How Culturally Aware are Vision-Language Models?
2405.17475
0
0
Abstract
An image is often said to be worth a thousand words, and certain images can tell rich and insightful stories. Can these stories be told via image captioning? Images from folklore genres, such as mythology, folk dance, cultural signs, and symbols, are vital to every culture. Our research compares the performance of four popular vision-language models (GPT-4V, Gemini Pro Vision, LLaVA, and OpenFlamingo) in identifying culturally specific information in such images and creating accurate and culturally sensitive image captions. We also propose a new evaluation metric, Cultural Awareness Score (CAS), dedicated to measuring the degree of cultural awareness in image captions. We provide a dataset MOSAIC-1.5k, labeled with ground truth for images containing cultural background and context, as well as a labeled dataset with assigned Cultural Awareness Scores that can be used with unseen data. Creating culturally appropriate image captions is valuable for scientific research and can be beneficial for many practical applications. We envision that our work will promote a deeper integration of cultural sensitivity in AI applications worldwide. By making the dataset and Cultural Awareness Score available to the public, we aim to facilitate further research in this area, encouraging the development of more culturally aware AI systems that respect and celebrate global diversity.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the cultural awareness of vision-language models, which are AI systems that can generate text descriptions of images.
- The researchers investigate whether these models can accurately represent diverse cultural perspectives and avoid biases.
- They propose the CIC Framework to assess cultural awareness and introduce new datasets to evaluate model performance.
Plain English Explanation
Vision-language models are AI systems that can look at images and describe them in words. However, these models may reflect the cultural biases of the data they were trained on, potentially leading to inaccurate or insensitive descriptions.
The researchers in this paper want to understand how culturally aware these vision-language models really are. They propose a new framework, called the CIC Framework, to assess the cultural awareness of these models. They also introduce new datasets that can be used to evaluate how well the models handle diverse cultural perspectives.
By doing this, the researchers hope to identify areas where vision-language models may be falling short and provide guidance on how to make them more culturally aware and inclusive.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by reviewing related work on cultural bias in AI systems and the challenges of creating culturally aware vision-language models. The researchers then introduce the CIC Framework, which stands for "Cultural, Intersectional, and Contextual." This framework provides a structured approach to assess the cultural awareness of vision-language models along these three dimensions.
To put the framework into practice, the researchers create two new datasets: No Filter, which focuses on cultural and socioeconomic diversity, and Image Speaks a Thousand Words, which examines the ability of models to handle diverse linguistic and cultural perspectives.
Using these datasets, the researchers evaluate the performance of several state-of-the-art vision-language models. Their analysis reveals that while these models can generate accurate captions for many images, they often struggle to represent cultural diversity and may perpetuate harmful stereotypes.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable framework and datasets for evaluating the cultural awareness of vision-language models. However, the researchers acknowledge that their work is just a starting point, and more research is needed to fully understand the limitations of these models.
One potential concern is that the datasets, while diverse, may not capture the full breadth of cultural perspectives and experiences. Additionally, the researchers note that the CIC Framework could be further refined and expanded to better assess the nuances of cultural awareness.
The paper also raises important questions about the effectiveness of recent large vision-language models and the need to address the fundamental reasons why these models may be 'bad' at representing cultural diversity.
Conclusion
This paper takes an important step in understanding the cultural awareness of vision-language models. By proposing a comprehensive framework and introducing new datasets, the researchers have provided valuable tools for evaluating and improving the cultural sensitivity of these AI systems.
As vision-language models become more widely deployed, it is crucial that they are able to accurately and respectfully represent diverse cultural perspectives. The insights from this research can help guide the development of more inclusive and equitable AI technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
CIC: A framework for Culturally-aware Image Captioning
Youngsik Yun, Jihie Kim
0
0
Image Captioning generates descriptive sentences from images using Vision-Language Pre-trained models (VLPs) such as BLIP, which has improved greatly. However, current methods lack the generation of detailed descriptive captions for the cultural elements depicted in the images, such as the traditional clothing worn by people from Asian cultural groups. In this paper, we propose a new framework, textbf{Culturally-aware Image Captioning (CIC)}, that generates captions and describes cultural elements extracted from cultural visual elements in images representing cultures. Inspired by methods combining visual modality and Large Language Models (LLMs) through appropriate prompts, our framework (1) generates questions based on cultural categories from images, (2) extracts cultural visual elements from Visual Question Answering (VQA) using generated questions, and (3) generates culturally-aware captions using LLMs with the prompts. Our human evaluation conducted on 45 participants from 4 different cultural groups with a high understanding of the corresponding culture shows that our proposed framework generates more culturally descriptive captions when compared to the image captioning baseline based on VLPs. Our code and dataset will be made publicly available upon acceptance.
5/3/2024
New!From Local Concepts to Universals: Evaluating the Multicultural Understanding of Vision-Language Models
Mehar Bhatia, Sahithya Ravi, Aditya Chinchure, Eunjeong Hwang, Vered Shwartz
0
0
Despite recent advancements in vision-language models, their performance remains suboptimal on images from non-western cultures due to underrepresentation in training datasets. Various benchmarks have been proposed to test models' cultural inclusivity, but they have limited coverage of cultures and do not adequately assess cultural diversity across universal as well as culture-specific local concepts. To address these limitations, we introduce the GlobalRG benchmark, comprising two challenging tasks: retrieval across universals and cultural visual grounding. The former task entails retrieving culturally diverse images for universal concepts from 50 countries, while the latter aims at grounding culture-specific concepts within images from 15 countries. Our evaluation across a wide range of models reveals that the performance varies significantly across cultures -- underscoring the necessity for enhancing multicultural understanding in vision-language models.
7/2/2024
See It from My Perspective: Diagnosing the Western Cultural Bias of Large Vision-Language Models in Image Understanding
Amith Ananthram, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Carl Vondrick, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown
0
0
Vision-language models (VLMs) can respond to queries about images in many languages. However, beyond language, culture affects how we see things. For example, individuals from Western cultures focus more on the central figure in an image while individuals from Eastern cultures attend more to scene context. In this work, we present a novel investigation that demonstrates and localizes VLMs' Western bias in image understanding. We evaluate large VLMs across subjective and objective visual tasks with culturally diverse images and annotations. We find that VLMs perform better on the Western subset than the Eastern subset of each task. Controlled experimentation tracing the source of this bias highlights the importance of a diverse language mix in text-only pre-training for building equitable VLMs, even when inference is performed in English. Moreover, while prompting in the language of a target culture can lead to reductions in bias, it is not a substitute for building AI more representative of the world's languages.
6/18/2024
📉
No Filter: Cultural and Socioeconomic Diversityin Contrastive Vision-Language Models
Ang'eline Pouget, Lucas Beyer, Emanuele Bugliarello, Xiao Wang, Andreas Peter Steiner, Xiaohua Zhai, Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin
0
0
We study cultural and socioeconomic diversity in contrastive vision-language models (VLMs). Using a broad range of benchmark datasets and evaluation metrics, we bring to attention several important findings. First, the common filtering of training data to English image-text pairs disadvantages communities of lower socioeconomic status and negatively impacts cultural understanding. Notably, this performance gap is not captured by - and even at odds with - the currently popular evaluation metrics derived from the Western-centric ImageNet and COCO datasets. Second, pretraining with global, unfiltered data before fine-tuning on English content can improve cultural understanding without sacrificing performance on said popular benchmarks. Third, we introduce the task of geo-localization as a novel evaluation metric to assess cultural diversity in VLMs. Our work underscores the value of using diverse data to create more inclusive multimodal systems and lays the groundwork for developing VLMs that better represent global perspectives.
5/27/2024