Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms for Causal Structure and Representation Learning

Read original: arXiv:2406.14302 - Published 9/11/2024 by Patrik Reizinger, Siyuan Guo, Ferenc Husz'ar, Bernhard Scholkopf, Wieland Brendel

🎲

Overview

Identifying meaningful representations or causal structures in data is crucial for robust generalization and good performance on downstream tasks.
However, these two fields of representation learning and causal structure learning have largely developed independently.
The authors observe that several methods in both areas rely on the same data-generating process (DGP) - exchangeable but not i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed) data.
The authors propose a unified framework called "Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM)" to study representation and causal structure learning under the lens of exchangeability.
IEM provides new insights that allow relaxing the necessary conditions for causal structure identification in exchangeable non-i.i.d. data.
The authors also demonstrate the existence of a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new identifiability results.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on two key areas in machine learning: representation learning and causal structure learning. Representation learning is about finding meaningful ways to encode or summarize data, while causal structure learning is about understanding the underlying causal relationships in the data-generating process.

The authors note that these two fields have largely developed independently, even though they often rely on the same type of data - data that is exchangeable (the order doesn't matter) but not i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed).

To bridge this gap, the authors propose a unified framework called Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM). This framework provides new insights that allow relaxing the conditions needed to identify the causal structure in exchangeable non-i.i.d. data. It also reveals a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new results in this area.

Overall, the goal of this work is to pave the way for further research in the important area of causal representation learning, where the goal is to learn representations of data that capture the underlying causal structure.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM) framework, which provides a unified perspective on representation learning and causal structure learning. The authors observe that many methods in these two fields rely on the same data-generating process (DGP), namely, exchangeable but not i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed) data.

Using the IEM framework, the authors show new insights that relax the necessary conditions for causal structure identification in exchangeable non-i.i.d. data. Specifically, the authors demonstrate the existence of a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new identifiability results.

The authors also discuss the connections between causal representation learning and dynamical systems theory, highlighting potential synergies between these fields.

Overall, the IEM framework provides a principled way to study causal de Finetti identification and causally disentangled representation learning under the lens of exchangeability, with the goal of advancing the state of the art in causal representation learning.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising unified framework for representation learning and causal structure learning, but there are a few limitations and avenues for further research:

The IEM framework is primarily theoretical and may require further work to translate the insights into practical algorithms for real-world applications.
The authors acknowledge that the duality condition in identifiable representation learning may not hold in all cases, and more research is needed to understand the precise conditions under which it applies.
While the connections to dynamical systems theory are intriguing, the paper does not provide a deep dive into how these fields can be further integrated, leaving room for future work in this direction.
The paper focuses on exchangeable but not i.i.d. data, but many real-world datasets may exhibit more complex statistical properties that are not fully captured by this assumption.

Despite these caveats, this work represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between representation learning and causal structure learning, and the IEM framework provides a solid foundation for further research in the emerging field of causal representation learning.

Conclusion

The paper introduces the Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM) framework, which provides a unified perspective on representation learning and causal structure learning. The authors show that several methods in these two fields rely on the same data-generating process, namely, exchangeable but not i.i.d. data.

By studying representation and causal structure learning through the lens of exchangeability, the IEM framework provides new insights that relax the necessary conditions for causal structure identification in exchangeable non-i.i.d. data. The authors also demonstrate the existence of a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new identifiability results.

This work represents a significant step towards bridging the gap between representation learning and causal structure learning, paving the way for further research in the important field of causal representation learning. By leveraging the insights from this paper, future studies can continue to explore the synergies between these two disciplines and develop more robust and generalizable machine learning systems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🎲

Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms for Causal Structure and Representation Learning

Patrik Reizinger, Siyuan Guo, Ferenc Husz'ar, Bernhard Scholkopf, Wieland Brendel

Identifying latent representations or causal structures is important for good generalization and downstream task performance. However, both fields have been developed rather independently. We observe that several methods in both representation and causal structure learning rely on the same data-generating process (DGP), namely, exchangeable but not i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed) data. We provide a unified framework, termed Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM), for representation and structure learning under the lens of exchangeability. IEM provides new insights that let us relax the necessary conditions for causal structure identification in exchangeable non--i.i.d. data. We also demonstrate the existence of a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new identifiability results. We hope this work will pave the way for further research in causal representation learning.

9/11/2024

📊

Causal de Finetti: On the Identification of Invariant Causal Structure in Exchangeable Data

Siyuan Guo, Viktor T'oth, Bernhard Scholkopf, Ferenc Husz'ar

Constraint-based causal discovery methods leverage conditional independence tests to infer causal relationships in a wide variety of applications. Just as the majority of machine learning methods, existing work focuses on studying $textit{independent and identically distributed}$ data. However, it is known that even with infinite i.i.d.$ $ data, constraint-based methods can only identify causal structures up to broad Markov equivalence classes, posing a fundamental limitation for causal discovery. In this work, we observe that exchangeable data contains richer conditional independence structure than i.i.d.$ $ data, and show how the richer structure can be leveraged for causal discovery. We first present causal de Finetti theorems, which state that exchangeable distributions with certain non-trivial conditional independences can always be represented as $textit{independent causal mechanism (ICM)}$ generative processes. We then present our main identifiability theorem, which shows that given data from an ICM generative process, its unique causal structure can be identified through performing conditional independence tests. We finally develop a causal discovery algorithm and demonstrate its applicability to inferring causal relationships from multi-environment data. Our code and models are publicly available at: https://github.com/syguo96/Causal-de-Finetti

5/27/2024

📶

Learning Causally Disentangled Representations via the Principle of Independent Causal Mechanisms

Aneesh Komanduri, Yongkai Wu, Feng Chen, Xintao Wu

Learning disentangled causal representations is a challenging problem that has gained significant attention recently due to its implications for extracting meaningful information for downstream tasks. In this work, we define a new notion of causal disentanglement from the perspective of independent causal mechanisms. We propose ICM-VAE, a framework for learning causally disentangled representations supervised by causally related observed labels. We model causal mechanisms using nonlinear learnable flow-based diffeomorphic functions to map noise variables to latent causal variables. Further, to promote the disentanglement of causal factors, we propose a causal disentanglement prior learned from auxiliary labels and the latent causal structure. We theoretically show the identifiability of causal factors and mechanisms up to permutation and elementwise reparameterization. We empirically demonstrate that our framework induces highly disentangled causal factors, improves interventional robustness, and is compatible with counterfactual generation.

8/27/2024

Do Finetti: On Causal Effects for Exchangeable Data

Siyuan Guo, Chi Zhang, Karthika Mohan, Ferenc Husz'ar, Bernhard Scholkopf

We study causal effect estimation in a setting where the data are not i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed). We focus on exchangeable data satisfying an assumption of independent causal mechanisms. Traditional causal effect estimation frameworks, e.g., relying on structural causal models and do-calculus, are typically limited to i.i.d. data and do not extend to more general exchangeable generative processes, which naturally arise in multi-environment data. To address this gap, we develop a generalized framework for exchangeable data and introduce a truncated factorization formula that facilitates both the identification and estimation of causal effects in our setting. To illustrate potential applications, we introduce a causal P'olya urn model and demonstrate how intervention propagates effects in exchangeable data settings. Finally, we develop an algorithm that performs simultaneous causal discovery and effect estimation given multi-environment data.

5/30/2024