Generate-on-Graph: Treat LLM as both Agent and KG in Incomplete Knowledge Graph Question Answering

Overview

• The paper addresses the issue of insufficient knowledge and tendency to generate hallucination in Large Language Models (LLMs).
• Numerous studies have tried to integrate LLMs with Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to address this problem.
• However, these methods are evaluated on conventional Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) with complete KGs, where the factual triples involved in each question are entirely covered by the given KG.
• In real-world scenarios, KGs are often incomplete, and the paper proposes leveraging LLMs for Question Answering under Incomplete Knowledge Graph (IKGQA) conditions.
• The paper introduces a training-free method called Generate-on-Graph (GoG) that can generate new factual triples while exploring on KGs.

Plain English Explanation

Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3 are powerful tools that can understand and generate human-like text. However, they often lack sufficient knowledge and can sometimes produce hallucinated or inaccurate information. To address this, researchers have tried integrating LLMs with Knowledge Graphs (KGs) - structured databases of facts and relationships.

In the typical setup for evaluating these methods, the KG contains all the information needed to answer the questions being asked. This makes the task relatively straightforward, as the LLM can simply explore the KG to find the relevant facts and provide the answer.

But in the real world, KGs are often incomplete - they don't have all the knowledge required to answer every question. This is where the paper's research comes in. The authors propose a new method called Generate-on-Graph (GoG) that allows LLMs to not only explore the KG, but also <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/logic-query-thoughts-guiding-large-language-models">generate new factual information</a> to supplement the incomplete KG and answer questions more effectively.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a method called Generate-on-Graph (GoG) to handle Question Answering under Incomplete Knowledge Graph (IKGQA) conditions. Unlike previous approaches that treat LLMs as agents to simply explore the KG, GoG also treats the LLM as a knowledge source to <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/reasoning-efficient-knowledge-pathsknowledge-graph-guides-large">generate new facts</a> based on the explored subgraph and the LLM's own inherent knowledge.

The key steps of the GoG method are:

1. Selecting the most relevant subgraph from the incomplete KG based on the question.
2. Generating new factual triples using the LLM to supplement the subgraph.
3. Answering the question by exploring the augmented subgraph.

Experimental results on two datasets show that GoG can solve IKGQA to a certain extent, while <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/counter-intuitive-large-language-models-can-better">almost all previous methods cannot perform well</a> on this task.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to integrating LLMs with incomplete KGs, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

• The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the types of facts the LLM is able to generate and how accurate or reliable these generated facts are. More research is needed to understand the strengths and weaknesses of the LLM's knowledge generation capabilities.
• The experiments are conducted on a limited set of datasets, and it would be valuable to evaluate the GoG method on a wider range of IKGQA benchmarks to assess its generalizability.
• The paper does not discuss potential biases or safety issues that may arise from allowing LLMs to freely generate new factual information, which could be an important consideration for real-world applications. <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/curiousllm-elevating-multi-document-qa-reasoning-infused">Further research is needed</a> to address these concerns.

Overall, the GoG method represents an interesting step forward in leveraging the complementary strengths of LLMs and KGs, and the paper's insights could contribute to the development of more robust and versatile question answering systems.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach called Generate-on-Graph (GoG) that aims to address the limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs (KGs) when it comes to question answering in the real world, where KGs are often incomplete.

The key idea of GoG is to not only treat the LLM as an agent to explore the KG, but also as a source of knowledge that can <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/cross-data-knowledge-graph-construction-llm-enabled">generate new factual information</a> to supplement the incomplete KG. This allows the system to better integrate internal and external knowledge sources to answer questions more effectively.

The paper's experimental results demonstrate the potential of this approach, suggesting that LLMs can play a valuable role in enhancing knowledge-based question answering systems, particularly in scenarios where the available knowledge is incomplete. While further research is needed to address some of the limitations, the GoG method represents an important step forward in the ongoing effort to create more robust and capable AI-powered question answering systems.