Integrating AI in College Education: Positive yet Mixed Experiences with ChatGPT
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the integration of AI, specifically ChatGPT, in college education, examining both the positive and mixed experiences of its usage.
- The researchers conducted a survey to gather insights from college students and instructors on their perceptions and experiences with ChatGPT.
- The findings highlight the potential benefits of ChatGPT in enhancing learning and productivity, as well as the challenges related to academic integrity and ethical considerations.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses the use of the AI chatbot ChatGPT in college education. The researchers wanted to understand how students and professors are experiencing the integration of this technology into the classroom.
They conducted a survey to gather feedback from both groups. The results show that there are some positive aspects to using ChatGPT, such as improving learning and productivity. However, there are also challenges, like concerns about academic integrity and ethical considerations around the use of AI in education.
The paper aims to provide a balanced perspective on the integration of ChatGPT, highlighting both the potential benefits and the real-world challenges that need to be addressed.
Technical Explanation
The researchers used a survey-based approach to gather data from college students and instructors on their experiences with integrating ChatGPT into their academic work and teaching, respectively. They designed the survey to explore perceptions, usage patterns, and the perceived impacts of ChatGPT on various aspects of the educational process.
The survey included questions on the frequency and purposes of ChatGPT usage, the perceived benefits and drawbacks of the technology, and the strategies employed to address any issues or concerns. The researchers also collected demographic information to analyze potential differences in experiences based on factors such as academic discipline, level of study, and teaching experience.
The findings suggest that while ChatGPT has the potential to enhance programming education and serve as an intelligent tutor, there are also significant concerns regarding academic integrity and the ethical implications of its use in educational settings. The paper discusses the need for clear policies, guidelines, and educational interventions to address these challenges effectively.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a balanced and comprehensive analysis of the integration of ChatGPT in college education, acknowledging both the potential benefits and the challenges that need to be addressed. The survey-based methodology offers valuable insights into the real-world experiences and perceptions of students and instructors, which can inform future research and policy decisions.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific strategies or best practices that institutions can adopt to effectively leverage ChatGPT while maintaining academic integrity. Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential long-term implications of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT on the broader educational ecosystem and the skills that students may need to develop in the future.
Further research could investigate the effectiveness of various interventions, such as educational programs or assessment methods, in addressing the ethical and academic integrity concerns raised in the paper. Longitudinal studies could also provide valuable insights into the evolving role of AI assistants like ChatGPT in the educational landscape.
Conclusion
This paper offers a nuanced perspective on the integration of ChatGPT in college education, highlighting both the positive and mixed experiences reported by students and instructors. While the technology presents opportunities for enhanced learning and productivity, the study also underscores the need to address significant concerns around academic integrity and ethical considerations.
The findings emphasize the importance of developing clear policies, guidelines, and educational interventions to ensure the responsible and effective use of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT in academic settings. As the adoption of these technologies continues to grow, ongoing research and dialogue will be crucial in shaping the future of education and ensuring that it remains equitable, engaging, and aligned with the evolving needs of students and society.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Integrating AI in College Education: Positive yet Mixed Experiences with ChatGPT
Xinrui Song, Jiajin Zhang, Pingkun Yan, Juergen Hahn, Uwe Kruger, Hisham Mohamed, Ge Wang
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots into higher education marks a shift towards a new generation of pedagogical tools, mirroring the arrival of milestones like the internet. With the launch of ChatGPT-4 Turbo in November 2023, we developed a ChatGPT-based teaching application (https://chat.openai.com/g/g-1imx1py4K-chatge-medical-imaging) and integrated it into our undergraduate medical imaging course in the Spring 2024 semester. This study investigates the use of ChatGPT throughout a semester-long trial, providing insights into students' engagement, perception, and the overall educational effectiveness of the technology. We systematically collected and analyzed data concerning students' interaction with ChatGPT, focusing on their attitudes, concerns, and usage patterns. The findings indicate that ChatGPT offers significant advantages such as improved information access and increased interactivity, but its adoption is accompanied by concerns about the accuracy of the information provided and the necessity for well-defined guidelines to optimize its use.
Read more7/9/2024
🌐
0
ChatGPT Is Here to Help, Not to Replace Anybody -- An Evaluation of Students' Opinions On Integrating ChatGPT In CS Courses
Bruno Pereira Cipriano, Pedro Alves
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT and Bard are capable of producing code based on textual descriptions, with remarkable efficacy. Such technology will have profound implications for computing education, raising concerns about cheating, excessive dependence, and a decline in computational thinking skills, among others. There has been extensive research on how teachers should handle this challenge but it is also important to understand how students feel about this paradigm shift. In this research, 52 first-year CS students were surveyed in order to assess their views on technologies with code-generation capabilities, both from academic and professional perspectives. Our findings indicate that while students generally favor the academic use of GPT, they don't over rely on it, only mildly asking for its help. Although most students benefit from GPT, some struggle to use it effectively, urging the need for specific GPT training. Opinions on GPT's impact on their professional lives vary, but there is a consensus on its importance in academic practice.
Read more4/29/2024
🤖
0
The AI Companion in Education: Analyzing the Pedagogical Potential of ChatGPT in Computer Science and Engineering
Zhangying He, Thomas Nguyen, Tahereh Miari, Mehrdad Aliasgari, Setareh Rafatirad, Hossein Sayadi
Artificial Intelligence (AI), with ChatGPT as a prominent example, has recently taken center stage in various domains including higher education, particularly in Computer Science and Engineering (CSE). The AI revolution brings both convenience and controversy, offering substantial benefits while lacking formal guidance on their application. The primary objective of this work is to comprehensively analyze the pedagogical potential of ChatGPT in CSE education, understanding its strengths and limitations from the perspectives of educators and learners. We employ a systematic approach, creating a diverse range of educational practice problems within CSE field, focusing on various subjects such as data science, programming, AI, machine learning, networks, and more. According to our examinations, certain question types, like conceptual knowledge queries, typically do not pose significant challenges to ChatGPT, and thus, are excluded from our analysis. Alternatively, we focus our efforts on developing more in-depth and personalized questions and project-based tasks. These questions are presented to ChatGPT, followed by interactions to assess its effectiveness in delivering complete and meaningful responses. To this end, we propose a comprehensive five-factor reliability analysis framework to evaluate the responses. This assessment aims to identify when ChatGPT excels and when it faces challenges. Our study concludes with a correlation analysis, delving into the relationships among subjects, task types, and limiting factors. This analysis offers valuable insights to enhance ChatGPT's utility in CSE education, providing guidance to educators and students regarding its reliability and efficacy.
Read more7/9/2024
📉
0
ChatGPT in Classrooms: Transforming Challenges into Opportunities in Education
Harris Bin Munawar, Nikolaos Misirlis
In the era of exponential technology growth, one unexpected guest has claimed a seat in classrooms worldwide, Artificial Intelligence. Generative AI, such as ChatGPT, promises a revolution in education, yet it arrives with a double-edged sword. Its potential for personalized learning is offset by issues of cheating, inaccuracies, and educators struggling to incorporate it effectively into their lesson design. We are standing on the brink of this educational frontier, and it is clear that we need to navigate this terrain with a lot of care. This is a major challenge that could undermine the integrity and value of our educational process. So, how can we turn these challenges into opportunities? When used inappropriately, AI tools can become the perfect tool for the cut copy paste mentality, and quickly begin to corrode critical thinking, creativity, and deep understanding, the most important skills in our rapidly changing world. Teachers feel that they are not equipped to leverage this technology, widening the digital divide among educators and institutions. Addressing these concerns calls for an in depth research approach. We will employ empirical research, drawing on the Technology Acceptance Model, to assess the attitudes toward generative AI among educators and students. Understanding their perceptions, usage patterns, and hurdles is the first crucial step in creating an effective solution. The present study will be used as a process manual for future researchers to apply, running their own data, based on the steps explained here
Read more5/20/2024