Gauges and Accelerated Optimization over Smooth and/or Strongly Convex Sets

Overview

• The paper considers optimization problems with constraints defined over smooth and/or strongly convex sets.
• The authors propose new scalable, projection-free, accelerated first-order methods for solving these problems.
• The algorithms avoid linear optimization or projection oracles, using only cheap one-dimensional line searches and normal vector computations.
• The methods achieve optimal accelerated convergence guarantees of O(1/T) for strongly convex problems, O(1/T^2) for smooth problems, and accelerated linear convergence given both.
• The analysis is based on novel characterizations of the Minkowski gauge of smooth and/or strongly convex sets.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at a particular type of optimization problem where the feasible set, or the set of allowed solutions, is defined by smooth and/or strongly convex constraints. These are special types of constraints that have certain mathematical properties.

The authors develop new optimization algorithms that can efficiently solve these types of constrained optimization problems. These algorithms are "projection-free", which means they don't need to perform expensive computations to "project" the solution onto the feasible set. Instead, they use much simpler operations like one-dimensional line searches and computing normal vectors.

Despite this, the authors prove that their algorithms can achieve optimal convergence rates. For strongly convex problems, they get a convergence rate of O(1/T), and for smooth problems, they get O(1/T^2). This means the algorithms converge very quickly, getting close to the optimal solution in a small number of iterations.

The key to their analysis is a new mathematical characterization of the Minkowski gauge of the feasible set. The Minkowski gauge is a way of measuring distances within the set, and the authors show that even though the gauge itself may not be smooth or strongly convex, the gauge squared inherits these properties if the set does.

Technical Explanation

The paper considers constrained optimization problems defined over smooth and/or strongly convex sets. These problems are important in many areas, but have been less explored in the first-order optimization literature compared to their unconstrained counterparts.

The authors propose new accelerated first-order methods that can efficiently solve these constrained optimization problems. Their algorithms are projection-free, meaning they avoid the need for expensive linear optimization or projection oracles. Instead, they use only cheap one-dimensional line searches and normal vector computations.

Despite this simplicity, the authors prove that their methods achieve optimal accelerated convergence guarantees. Specifically, they derive rates of O(1/T) for strongly convex problems, O(1/T^2) for smooth problems, and accelerated linear convergence when both properties hold.

The key to their analysis is a novel characterization of the Minkowski gauge of the feasible set. Even though the gauge itself may not be smooth or strongly convex, the authors show that the gauge squared inherits these properties if the set does. This allows them to apply powerful analytical tools developed for unconstrained problems.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents interesting theoretical results on constrained optimization that extend the state-of-the-art. The authors' projection-free algorithms and associated convergence guarantees are impressive, especially given the simplicity of the required operations.

However, the paper does not provide any empirical evaluation of the proposed methods. It would be helpful to see how they perform on practical optimization problems compared to other constrained optimization techniques. The authors also do not discuss any potential limitations or caveats of their approach.

Additionally, while the mathematical characterization of the Minkowski gauge is technically novel, it is not clear how this could be leveraged beyond the specific algorithms presented in the paper. Further research may be needed to understand the broader implications of this gauge analysis.

Overall, this is a strong theoretical contribution, but more work is needed to understand the real-world applicability and practical tradeoffs of the authors' methods.

Conclusion

This paper tackles the important problem of optimization with smooth and/or strongly convex constraints. The authors develop new projection-free, accelerated first-order algorithms that achieve optimal convergence guarantees despite their simplicity.

The key enabler is a novel mathematical characterization of the Minkowski gauge of the feasible set, which allows the authors to adapt powerful analytical tools from unconstrained optimization. While the theoretical results are impressive, more empirical validation and exploration of the practical implications would strengthen the overall contribution.

Overall, this work represents an interesting advance in constrained optimization that could have broad applications in machine learning, engineering, and other fields that rely on efficient numerical optimization.