Investigating impact of bit-flip errors in control electronics on quantum computation

Overview

• This paper investigates the impact of bit flip errors in FPGA memories on quantum computing systems.
• FPGA memories are crucial for storing the amplitude and phase information of quantum gate pulses.
• These memories can experience faults due to physical and environmental factors, potentially leading to errors in quantum gate operations.
• The researchers conducted experiments to introduce bit flips into the amplitude and phase values of quantum pulses using IBM's simulated quantum environments.
• The findings reveal that bit flips in the exponent and initial mantissa bits of the real amplitude cause substantial deviations in quantum gate operations.
• The researchers propose a 3-bit repetition error correction code to mitigate these errors.

Plain English Explanation

Quantum computers rely on specialized hardware, including FPGA memories, to store the information needed to generate quantum gate pulses. Unfortunately, these memories can experience errors, or "bit flips," due to factors like electromagnetic interference or power fluctuations. When these errors occur, it can disrupt the quantum computations and lead to incorrect results.

To understand how these bit flip errors affect quantum computing, the researchers ran a series of experiments using IBM's simulated quantum environments. They introduced bit flips into the amplitude and phase values of the quantum pulses and observed the impact on the computations. Their findings showed that the most significant bits, the exponent and initial mantissa bits, were particularly sensitive to errors, causing substantial deviations in the quantum gate operations.

To address this issue, the researchers proposed a 3-bit repetition error correction code. This approach involves storing each bit three times, so that if one bit is flipped, the other two can be used to correct it. This effectively reduced the impact of the bit flip errors, keeping the deviations in quantum gate operations below 40%. However, this error correction does come with a small memory overhead, as some of the memory space is used for the redundant bits.

Technical Explanation

The researchers conducted a series of experiments to investigate the impact of bit flip errors in FPGA memories on quantum computing systems. FPGA memories are integral in storing the amplitude and phase information of the pulse envelopes, which are essential for generating quantum gate pulses. However, these memories can incur faults due to physical and environmental stressors, such as electromagnetic interference, power fluctuations, and temperature variations, as well as adversarial fault injections, potentially leading to errors in quantum gate operations.

To understand how these faults affect quantum computations, the researchers used IBM's simulated quantum environments, FakeValencia, FakeManila, and FakeLima, to introduce bit flips into the amplitude (both real and imaginary components) and phase values of quantum pulses.

Their findings reveal that bit flips in the exponent and initial mantissa bits of the real amplitude cause substantial deviations in quantum gate operations, with total variation distance (TVD) increases as high as ~200%. Interestingly, the remaining bits exhibited natural tolerance to errors.

To mitigate these errors, the researchers proposed a 3-bit repetition error correction code, which effectively reduced the TVD increases to below 40% without incurring any memory overhead. However, due to the reuse of less significant bits for error correction, the proposed approach introduces a maximum of 5-7% extra TVD in nominal cases. This can be avoided by sacrificing memory area for implementing the repetition code.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides valuable insights into the impact of bit flip errors in FPGA memories on quantum computing systems. The researchers' experimental approach using IBM's simulated quantum environments is well-designed and provides a systematic way to understand the effects of these errors on quantum computations.

One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses solely on bit flip errors and does not consider other types of faults, such as stuck-at faults or more complex multi-bit errors. Averting multi-qubit burst errors in surface code and Quantum tunneling: from theory to error-mitigated may provide additional perspectives on addressing various error types in quantum computing.

Additionally, the proposed 3-bit repetition error correction code, while effective in reducing the impact of bit flip errors, may not be the most efficient solution in terms of memory overhead. Error correction in non-volatile processing memory discusses alternative error correction techniques that could potentially be more memory-efficient.

Further research could explore the impact of bit flip errors in real-world quantum computing hardware, as well as investigate the interplay between different fault types and their combined effects on quantum computations.

Conclusion

This paper investigates the impact of bit flip errors in FPGA memories on quantum computing systems, which are crucial for storing the amplitude and phase information of quantum gate pulses. The researchers' experiments using IBM's simulated quantum environments reveal that bit flips in the exponent and initial mantissa bits of the real amplitude can cause substantial deviations in quantum gate operations.

To mitigate these errors, the researchers propose a 3-bit repetition error correction code, which effectively reduces the impact of the bit flip errors on quantum computations. While this approach introduces a small memory overhead, it highlights the importance of addressing hardware-related faults in quantum computing systems to ensure the reliability and accuracy of quantum computations.