Instances Need More Care: Rewriting Prompts for Instances with LLMs in the Loop Yields Better Zero-Shot Performance

Overview

• This paper explores how rewriting prompts for individual problem instances can improve the zero-shot performance of large language models (LLMs).
• The authors propose a prompt rewriting approach that tailors prompts to specific instances, rather than using a single generic prompt for all instances.
• They demonstrate that this instance-level prompt rewriting leads to significant performance gains on a variety of tasks compared to using a single generic prompt.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a common issue with using large language models (LLMs) for tasks in a "zero-shot" setting, where the model is asked to perform a task without any fine-tuning or specialized training. In these zero-shot scenarios, the performance of LLMs can sometimes be disappointing.

The key insight of this paper is that the way you phrase the instructions or "prompt" given to the LLM can have a big impact on its performance. Rather than using a single generic prompt for all problem instances, the authors show that rewriting the prompt to be more tailored to each specific instance can lead to much better results.

Imagine you're using an LLM to answer questions about a complex topic like astrophysics. If you give the model a vague, generic prompt, it may struggle to provide high-quality answers. But if you rephrase the prompt to be more specific to the particular question being asked, the model is much more likely to succeed.

The authors demonstrate this effect across a variety of tasks, showing that instance-level prompt rewriting consistently outperforms using a single generic prompt. This suggests that the way we communicate with and instruct these powerful language models is just as important as the models themselves.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by providing background on the challenge of using LLMs in zero-shot settings, where the model is asked to perform a task without any fine-tuning or specialized training. The authors note that despite the impressive capabilities of LLMs, their performance can sometimes be suboptimal in these zero-shot scenarios.

To address this, the authors propose a prompt rewriting approach that tailors the instructions or "prompt" given to the LLM for each individual problem instance, rather than using a single generic prompt for all instances. The key steps of their method are:

1. Defining a base prompt that captures the overall task.
2. Automatically rewriting this base prompt to be more specific to each individual instance, using techniques like paraphrasing and expanding on key details.
3. Feeding the rewritten instance-specific prompt to the LLM to generate the final output.

Through extensive experiments across a range of benchmark tasks, the authors demonstrate that this instance-level prompt rewriting approach consistently outperforms using a single generic prompt. They attribute this performance boost to the LLM being able to better understand and reason about the specific problem at hand when provided with a more tailored prompt.

The authors also analyze the types of prompt rewrites that are most effective, finding that techniques like adding more context, rephrasing the instructions, and expanding on key details tend to be especially helpful.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of prompt engineering when working with LLMs in zero-shot settings. The authors provide a clear and rigorous experimental setup, thoroughly evaluating their approach across a diverse set of tasks.

One potential limitation is that the prompt rewriting process is currently done manually, which may limit its scalability. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that developing automated prompt rewriting techniques could be an interesting area for future research.

Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of instance-level prompt rewriting, it does not explore the underlying reasons for this phenomenon in depth. Further investigation into the cognitive and architectural factors that make LLMs responsive to prompt changes could lead to additional insights.

Overall, this paper makes an important contribution by highlighting the crucial role of prompts in leveraging the capabilities of LLMs. The findings suggest that investing time and effort into prompt engineering may be a highly effective way to improve the performance of these models, especially in zero-shot scenarios.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for improving the zero-shot performance of large language models (LLMs) by rewriting prompts at the instance level. The key insight is that tailoring the instructions or "prompt" given to the LLM for each specific problem instance can lead to much better results than using a single generic prompt.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their instance-level prompt rewriting approach across a variety of benchmark tasks, consistently outperforming the use of a single generic prompt. This work highlights the importance of prompt engineering when working with powerful language models, and suggests that investing time and effort into crafting high-quality prompts may be a highly impactful way to unlock the full potential of these models.

The findings of this paper have broader implications for the field of AI, underscoring the need to carefully consider the way we communicate with and instruct these language models. As LLMs become increasingly ubiquitous, developing techniques like instance-level prompt rewriting may be crucial for ensuring they can be reliably and effectively deployed in real-world applications.