Improving behavior profile discovery for vehicles
0
📈
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new approach to mimic real driver behaviors in simulation.
- The approach is based solely on the exploration of undisturbed observation of intersections.
- From the observations, the behavior profiles for each macro-maneuver will be discovered.
- A comparison method between trajectories with different lengths using an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) is proposed.
- This is combined with an Expectation-Maximization (EM) inspired method to define the different clusters that represent the observed behaviors.
- A Kullback-Liebler divergent (KL) criteria is used to determine when the clusters need to be split or merged.
- The behaviors for each macro-maneuver are determined by each cluster discovered, without using any map information about the environment and being dynamically consistent with vehicle motion.
- The two main factors for driver's behavior are their assertiveness and interaction with other road users.
Plain English Explanation
The paper proposes a new way to mimic real driver behaviors in simulation. Instead of relying on pre-defined rules or models, the researchers focused on observing driver behavior at intersections. By watching how drivers naturally navigate these situations, they were able to discover the different behavior profiles that drivers exhibit.
To analyze these observed behaviors, the researchers used a combination of techniques. They compared the trajectories of different driver behaviors using an Extended Kalman Filter, and then applied an Expectation-Maximization inspired method to group the behaviors into distinct clusters. A Kullback-Liebler divergence metric was used to determine when those clusters should be split or merged.
The key insight from this work is that driver behavior is primarily influenced by two factors: their assertiveness and how they interact with other vehicles on the road. By understanding these underlying drivers of behavior, the researchers were able to model realistic driver actions without relying on detailed maps or vehicle dynamics models.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach to discover driver behavior profiles solely from observing undisturbed intersection scenarios. The researchers leverage the macro-maneuvers previously identified in the literature and introduce a comparison method using an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) to handle trajectories of different lengths.
This EKF-based comparison is combined with an Expectation-Maximization (EM) inspired method to define the different clusters that represent the observed driver behaviors. A Kullback-Liebler divergence (KL) criterion is then used to determine when these clusters should be split or merged.
The key contribution is that the discovered driver behavior profiles are determined solely from the observed data, without relying on any map information about the environment. Additionally, the behaviors are dynamically consistent with the vehicle's motion model.
The analysis reveals that the two primary factors influencing driver behavior are their assertiveness and their interaction with other road users.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and data-driven approach to modeling driver behaviors without relying on pre-defined rules or maps of the environment. By focusing on observing natural driver behavior, the researchers were able to discover the key factors that influence how people drive.
However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of this approach. For example, it's unclear how well the discovered behavior profiles would generalize to different driving environments or scenarios beyond the observed intersections. Additionally, the reliance on the EKF and EM techniques may have certain inherent biases or assumptions that could impact the fidelity of the resulting behavior models.
Further research could explore ways to validate the discovered behaviors against real-world driving data, or investigate how the approach could be extended to more complex driving environments and situations. Ultimately, while the proposed method is a promising step forward, there are still opportunities to refine and build upon this work to create even more realistic and comprehensive driver behavior models.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to mimicking real driver behaviors in simulation, based solely on the observation of undisturbed intersections. By discovering the key behavior profiles through a combination of EKF, EM, and KL divergence techniques, the researchers were able to model driver actions without relying on detailed maps or vehicle dynamics.
The crucial insight is that driver behavior is primarily influenced by their assertiveness and interaction with other road users. This understanding can lead to more realistic simulations of driver behavior and pave the way for further advancements in autonomous vehicle development and traffic modeling.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
0
Improving behavior profile discovery for vehicles
Nelson de Moura (ASTRA), Fawzi Nashashibi (ASTRA), Fernando Garrido
Multiple approaches have already been proposed to mimic real driver behaviors in simulation. This article proposes a new one, based solely on the exploration of undisturbed observation of intersections. From them, the behavior profiles for each macro-maneuver will be discovered. Using the macro-maneuvers already identified in previous works, a comparison method between trajectories with different lengths using an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) is proposed, which combined with an Expectation-Maximization (EM) inspired method, defines the different clusters that represent the behaviors observed. This is also paired with a Kullback-Liebler divergent (KL) criteria to define when the clusters need to be split or merged. Finally, the behaviors for each macro-maneuver are determined by each cluster discovered, without using any map information about the environment and being dynamically consistent with vehicle motion. By observation it becomes clear that the two main factors for driver's behavior are their assertiveness and interaction with other road users.
Read more9/25/2024
🔗
0
Fast maneuver recovery from aerial observation: trajectory clustering and outliers rejection
Nelson de Moura (ASTRA), Augustin Gervreau-Mercier (ASTRA), Fernando Garrido (ASTRA), Fawzi Nashashibi (ASTRA)
The implementation of road user models that realistically reproduce a credible behavior in a multi-agentsimulation is still an open problem. A data-driven approach consists on to deduce behaviors that may exist in real situation to obtain different types of trajectories from a large set of observations. The data, and its classification, could then be used to train models capable to extrapolate such behavior. Cars and two different types of Vulnerable Road Users (VRU) will be considered by the trajectory clustering methods proposed: pedestrians and cyclists. The results reported here evaluate methods to extract well-defined trajectory classes from raw data without the use of map information while also separating ''eccentric'' or incomplete trajectories from the ones that are complete and representative in any scenario. Two environments will serve as test for the methods develop, three different intersections and one roundabout. The resulting clusters of trajectories can then be used for prediction or learning tasks or discarded if it is composed by outliers.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Fast Long-Term Multi-Scenario Prediction for Maneuver Planning at Unsignalized Intersections
Max Bastian Mertens, Jona Ruof, Jan Strohbeck, Michael Buchholz
Motion prediction for intelligent vehicles typically focuses on estimating the most probable future evolutions of a traffic scenario. Estimating the gap acceptance, i.e., whether a vehicle merges or crosses before another vehicle with the right of way, is often handled implicitly in the prediction. However, an infrastructure-based maneuver planning can assign artificial priorities between cooperative vehicles, so it needs to evaluate many more potential scenarios. Additionally, the prediction horizon has to be long enough to assess the impact of a maneuver. We, therefore, present a novel long-term prediction approach handling the gap acceptance estimation and the velocity prediction in two separate stages. Thereby, the behavior of regular vehicles as well as priority assignments of cooperative vehicles can be considered. We train both stages on real-world traffic observations to achieve realistic prediction results. Our method has a competitive accuracy and is fast enough to predict a multitude of scenarios in a short time, making it suitable to be used in a maneuver planning framework.
Read more9/18/2024
0
Pedestrian Motion Prediction Using Transformer-based Behavior Clustering and Data-Driven Reachability Analysis
Kleio Fragkedaki, Frank J. Jiang, Karl H. Johansson, Jonas M{aa}rtensson
In this work, we present a transformer-based framework for predicting future pedestrian states based on clustered historical trajectory data. In previous studies, researchers propose enhancing pedestrian trajectory predictions by using manually crafted labels to categorize pedestrian behaviors and intentions. However, these approaches often only capture a limited range of pedestrian behaviors and introduce human bias into the predictions. To alleviate the dependency on manually crafted labels, we utilize a transformer encoder coupled with hierarchical density-based clustering to automatically identify diverse behavior patterns, and use these clusters in data-driven reachability analysis. By using a transformer-based approach, we seek to enhance the representation of pedestrian trajectories and uncover characteristics or features that are subsequently used to group trajectories into different behavior clusters. We show that these behavior clusters can be used with data-driven reachability analysis, yielding an end-to-end data-driven approach to predicting the future motion of pedestrians. We train and evaluate our approach on a real pedestrian dataset, showcasing its effectiveness in forecasting pedestrian movements.
Read more8/29/2024