Interpretable Multimodal Misinformation Detection with Logic Reasoning
0
🔎
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Online misinformation is a growing problem, especially when it includes multimedia content like images and videos
- Existing approaches for detecting multimodal misinformation have high performance but lack interpretability
- This paper proposes a new model that combines neural networks and symbolic logic to provide both high performance and interpretability
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new approach for detecting misinformation that is shared online, especially when it includes a mix of text, images, and videos. Compared to text-only information, multimedia content can seem more credible and spread more easily on social media.
While current techniques for detecting this type of multimodal misinformation work well, they are like "black boxes" - it's hard to understand how they make their decisions. This lack of interpretability makes these systems less reliable and harder to use in practice.
The researchers were inspired by an approach called Neural-Symbolic AI, which combines the powerful learning abilities of neural networks with the clarity of symbolic logic. Their new model uses neural networks to automatically generate and evaluate logical rules that explain the reasoning behind its decisions on detecting misinformation.
Additionally, the model is designed to work across different sources of misinformation, not just one specific platform. Experiments on several public datasets show that this approach is both effective and flexible.
Technical Explanation
The core of the proposed model is a logic-based neural network that integrates interpretable logical clauses to express the reasoning behind multimodal misinformation detection. To enable effective learning, the model parameterizes the symbolic logical elements using neural representations, which allows for the automatic generation and evaluation of meaningful logic clauses.
To make the framework generalizable across diverse misinformation sources, the researchers introduce five "meta-predicates" that can be instantiated with different correlations. These meta-predicates capture various relationships between the text, images, and other modalities that could indicate misinformation.
The model is evaluated on three public datasets (Twitter, Weibo, and Sarcasm) and demonstrates strong performance compared to existing approaches, while also providing interpretable explanations for its decisions.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that while the proposed model achieves high accuracy, there are still some limitations. For example, the meta-predicates used in the model may not capture all the nuanced relationships that could signal misinformation, and the model's performance may vary depending on the specific dataset and domain.
Additionally, the paper does not extensively explore the tradeoffs between interpretability and performance - it's possible that the interpretable logical rules come at the cost of some predictive power compared to more opaque neural network models.
Further research could investigate ways to expand the set of meta-predicates, explore techniques for automatically discovering relevant logical rules, and conduct more thorough comparisons to state-of-the-art misinformation detection methods. Integrating this approach with broader fact-checking and content moderation workflows could also be an interesting direction.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel logic-based neural model for detecting multimodal misinformation that combines the learning power of neural networks with the interpretability of symbolic logic. By automatically generating and evaluating logical rules, the model provides transparency into its decision-making process, which could improve its reliability and practical deployment.
The versatility of the approach, demonstrated across multiple datasets, suggests it could be a valuable tool for combating the growing problem of online misinformation. As social media platforms continue to grapple with the spread of misleading multimedia content, interpretable AI systems like this one may play an important role in preserving the integrity of online information.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
0
New!Interpretable Multimodal Misinformation Detection with Logic Reasoning
Hui Liu, Wenya Wang, Haoliang Li
Multimodal misinformation on online social platforms is becoming a critical concern due to increasing credibility and easier dissemination brought by multimedia content, compared to traditional text-only information. While existing multimodal detection approaches have achieved high performance, the lack of interpretability hinders these systems' reliability and practical deployment. Inspired by NeuralSymbolic AI which combines the learning ability of neural networks with the explainability of symbolic learning, we propose a novel logic-based neural model for multimodal misinformation detection which integrates interpretable logic clauses to express the reasoning process of the target task. To make learning effective, we parameterize symbolic logical elements using neural representations, which facilitate the automatic generation and evaluation of meaningful logic clauses. Additionally, to make our framework generalizable across diverse misinformation sources, we introduce five meta-predicates that can be instantiated with different correlations. Results on three public datasets (Twitter, Weibo, and Sarcasm) demonstrate the feasibility and versatility of our model.
Read more9/17/2024
🔎
0
Interpretable Detection of Out-of-Context Misinformation with Neural-Symbolic-Enhanced Large Multimodal Model
Yizhou Zhang, Loc Trinh, Defu Cao, Zijun Cui, Yan Liu
Recent years have witnessed the sustained evolution of misinformation that aims at manipulating public opinions. Unlike traditional rumors or fake news editors who mainly rely on generated and/or counterfeited images, text and videos, current misinformation creators now more tend to use out-of-context multimedia contents (e.g. mismatched images and captions) to deceive the public and fake news detection systems. This new type of misinformation increases the difficulty of not only detection but also clarification, because every individual modality is close enough to true information. To address this challenge, in this paper we explore how to achieve interpretable cross-modal de-contextualization detection that simultaneously identifies the mismatched pairs and the cross-modal contradictions, which is helpful for fact-check websites to document clarifications. The proposed model first symbolically disassembles the text-modality information to a set of fact queries based on the Abstract Meaning Representation of the caption and then forwards the query-image pairs into a pre-trained large vision-language model select the ``evidences that are helpful for us to detect misinformation. Extensive experiments indicate that the proposed methodology can provide us with much more interpretable predictions while maintaining the accuracy same as the state-of-the-art model on this task.
Read more4/9/2024
👀
0
Detecting Misinformation in Multimedia Content through Cross-Modal Entity Consistency: A Dual Learning Approach
Zhe Fu, Kanlun Wang, Wangjiaxuan Xin, Lina Zhou, Shi Chen, Yaorong Ge, Daniel Janies, Dongsong Zhang
The landscape of social media content has evolved significantly, extending from text to multimodal formats. This evolution presents a significant challenge in combating misinformation. Previous research has primarily focused on single modalities or text-image combinations, leaving a gap in detecting multimodal misinformation. While the concept of entity consistency holds promise in detecting multimodal misinformation, simplifying the representation to a scalar value overlooks the inherent complexities of high-dimensional representations across different modalities. To address these limitations, we propose a Multimedia Misinformation Detection (MultiMD) framework for detecting misinformation from video content by leveraging cross-modal entity consistency. The proposed dual learning approach allows for not only enhancing misinformation detection performance but also improving representation learning of entity consistency across different modalities. Our results demonstrate that MultiMD outperforms state-of-the-art baseline models and underscore the importance of each modality in misinformation detection. Our research provides novel methodological and technical insights into multimodal misinformation detection.
Read more9/4/2024
0
MMIDR: Teaching Large Language Model to Interpret Multimodal Misinformation via Knowledge Distillation
Longzheng Wang, Xiaohan Xu, Lei Zhang, Jiarui Lu, Yongxiu Xu, Hongbo Xu, Minghao Tang, Chuang Zhang
Automatic detection of multimodal misinformation has gained a widespread attention recently. However, the potential of powerful Large Language Models (LLMs) for multimodal misinformation detection remains underexplored. Besides, how to teach LLMs to interpret multimodal misinformation in cost-effective and accessible way is still an open question. To address that, we propose MMIDR, a framework designed to teach LLMs in providing fluent and high-quality textual explanations for their decision-making process of multimodal misinformation. To convert multimodal misinformation into an appropriate instruction-following format, we present a data augmentation perspective and pipeline. This pipeline consists of a visual information processing module and an evidence retrieval module. Subsequently, we prompt the proprietary LLMs with processed contents to extract rationales for interpreting the authenticity of multimodal misinformation. Furthermore, we design an efficient knowledge distillation approach to distill the capability of proprietary LLMs in explaining multimodal misinformation into open-source LLMs. To explore several research questions regarding the performance of LLMs in multimodal misinformation detection tasks, we construct an instruction-following multimodal misinformation dataset and conduct comprehensive experiments. The experimental findings reveal that our MMIDR exhibits sufficient detection performance and possesses the capacity to provide compelling rationales to support its assessments.
Read more4/9/2024