Hybridizing Target- and SHAP-encoded Features for Algorithm Selection in Mixed-variable Black-box Optimization
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach for algorithm selection in mixed-variable black-box optimization problems.
- The method combines target-encoded features and SHAP-encoded features to create a more informative and robust representation of the optimization problem.
- The authors evaluate their approach on a suite of benchmark problems and demonstrate improved performance compared to existing methods.
Plain English Explanation
When faced with a complex optimization problem, where the inputs can be a mix of continuous and discrete variables, it can be challenging to choose the right algorithm to solve the problem efficiently. Hybridizing Target- and SHAP-encoded Features for Algorithm Selection in Mixed-variable Black-box Optimization proposes a new way to help select the best algorithm for the job.
The key idea is to create a more informative representation of the optimization problem by combining two different types of features. The first type, called "target-encoded features," captures the relationship between the input variables and the objective function that we're trying to optimize. The second type, "SHAP-encoded features," provides information about how each input variable contributes to the overall objective.
By combining these two feature sets, the researchers were able to create a more comprehensive and robust description of the optimization problem. This, in turn, allowed them to train a machine learning model that could better predict which algorithm would work best for a given problem.
The researchers tested their approach on a variety of benchmark optimization problems, and found that it outperformed existing methods for algorithm selection. This suggests that their hybrid feature representation is a promising approach for tackling complex optimization challenges, where the inputs can be a mix of different types of variables.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel method for algorithm selection in mixed-variable black-box optimization problems. The authors propose a hybrid feature representation that combines target-encoded features and SHAP-encoded features.
Target-encoded features capture the relationship between the input variables and the objective function that is being optimized. SHAP-encoded features, on the other hand, provide information about the relative importance of each input variable in determining the objective function value.
By combining these two feature sets, the authors create a more comprehensive and informative representation of the optimization problem. This representation is then used to train a machine learning model that can predict the best algorithm to use for a given problem instance.
The authors evaluate their approach on a suite of benchmark mixed-variable optimization problems. They compare the performance of their hybrid feature representation to that of using target-encoded features or SHAP-encoded features alone. The results show that the hybrid approach outperforms the individual feature sets, demonstrating the value of combining these complementary sources of information.
Additionally, the authors investigate the stability of the SHAP-encoded features and propose a method to enhance their stability, further improving the robustness of the hybrid feature representation.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough investigation of the proposed hybrid feature representation for algorithm selection in mixed-variable black-box optimization. The authors have clearly identified a relevant problem and have developed a novel and innovative solution.
One potential limitation of the approach is that it relies on the availability of SHAP values, which can be computationally expensive to compute, especially for large-scale problems. The authors acknowledge this and propose a method to enhance the stability of the SHAP-encoded features, but this may still be a practical concern in some scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the interpretability of the hybrid feature representation. While the combination of target-encoded and SHAP-encoded features provides a more informative description of the optimization problem, it would be valuable to understand how these features can be interpreted by practitioners to gain insights into the problem structure and the algorithm selection process.
Overall, the paper presents a significant contribution to the field of mixed-variable black-box optimization and algorithm selection. The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach on benchmark problems and have provided a solid foundation for further research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel hybrid feature representation that combines target-encoded and SHAP-encoded features for algorithm selection in mixed-variable black-box optimization problems. The authors show that this approach outperforms using either feature set alone, resulting in improved performance on a suite of benchmark problems.
The key insights from this work are the value of integrating complementary sources of information (target-encoding and SHAP-encoding) to create a more comprehensive problem representation, and the importance of addressing the stability of SHAP-encoded features to ensure the robustness of the hybrid approach.
This research has important implications for practitioners and researchers working on complex optimization challenges, where the ability to select the most appropriate algorithm can significantly impact the efficiency and effectiveness of the optimization process. The hybrid feature representation proposed in this paper provides a promising direction for further advancements in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Hybridizing Target- and SHAP-encoded Features for Algorithm Selection in Mixed-variable Black-box Optimization
Konstantin Dietrich, Raphael Patrick Prager, Carola Doerr, Heike Trautmann
Exploratory landscape analysis (ELA) is a well-established tool to characterize optimization problems via numerical features. ELA is used for problem comprehension, algorithm design, and applications such as automated algorithm selection and configuration. Until recently, however, ELA was limited to search spaces with either continuous or discrete variables, neglecting problems with mixed variable types. This gap was addressed in a recent study that uses an approach based on target-encoding to compute exploratory landscape features for mixedvariable problems. In this work, we investigate an alternative encoding scheme based on SHAP values. While these features do not lead to better results in the algorithm selection setting considered in previous work, the two different encoding mechanisms exhibit complementary performance. Combining both feature sets into a hybrid approach outperforms each encoding mechanism individually. Finally, we experiment with two different ways of meta-selecting between the two feature sets. Both approaches are capable of taking advantage of the performance complementarity of the models trained on target-encoded and SHAP-encoded feature sets, respectively.
Read more7/11/2024
0
Deep-ELA: Deep Exploratory Landscape Analysis with Self-Supervised Pretrained Transformers for Single- and Multi-Objective Continuous Optimization Problems
Moritz Vinzent Seiler, Pascal Kerschke, Heike Trautmann
In many recent works, the potential of Exploratory Landscape Analysis (ELA) features to numerically characterize, in particular, single-objective continuous optimization problems has been demonstrated. These numerical features provide the input for all kinds of machine learning tasks on continuous optimization problems, ranging, i.a., from High-level Property Prediction to Automated Algorithm Selection and Automated Algorithm Configuration. Without ELA features, analyzing and understanding the characteristics of single-objective continuous optimization problems is -- to the best of our knowledge -- very limited. Yet, despite their usefulness, as demonstrated in several past works, ELA features suffer from several drawbacks. These include, in particular, (1.) a strong correlation between multiple features, as well as (2.) its very limited applicability to multi-objective continuous optimization problems. As a remedy, recent works proposed deep learning-based approaches as alternatives to ELA. In these works, e.g., point-cloud transformers were used to characterize an optimization problem's fitness landscape. However, these approaches require a large amount of labeled training data. Within this work, we propose a hybrid approach, Deep-ELA, which combines (the benefits of) deep learning and ELA features. Specifically, we pre-trained four transformers on millions of randomly generated optimization problems to learn deep representations of the landscapes of continuous single- and multi-objective optimization problems. Our proposed framework can either be used out-of-the-box for analyzing single- and multi-objective continuous optimization problems, or subsequently fine-tuned to various tasks focussing on algorithm behavior and problem understanding.
Read more7/30/2024
🤔
0
Succinct Interaction-Aware Explanations
Sascha Xu, Joscha Cuppers, Jilles Vreeken
SHAP is a popular approach to explain black-box models by revealing the importance of individual features. As it ignores feature interactions, SHAP explanations can be confusing up to misleading. NSHAP, on the other hand, reports the additive importance for all subsets of features. While this does include all interacting sets of features, it also leads to an exponentially sized, difficult to interpret explanation. In this paper, we propose to combine the best of these two worlds, by partitioning the features into parts that significantly interact, and use these parts to compose a succinct, interpretable, additive explanation. We derive a criterion by which to measure the representativeness of such a partition for a models behavior, traded off against the complexity of the resulting explanation. To efficiently find the best partition out of super-exponentially many, we show how to prune sub-optimal solutions using a statistical test, which not only improves runtime but also helps to detect spurious interactions. Experiments on synthetic and real world data show that our explanations are both more accurate resp. more easily interpretable than those of SHAP and NSHAP.
Read more4/22/2024
0
Neural Exploratory Landscape Analysis
Zeyuan Ma, Jiacheng Chen, Hongshu Guo, Yue-Jiao Gong
Recent research in Meta-Black-Box Optimization (MetaBBO) have shown that meta-trained neural networks can effectively guide the design of black-box optimizers, significantly reducing the need for expert tuning and delivering robust performance across complex problem distributions. Despite their success, a paradox remains: MetaBBO still rely on human-crafted Exploratory Landscape Analysis features to inform the meta-level agent about the low-level optimization progress. To address the gap, this paper proposes Neural Exploratory Landscape Analysis (NeurELA), a novel framework that dynamically profiles landscape features through a two-stage, attention-based neural network, executed in an entirely end-to-end fashion. NeurELA is pre-trained over a variety of MetaBBO algorithms using a multi-task neuroevolution strategy. Extensive experiments show that NeurELA achieves consistently superior performance when integrated into different and even unseen MetaBBO tasks and can be efficiently fine-tuned for further performance boost. This advancement marks a pivotal step in making MetaBBO algorithms more autonomous and broadly applicable.
Read more8/21/2024