Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps for Interpretable Image Classification

Read original: arXiv:2408.03745 - Published 8/9/2024 by Georgia Sovatzidi, Michael D. Vasilakakis, Dimitris K. Iakovidis

🖼️

Overview

Machine learning model interpretability is crucial for user trust
Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (iFCMs) can assess model output quality through hesitancy estimation
This paper introduces Interpretable Intuitionistic FCM (I2FCM) to make CNN models interpretable for image classification

Plain English Explanation

Interpretable machine learning is important because people may be hesitant to rely on the decisions made by complex AI models if they can't understand how those decisions were reached. This paper proposes using a type of fuzzy logic model called Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (iFCMs) to make Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) more interpretable for image classification tasks.

iFCMs can estimate a degree of "hesitancy" in the model's classifications, similar to how humans sometimes feel unsure about their decisions. By analyzing this hesitancy, the model can reveal the most important aspects of the image that led to its classification. This helps users understand the model's reasoning.

The paper introduces a new framework called Interpretable Intuitionistic FCM (I2FCM) that applies iFCMs to CNN models. It also includes novel contributions like a process to focus on the most informative image regions and a learning algorithm to determine the relationships between different image features.

The key benefit of I2FCM is that it can provide more accurate and interpretable image classifications compared to standard CNN models. This allows users to better understand and trust the model's decisions.

Technical Explanation

The Interpretable Intuitionistic FCM (I2FCM) framework combines Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) with Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (iFCMs) to make image classification models more interpretable.

The feature extraction process focuses on the most informative regions of the input image. A learning algorithm is used to determine the intuitionistic fuzzy interconnections between these informative image features within the iFCM model.

The iFCM model then distinguishes the most representative image semantics and analyzes them using cause-and-effect relationships. This allows the model to provide inherently interpretable classifications based on the image contents.

In the context of image classification, the hesitancy estimated by the iFCM represents the degree of uncertainty or inconfidence with which the model categorizes the image to a particular class.

The effectiveness of the I2FCM framework is evaluated on publicly available datasets, and the results confirm that it can improve classification performance while providing interpretable inferences.

Critical Analysis

The paper introduces a novel and promising approach to making CNN-based image classification models more interpretable through the use of iFCMs. The ability to estimate model hesitancy and analyze the underlying image features and their relationships is a valuable contribution.

However, the paper does not provide a thorough discussion of the potential limitations or caveats of the I2FCM framework. For example, it's unclear how the framework would scale to more complex or diverse image classification tasks, or how sensitive the performance is to the choice of hyperparameters and other design decisions.

Additionally, while the experimental results demonstrate improved performance and interpretability, more rigorous comparisons to other interpretable AI techniques, such as self-supervised concept-based models or intrinsic user-centric interpretability methods, would help contextualize the contributions of the I2FCM approach.

Overall, the paper presents a novel and potentially valuable framework for making CNN-based image classification models more interpretable, but further research is needed to fully understand its capabilities, limitations, and practical implications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces the Interpretable Intuitionistic FCM (I2FCM) framework, which combines Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) with Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (iFCMs) to make image classification models more interpretable.

The key innovation is the ability to estimate model "hesitancy" and analyze the underlying image features and their relationships, providing users with a better understanding of how the model arrives at its classifications. The experimental results demonstrate improved performance and interpretability compared to standard CNN models.

While the paper presents a promising approach, further research is needed to fully explore the limitations, scalability, and practical applications of the I2FCM framework. Nonetheless, this work contributes to the growing field of interpretable AI and could have important implications for enhancing user trust and transparency in image classification systems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🖼️

Intuitionistic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps for Interpretable Image Classification

Georgia Sovatzidi, Michael D. Vasilakakis, Dimitris K. Iakovidis

The interpretability of machine learning models is critical, as users may be reluctant to rely on their inferences. Intuitionistic FCMs (iFCMs) have been proposed as an extension of FCMs offering a natural mechanism to assess the quality of their output through the estimation of hesitancy, a concept resembling to human hesitation in decision making. To address the challenge of interpretable image classification, this paper introduces a novel framework, named Interpretable Intuitionistic FCM (I2FCM) which is domain-independent, simple to implement, and can be applied on Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) models, rendering them interpretable. To the best of our knowledge this is the first time iFCMs are applied for image classification. Further novel contributions include: a feature extraction process focusing on the most informative image regions; a learning algorithm for data-driven determination of the intuitionistic fuzzy interconnections of the iFCM; an inherently interpretable classification approach based on image contents. In the context of image classification, hesitancy is considered as a degree of inconfidence with which an image is categorized to a class. The constructed iFCM model distinguishes the most representative image semantics and analyses them utilizing cause-and-effect relations. The effectiveness of the introduced framework is evaluated on publicly available datasets, and the experimental results confirm that it can provide enhanced classification performance, while providing interpretable inferences.

8/9/2024

Advancing Explainable AI with Causal Analysis in Large-Scale Fuzzy Cognitive Maps

Marios Tyrovolas, Nikolaos D. Kallimanis, Chrysostomos Stylios

In the quest for accurate and interpretable AI models, eXplainable AI (XAI) has become crucial. Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (FCMs) stand out as an advanced XAI method because of their ability to synergistically combine and exploit both expert knowledge and data-driven insights, providing transparency and intrinsic interpretability. This letter introduces and investigates the Total Causal Effect Calculation for FCMs (TCEC-FCM) algorithm, an innovative approach that, for the first time, enables the efficient calculation of total causal effects among concepts in large-scale FCMs by leveraging binary search and graph traversal techniques, thereby overcoming the challenge of exhaustive causal path exploration that hinder existing methods. We evaluate the proposed method across various synthetic FCMs that demonstrate TCEC-FCM's superior performance over exhaustive methods, marking a significant advancement in causal effect analysis within FCMs, thus broadening their usability for modern complex XAI applications.

5/16/2024

Self-supervised Interpretable Concept-based Models for Text Classification

Francesco De Santis, Philippe Bich, Gabriele Ciravegna, Pietro Barbiero, Danilo Giordano, Tania Cerquitelli

Despite their success, Large-Language Models (LLMs) still face criticism as their lack of interpretability limits their controllability and reliability. Traditional post-hoc interpretation methods, based on attention and gradient-based analysis, offer limited insight into the model's decision-making processes. In the image field, Concept-based models have emerged as explainable-by-design architectures, employing human-interpretable features as intermediate representations. However, these methods have not been yet adapted to textual data, mainly because they require expensive concept annotations, which are impractical for real-world text data. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a self-supervised Interpretable Concept Embedding Models (ICEMs). We leverage the generalization abilities of LLMs to predict the concepts labels in a self-supervised way, while we deliver the final predictions with an interpretable function. The results of our experiments show that ICEMs can be trained in a self-supervised way achieving similar performance to fully supervised concept-based models and end-to-end black-box ones. Additionally, we show that our models are (i) interpretable, offering meaningful logical explanations for their predictions; (ii) interactable, allowing humans to modify intermediate predictions through concept interventions; and (iii) controllable, guiding the LLMs' decoding process to follow a required decision-making path.

6/21/2024

InterpretCC: Intrinsic User-Centric Interpretability through Global Mixture of Experts

Vinitra Swamy, Syrielle Montariol, Julian Blackwell, Jibril Frej, Martin Jaggi, Tanja Kaser

Interpretability for neural networks is a trade-off between three key requirements: 1) faithfulness of the explanation (i.e., how perfectly it explains the prediction), 2) understandability of the explanation by humans, and 3) model performance. Most existing methods compromise one or more of these requirements; e.g., post-hoc approaches provide limited faithfulness, automatically identified feature masks compromise understandability, and intrinsically interpretable methods such as decision trees limit model performance. These shortcomings are unacceptable for sensitive applications such as education and healthcare, which require trustworthy explanations, actionable interpretations, and accurate predictions. In this work, we present InterpretCC (interpretable conditional computation), a family of interpretable-by-design neural networks that guarantee human-centric interpretability, while maintaining comparable performance to state-of-the-art models by adaptively and sparsely activating features before prediction. We extend this idea into an interpretable, global mixture-of-experts (MoE) model that allows humans to specify topics of interest, discretely separates the feature space for each data point into topical subnetworks, and adaptively and sparsely activates these topical subnetworks for prediction. We apply variations of the InterpretCC architecture for text, time series and tabular data across several real-world benchmarks, demonstrating comparable performance with non-interpretable baselines, outperforming interpretable-by-design baselines, and showing higher actionability and usefulness according to a user study.

5/30/2024