Hierarchical in-Context Reinforcement Learning with Hindsight Modular Reflections for Planning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel hierarchical reinforcement learning approach called Hierarchical in-Context Reinforcement Learning with Hindsight Modular Reflections for Planning (HICRL-HMRP).
- The key contributions include a hierarchical agent architecture and a hindsight modular reflection mechanism for improved planning and generalization.
- The approach is evaluated on a suite of challenging robotic manipulation tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way for AI systems to learn complex skills through Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning. The main idea is to break down a challenging task into smaller, more manageable sub-tasks that the AI can learn independently. This hierarchical structure allows the AI to gradually build up its capabilities.
A key innovation in this paper is the "hindsight modular reflection" mechanism. This allows the AI to reflect on its past experiences and extract useful information that can help it plan better for the future. By breaking down its past actions into modular components, the AI can identify patterns and insights that improve its decision-making.
For example, if the AI is trying to manipulate a object, it might discover that certain hand motions are particularly effective, even if they weren't initially successful in the full task. By recognizing these useful building blocks, the AI can assemble them more effectively in the future.
This hierarchical and reflective approach enables the AI to tackle complex robotic manipulation tasks more efficiently and with better generalization to new situations.
Technical Explanation
The HICRL-HMRP framework has two key components:
-
Hierarchical Agent Architecture: The agent is composed of a high-level policy that selects abstract macro-actions, and a low-level policy that executes the primitive actions within each macro-action. This hierarchy allows the agent to learn complex behaviors by first mastering simpler sub-tasks.
-
Hindsight Modular Reflection: After executing a macro-action, the agent reflects on the low-level actions it took and identifies modular components that were particularly useful or ineffective. This hindsight knowledge is then used to guide future planning and decision-making.
The reflection process involves decomposing the agent's recent trajectory into a set of modular action primitives. The agent can then analyze the success or failure of each module and update its understanding of their utility. This modular reflection allows the agent to build a more nuanced model of the task structure and discover effective building blocks for solving the overall problem.
The authors evaluate HICRL-HMRP on a suite of challenging robotic manipulation tasks, where the agent must learn to grasp, lift, and move objects with dexterity. The results demonstrate that the hierarchical and reflective approach leads to faster learning and better generalization compared to flat reinforcement learning and other hierarchical baselines.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the HICRL-HMRP framework, exploring its performance across a range of robotic manipulation tasks. The authors acknowledge some potential limitations, such as the reliance on a pre-defined set of primitive actions and the need for additional research to further improve the reflection mechanism.
One area that could be explored further is the scalability of the approach to more complex, real-world environments. The evaluation is conducted in simulation, and it would be valuable to see how the framework performs in physical robotic systems with noisy sensors and dynamics.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the interpretability of the learned behaviors. Understanding the internal representations and decision-making process of the hierarchical agent could provide valuable insights for improving the approach and making it more transparent.
Overall, the HICRL-HMRP framework represents an exciting advance in hierarchical reinforcement learning, with the potential to enable more capable and versatile robotic systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel hierarchical reinforcement learning approach called HICRL-HMRP, which leverages a hierarchical agent architecture and a hindsight modular reflection mechanism to improve planning and generalization. The results demonstrate that this approach can effectively solve complex robotic manipulation tasks, outperforming other hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines.
The key contributions of this work are the hierarchical agent design and the modular reflection process, which allow the agent to build a more nuanced understanding of the task structure and identify effective building blocks for solving the overall problem. While the evaluation is conducted in simulation, the framework shows promise for enabling more capable and versatile robotic systems in the real world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Hierarchical in-Context Reinforcement Learning with Hindsight Modular Reflections for Planning
Chuanneng Sun, Songjun Huang, Dario Pompili
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in various language tasks, making them promising candidates for decision-making in robotics. Inspired by Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning (HRL), we propose Hierarchical in-Context Reinforcement Learning (HCRL), a novel framework that decomposes complex tasks into sub-tasks using an LLM-based high-level policy, in which a complex task is decomposed into sub-tasks by a high-level policy on-the-fly. The sub-tasks, defined by goals, are assigned to the low-level policy to complete. Once the LLM agent determines that the goal is finished, a new goal will be proposed. To improve the agent's performance in multi-episode execution, we propose Hindsight Modular Reflection (HMR), where, instead of reflecting on the full trajectory, we replace the task objective with intermediate goals and let the agent reflect on shorter trajectories to improve reflection efficiency. We evaluate the decision-making ability of the proposed HCRL in three benchmark environments--ALFWorld, Webshop, and HotpotQA. Results show that HCRL can achieve 9%, 42%, and 10% performance improvement in 5 episodes of execution over strong in-context learning baselines.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Subgoal-based Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Agent Collaboration
Cheng Xu, Changtian Zhang, Yuchen Shi, Ran Wang, Shihong Duan, Yadong Wan, Xiaotong Zhang
Recent advancements in reinforcement learning have made significant impacts across various domains, yet they often struggle in complex multi-agent environments due to issues like algorithm instability, low sampling efficiency, and the challenges of exploration and dimensionality explosion. Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) offers a structured approach to decompose complex tasks into simpler sub-tasks, which is promising for multi-agent settings. This paper advances the field by introducing a hierarchical architecture that autonomously generates effective subgoals without explicit constraints, enhancing both flexibility and stability in training. We propose a dynamic goal generation strategy that adapts based on environmental changes. This method significantly improves the adaptability and sample efficiency of the learning process. Furthermore, we address the critical issue of credit assignment in multi-agent systems by synergizing our hierarchical architecture with a modified QMIX network, thus improving overall strategy coordination and efficiency. Comparative experiments with mainstream reinforcement learning algorithms demonstrate the superior convergence speed and performance of our approach in both single-agent and multi-agent environments, confirming its effectiveness and flexibility in complex scenarios. Our code is open-sourced at: url{https://github.com/SICC-Group/GMAH}.
Read more8/22/2024
🌿
0
Scaling Up Natural Language Understanding for Multi-Robots Through the Lens of Hierarchy
Shaojun Xu, Xusheng Luo, Yutong Huang, Letian Leng, Ruixuan Liu, Changliu Liu
Long-horizon planning is hindered by challenges such as uncertainty accumulation, computational complexity, delayed rewards and incomplete information. This work proposes an approach to exploit the task hierarchy from human instructions to facilitate multi-robot planning. Using Large Language Models (LLMs), we propose a two-step approach to translate multi-sentence instructions into a structured language, Hierarchical Linear Temporal Logic (LTL), which serves as a formal representation for planning. Initially, LLMs transform the instructions into a hierarchical representation defined as Hierarchical Task Tree, capturing the logical and temporal relations among tasks. Following this, a domain-specific fine-tuning of LLM translates sub-tasks of each task into flat LTL formulas, aggregating them to form hierarchical LTL specifications. These specifications are then leveraged for planning using off-the-shelf planners. Our framework not only bridges the gap between instructions and algorithmic planning but also showcases the potential of LLMs in harnessing hierarchical reasoning to automate multi-robot task planning. Through evaluations in both simulation and real-world experiments involving human participants, we demonstrate that our method can handle more complex instructions compared to existing methods. The results indicate that our approach achieves higher success rates and lower costs in multi-robot task allocation and plan generation. Demos videos are available at https://youtu.be/7WOrDKxIMIs .
Read more8/16/2024
0
Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies
Yu Luo, Fuchun Sun, Tianying Ji, Xianyuan Zhan
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) addresses complex long-horizon tasks by skillfully decomposing them into subgoals. Therefore, the effectiveness of HRL is greatly influenced by subgoal reachability. Typical HRL methods only consider subgoal reachability from the unilateral level, where a dominant level enforces compliance to the subordinate level. However, we observe that when the dominant level becomes trapped in local exploration or generates unattainable subgoals, the subordinate level is negatively affected and cannot follow the dominant level's actions. This can potentially make both levels stuck in local optima, ultimately hindering subsequent subgoal reachability. Allowing real-time bilateral information sharing and error correction would be a natural cure for this issue, which motivates us to propose a mutual response mechanism. Based on this, we propose the Bidirectional-reachable Hierarchical Policy Optimization (BrHPO)--a simple yet effective algorithm that also enjoys computation efficiency. Experiment results on a variety of long-horizon tasks showcase that BrHPO outperforms other state-of-the-art HRL baselines, coupled with a significantly higher exploration efficiency and robustness.
Read more6/27/2024