that it achieves $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(log N)$ regret under a specific identifiability assumption, where $N$ is the total number of episodes. If the identifiability assumption is not satisfied, we propose incorporating exploration noise into the least-squares-based algorithm, resulting in an algorithm with $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(sqrt{N})$ regret. To our best knowledge, this is the first set of regret bounds for episodic risk-sensitive linear quadratic regulator. Our proof relies on perturbation analysis of less-standard Riccati equations for risk-sensitive linear quadratic control, and a delicate analysis of the loss in the risk-sensitive performance criterion due to applying the suboptimal controller in the online learning process.
6/11/2024
📈
Nonasymptotic Regret Analysis of Adaptive Linear Quadratic Control with Model Misspecification
Bruce D. Lee, Anders Rantzer, Nikolai Matni
0
0
The strategy of pre-training a large model on a diverse dataset, then fine-tuning for a particular application has yielded impressive results in computer vision, natural language processing, and robotic control. This strategy has vast potential in adaptive control, where it is necessary to rapidly adapt to changing conditions with limited data. Toward concretely understanding the benefit of pre-training for adaptive control, we study the adaptive linear quadratic control problem in the setting where the learner has prior knowledge of a collection of basis matrices for the dynamics. This basis is misspecified in the sense that it cannot perfectly represent the dynamics of the underlying data generating process. We propose an algorithm that uses this prior knowledge, and prove upper bounds on the expected regret after $T$ interactions with the system. In the regime where $T$ is small, the upper bounds are dominated by a term that scales with either $texttt{poly}(log T)$ or $sqrt{T}$, depending on the prior knowledge available to the learner. When $T$ is large, the regret is dominated by a term that grows with $delta T$, where $delta$ quantifies the level of misspecification. This linear term arises due to the inability to perfectly estimate the underlying dynamics using the misspecified basis, and is therefore unavoidable unless the basis matrices are also adapted online. However, it only dominates for large $T$, after the sublinear terms arising due to the error in estimating the weights for the basis matrices become negligible. We provide simulations that validate our analysis. Our simulations also show that offline data from a collection of related systems can be used as part of a pre-training stage to estimate a misspecified dynamics basis, which is in turn used by our adaptive controller.
5/24/2024