HowToCaption: Prompting LLMs to Transform Video Annotations at Scale

Overview

• Instructional videos are a common source for learning text-video or multimodal representations
• Subtitles extracted from the audio signal using automatic speech recognition (ASR) provide noisy supervision for training text-video models
• This work proposes using large language models (LLMs) to generate high-quality video descriptions aligned with the video content at scale

Plain English Explanation

Instructional videos often have subtitles that are automatically generated from the audio. While these subtitles can be used to train models that combine text and video, the subtitles don't always match what's happening in the video. This can lead to poor performance when using the subtitles to train these models.

This paper suggests using powerful language models, called large language models (LLMs), to generate better video captions that are more aligned with the video content. The researchers developed a method to prompt the LLM to create plausible video captions based on the longer context of the subtitles, rather than just one sentence at a time. They also had the LLM generate timestamps for the captions so they could be aligned with the video.

This allowed them to create a new large-scale dataset of high-quality video captions without any human supervision. When they used this dataset to train text-video models, the models performed significantly better on standard benchmarks. The captions also helped the models differentiate the textual narration from the audio, improving their performance on tasks involving both text and audio.

Technical Explanation

The researchers proposed a method to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to generate high-quality video captions aligned with instructional videos at scale. Specifically, they prompt the LLM to create plausible video captions based on the ASR subtitles extracted from the audio signal in the videos.

To capture the contextual information beyond a single sentence, the prompting method takes into account the longer text of the subtitles. The researchers also prompt the LLM to generate timestamps for each produced caption based on the timestamps of the subtitles, and then align the generated captions to the video temporally.

This allowed them to obtain human-style video captions at scale without any human supervision. They applied this method to the HowTo100M dataset, creating a new large-scale dataset called HowToCaption.

Evaluation of the HowToCaption dataset shows that the resulting captions significantly improve performance on various text-video retrieval and video captioning benchmarks compared to using the original ASR subtitles. The captions also lead to a better disentanglement of textual narration from the audio, boosting performance on text-video-audio tasks.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that while their method can generate high-quality video captions at scale, there may still be some limitations or room for further improvement. For example, the captions generated by the LLM may not always perfectly match the visual content of the video, and there could be biases or inconsistencies introduced by the prompting process.

Additionally, the researchers did not conduct a detailed analysis of the specific failure cases or areas where the generated captions fall short. It would be helpful to understand the types of errors or shortcomings in the captions to identify opportunities for further refinement of the method.

Furthermore, the researchers did not explore the potential impact of the choice of LLM or the prompting strategy on the quality and alignment of the generated captions. Investigating these factors could lead to insights on how to further optimize the caption generation process.

Overall, the researchers have developed an innovative approach to leveraging the power of LLMs to address the limitations of using ASR subtitles for training text-video models. The resulting HowToCaption dataset represents a significant step forward in the field, but continued research and refinement could lead to even more robust and accurate video caption generation methods.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to leveraging large language models (LLMs) to generate high-quality video captions aligned with instructional videos at scale. By prompting the LLM to create captions based on the context of the ASR subtitles, and generating timestamps to align the captions with the video, the researchers were able to create a new large-scale dataset called HowToCaption without any human supervision.

The evaluation of the HowToCaption dataset shows that it can significantly improve the performance of text-video models on various benchmarks, compared to using the original ASR subtitles. The generated captions also help to better disentangle the textual narration from the audio, leading to improved performance on tasks involving both text and audio.

This work demonstrates the potential of LLMs to transform low-quality, noisy annotations into high-quality, contextually-relevant video descriptions at scale. As the field of multimodal learning continues to advance, techniques like the one presented in this paper will be crucial for building robust and versatile models that can effectively leverage the rich information available in instructional videos and other multimedia sources.