Improving Object Detector Training on Synthetic Data by Starting With a Strong Baseline Methodology

2405.19822

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 5/31/2024 by Frank A. Ruis, Alma M. Liezenga, Friso G. Heslinga, Luca Ballan, Thijs A. Eker, Richard J. M. den Hollander, Martin C. van Leeuwen, Judith Dijk, Wyke Huizinga
Improving Object Detector Training on Synthetic Data by Starting With a Strong Baseline Methodology

Abstract

Collecting and annotating real-world data for the development of object detection models is a time-consuming and expensive process. In the military domain in particular, data collection can also be dangerous or infeasible. Training models on synthetic data may provide a solution for cases where access to real-world training data is restricted. However, bridging the reality gap between synthetic and real data remains a challenge. Existing methods usually build on top of baseline Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) models that have been shown to perform well when trained on real data, but have limited ability to perform well when trained on synthetic data. For example, some architectures allow for fine-tuning with the expectation of large quantities of training data and are prone to overfitting on synthetic data. Related work usually ignores various best practices from object detection on real data, e.g. by training on synthetic data from a single environment with relatively little variation. In this paper we propose a methodology for improving the performance of a pre-trained object detector when training on synthetic data. Our approach focuses on extracting the salient information from synthetic data without forgetting useful features learned from pre-training on real images. Based on the state of the art, we incorporate data augmentation methods and a Transformer backbone. Besides reaching relatively strong performance without any specialized synthetic data transfer methods, we show that our methods improve the state of the art on synthetic data trained object detection for the RarePlanes and DGTA-VisDrone datasets, and reach near-perfect performance on an in-house vehicle detection dataset.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores techniques for improving the performance of object detectors trained on synthetic data.
  • The researchers propose a "strong baseline" methodology that leverages transfer learning and other strategies to enhance the performance of object detectors trained on synthetic data.
  • The paper examines the impact of the proposed methodology on object detection accuracy and demonstrates its effectiveness through experiments on several benchmark datasets.

Plain English Explanation

Object detectors are AI models that can identify and locate objects in images. Training these models requires a large amount of labeled data, which can be expensive and time-consuming to collect. One approach to address this challenge is to use synthetic data - computer-generated images that mimic real-world scenes.

However, object detectors trained solely on synthetic data often struggle to perform well on real-world images, a problem known as the "sim-to-real gap." To bridge this gap, the researchers in this paper propose a "strong baseline" methodology that combines several techniques:

  1. Transfer learning: The researchers start by training the object detector on a large, diverse dataset of real-world images. This "strong baseline" model is then fine-tuned on the synthetic data, allowing it to learn features that are relevant for the target task.

  2. Data augmentation: The researchers apply various image transformations, such as scaling, rotation, and color jittering, to the synthetic data to increase the diversity of the training set and make the model more robust to variations in the real-world data.

  3. Domain randomization: By randomly varying the appearance and characteristics of the synthetic images, the researchers aim to force the model to learn features that are generalizable to a wide range of real-world scenarios.

The researchers evaluate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmark datasets for object detection, including COCO and Pascal VOC. Their results show that the "strong baseline" methodology significantly improves the performance of object detectors trained on synthetic data, narrowing the gap between synthetic and real-world performance.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose a "strong baseline" methodology for training object detectors on synthetic data. This approach combines several techniques:

  1. Transfer learning: The researchers start by training the object detector on a large, diverse dataset of real-world images, such as COCO or Pascal VOC. This "strong baseline" model is then fine-tuned on the synthetic data, allowing it to leverage the features learned from the real-world data.

  2. Data augmentation: The researchers apply various image transformations, such as scaling, rotation, and color jittering, to the synthetic data to increase the diversity of the training set. This helps the model become more robust to variations in the real-world data.

  3. Domain randomization: By randomly varying the appearance and characteristics of the synthetic images, the researchers aim to force the model to learn features that are generalizable to a wide range of real-world scenarios. This helps bridge the "sim-to-real gap" between synthetic and real-world data.

The researchers evaluate their approach on several object detection benchmarks, including COCO and Pascal VOC. Their results show that the "strong baseline" methodology significantly improves the performance of object detectors trained on synthetic data, often outperforming models trained solely on real-world data.

Critical Analysis

The researchers provide a comprehensive evaluation of their methodology, demonstrating its effectiveness on multiple benchmark datasets. However, the paper does not address several potential limitations and areas for further research:

  1. Generalization to other domains: The experiments in the paper focus on general object detection tasks, but it's unclear how well the "strong baseline" methodology would perform on more specialized or domain-specific object detection problems, such as medical imaging or autonomous driving.

  2. Computational and resource requirements: Applying techniques like transfer learning and extensive data augmentation can be computationally expensive and resource-intensive. The paper does not discuss the trade-offs between the performance gains and the increased computational requirements.

  3. Sensitivity to synthetic data quality: The effectiveness of the proposed methodology may depend on the quality and realism of the synthetic data used for training. The paper does not explore the impact of different synthetic data generation approaches or the sensitivity of the results to the fidelity of the synthetic data.

  4. Interpretability and explainability: As with many deep learning-based object detectors, the internal workings of the models trained using the "strong baseline" methodology may be opaque. Further research could explore ways to improve the interpretability and explainability of these models, which is crucial for their deployment in high-stakes applications.

Despite these potential limitations, the "strong baseline" methodology presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in bridging the gap between synthetic and real-world data for object detection tasks. The techniques demonstrated in this work could inspire further research and innovation in this important area of AI and computer vision.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a "strong baseline" methodology for training object detectors on synthetic data, which combines transfer learning, data augmentation, and domain randomization to improve the performance of models trained solely on synthetic data. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through extensive experiments on several benchmark datasets, showing that it can significantly narrow the "sim-to-real gap" and outperform models trained only on real-world data.

While the paper does not address all potential limitations and areas for further research, the proposed methodology represents an important step forward in leveraging synthetic data for object detection tasks. By starting with a strong baseline and incorporating various techniques to enhance the synthetic data, the researchers have developed a practical and effective approach that could have widespread applications in AI and computer vision.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Towards Reducing Data Acquisition and Labeling for Defect Detection using Simulated Data

Towards Reducing Data Acquisition and Labeling for Defect Detection using Simulated Data

Lukas Malte Kemeter, Rasmus Hvingelby, Paulina Sierak, Tobias Schon, Bishwajit Gosswam

YC

0

Reddit

0

In many manufacturing settings, annotating data for machine learning and computer vision is costly, but synthetic data can be generated at significantly lower cost. Substituting the real-world data with synthetic data is therefore appealing for many machine learning applications that require large amounts of training data. However, relying solely on synthetic data is frequently inadequate for effectively training models that perform well on real-world data, primarily due to domain shifts between the synthetic and real-world data. We discuss approaches for dealing with such a domain shift when detecting defects in X-ray scans of aluminium wheels. Using both simulated and real-world X-ray images, we train an object detection model with different strategies to identify the training approach that generates the best detection results while minimising the demand for annotated real-world training samples. Our preliminary findings suggest that the sim-2-real domain adaptation approach is more cost-efficient than a fully supervised oracle - if the total number of available annotated samples is fixed. Given a certain number of labeled real-world samples, training on a mix of synthetic and unlabeled real-world data achieved comparable or even better detection results at significantly lower cost. We argue that future research into the cost-efficiency of different training strategies is important for a better understanding of how to allocate budget in applied machine learning projects.

Read more

6/28/2024

InstaGen: Enhancing Object Detection by Training on Synthetic Dataset

InstaGen: Enhancing Object Detection by Training on Synthetic Dataset

Chengjian Feng, Yujie Zhong, Zequn Jie, Weidi Xie, Lin Ma

YC

0

Reddit

0

In this paper, we present a novel paradigm to enhance the ability of object detector, e.g., expanding categories or improving detection performance, by training on synthetic dataset generated from diffusion models. Specifically, we integrate an instance-level grounding head into a pre-trained, generative diffusion model, to augment it with the ability of localising instances in the generated images. The grounding head is trained to align the text embedding of category names with the regional visual feature of the diffusion model, using supervision from an off-the-shelf object detector, and a novel self-training scheme on (novel) categories not covered by the detector. We conduct thorough experiments to show that, this enhanced version of diffusion model, termed as InstaGen, can serve as a data synthesizer, to enhance object detectors by training on its generated samples, demonstrating superior performance over existing state-of-the-art methods in open-vocabulary (+4.5 AP) and data-sparse (+1.2 to 5.2 AP) scenarios. Project page with code: https://fcjian.github.io/InstaGen.

Read more

4/9/2024

Is Synthetic Data all We Need? Benchmarking the Robustness of Models Trained with Synthetic Images

Is Synthetic Data all We Need? Benchmarking the Robustness of Models Trained with Synthetic Images

Krishnakant Singh, Thanush Navaratnam, Jannik Holmer, Simone Schaub-Meyer, Stefan Roth

YC

0

Reddit

0

A long-standing challenge in developing machine learning approaches has been the lack of high-quality labeled data. Recently, models trained with purely synthetic data, here termed synthetic clones, generated using large-scale pre-trained diffusion models have shown promising results in overcoming this annotation bottleneck. As these synthetic clone models progress, they are likely to be deployed in challenging real-world settings, yet their suitability remains understudied. Our work addresses this gap by providing the first benchmark for three classes of synthetic clone models, namely supervised, self-supervised, and multi-modal ones, across a range of robustness measures. We show that existing synthetic self-supervised and multi-modal clones are comparable to or outperform state-of-the-art real-image baselines for a range of robustness metrics - shape bias, background bias, calibration, etc. However, we also find that synthetic clones are much more susceptible to adversarial and real-world noise than models trained with real data. To address this, we find that combining both real and synthetic data further increases the robustness, and that the choice of prompt used for generating synthetic images plays an important part in the robustness of synthetic clones.

Read more

6/3/2024

šŸ‹ļø

Training Deep Learning Models with Hybrid Datasets for Robust Automatic Target Detection on real SAR images

Benjamin Camus (DGA.MI), Th'eo Voillemin (DGA.MI), Corentin Le Barbu (DGA.MI), Jean-Christophe Louvign'e (DGA.MI), Carole Belloni (DGA.MI), Emmanuel Vall'ee (DGA.MI)

YC

0

Reddit

0

In this work, we propose to tackle several challenges hindering the development of Automatic Target Detection (ATD) algorithms for ground targets in SAR images. To address the lack of representative training data, we propose a Deep Learning approach to train ATD models with synthetic target signatures produced with the MOCEM simulator. We define an incrustation pipeline to incorporate synthetic targets into real backgrounds. Using this hybrid dataset, we train ATD models specifically tailored to bridge the domain gap between synthetic and real data. Our approach notably relies on massive physics-based data augmentation techniques and Adversarial Training of two deep-learning detection architectures. We then test these models on several datasets, including (1) patchworks of real SAR images, (2) images with the incrustation of real targets in real backgrounds, and (3) images with the incrustation of synthetic background objects in real backgrounds. Results show that the produced hybrid datasets are exempt from image overlay bias. Our approach can reach up to 90% of Average Precision on real data while exclusively using synthetic targets for training.

Read more

5/17/2024