Is CLIP the main roadblock for fine-grained open-world perception?
2404.03539
0
0
Abstract
Modern applications increasingly demand flexible computer vision models that adapt to novel concepts not encountered during training. This necessity is pivotal in emerging domains like extended reality, robotics, and autonomous driving, which require the ability to respond to open-world stimuli. A key ingredient is the ability to identify objects based on free-form textual queries defined at inference time - a task known as open-vocabulary object detection. Multimodal backbones like CLIP are the main enabling technology for current open-world perception solutions. Despite performing well on generic queries, recent studies highlighted limitations on the fine-grained recognition capabilities in open-vocabulary settings - i.e., for distinguishing subtle object features like color, shape, and material. In this paper, we perform a detailed examination of these open-vocabulary object recognition limitations to find the root cause. We evaluate the performance of CLIP, the most commonly used vision-language backbone, against a fine-grained object-matching benchmark, revealing interesting analogies between the limitations of open-vocabulary object detectors and their backbones. Experiments suggest that the lack of fine-grained understanding is caused by the poor separability of object characteristics in the CLIP latent space. Therefore, we try to understand whether fine-grained knowledge is present in CLIP embeddings but not exploited at inference time due, for example, to the unsuitability of the cosine similarity matching function, which may discard important object characteristics. Our preliminary experiments show that simple CLIP latent-space re-projections help separate fine-grained concepts, paving the way towards the development of backbones inherently able to process fine-grained details. The code for reproducing these experiments is available at https://github.com/lorebianchi98/FG-CLIP.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of CLIP, a popular image-text matching model, for fine-grained open-world perception tasks.
- The research was partially supported by several European projects, including SUN, FAIR, ITSERR, and MUCES.
- The paper aims to understand if CLIP is the main roadblock for achieving better performance on these challenging tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper investigates the limitations of CLIP, a widely-used model that can match images with relevant text descriptions. The researchers want to understand if CLIP is the main obstacle preventing better performance on fine-grained open-vocabulary object detection and open-world video understanding tasks. These tasks require a model to recognize a very large number of detailed object categories in complex real-world scenes and videos.
The paper is partially funded by several European research projects focused on advancing artificial intelligence and multimedia technologies. The researchers hope to use their findings to guide future work on improving fine-grained open-world perception capabilities.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an evaluation study to understand the limitations of using CLIP for fine-grained open-world perception tasks. CLIP is a prominent image-text matching model that has shown impressive zero-shot transfer capabilities. However, its performance on tasks requiring granular object-level understanding in diverse real-world settings has been less explored.
The researchers conduct experiments on several benchmarks, including open-vocabulary object detection, video highlight detection, and open-world video instance segmentation. They analyze CLIP's performance compared to specialized models and identify key challenges, such as capturing fine-grained visual distinctions and generalizing to unseen object categories.
The findings suggest that while CLIP is a powerful general-purpose model, it may not be the sole solution for achieving high performance on these complex open-world perception tasks. The paper discusses potential directions for improving CLIP or developing complementary approaches to address the identified limitations.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed evaluation of CLIP's capabilities for fine-grained open-world perception tasks. The researchers acknowledge the inherent challenges of these tasks and recognize that CLIP, while highly capable, may not be the complete solution.
One potential limitation of the study is the specific choice of benchmark tasks and datasets. While the selected tasks are representative of open-world perception challenges, the results may not generalize to all possible fine-grained understanding scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the underlying reasons for CLIP's performance limitations, which could provide valuable insights for future model improvements.
Furthermore, the paper could have explored the potential synergies between CLIP and other specialized models or architectures like those discussed in the referenced papers. Investigating hybrid approaches or ways to leverage CLIP's strengths in conjunction with other techniques could yield promising directions for advancing open-world perception capabilities.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of the use of CLIP, a prominent image-text matching model, for fine-grained open-world perception tasks. The results suggest that while CLIP is a powerful general-purpose model, it may not be the sole solution for achieving high performance on these challenging tasks, which require granular understanding of diverse real-world scenes and objects.
The findings highlight the need for continued research and development in this area, potentially exploring ways to enhance CLIP or combine it with other specialized approaches. The insights from this work can inform the design of future models and architectures to push the boundaries of open-world perception capabilities, ultimately enabling more robust and versatile artificial intelligence systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
African or European Swallow? Benchmarking Large Vision-Language Models for Fine-Grained Object Classification
Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavav{s}
0
0
Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) demonstrate impressive abilities on numerous image understanding and reasoning tasks. The task of fine-grained object classification (e.g., distinction between textit{animal species}), however, has been probed insufficiently, despite its downstream importance. We fill this evaluation gap by creating texttt{FOCI} (textbf{F}ine-grained textbf{O}bject textbf{C}lasstextbf{I}fication), a difficult multiple-choice benchmark for fine-grained object classification, from existing object classification datasets: (1) multiple-choice avoids ambiguous answers associated with casting classification as open-ended QA task; (2) we retain classification difficulty by mining negative labels with a CLIP model. texttt{FOCI}xspace complements five popular classification datasets with four domain-specific subsets from ImageNet-21k. We benchmark 12 public LVLMs on texttt{FOCI} and show that it tests for a textit{complementary skill} to established image understanding and reasoning benchmarks. Crucially, CLIP models exhibit dramatically better performance than LVLMs. Since the image encoders of LVLMs come from these CLIP models, this points to inadequate alignment for fine-grained object distinction between the encoder and the LLM and warrants (pre)training data with more fine-grained annotation. We release our code at url{https://github.com/gregor-ge/FOCI-Benchmark}.
6/21/2024
Enhancing Fine-Grained Image Classifications via Cascaded Vision Language Models
Canshi Wei
0
0
Fine-grained image classification, particularly in zero/few-shot scenarios, presents a significant challenge for vision-language models (VLMs), such as CLIP. These models often struggle with the nuanced task of distinguishing between semantically similar classes due to limitations in their pre-trained recipe, which lacks supervision signals for fine-grained categorization. This paper introduces CascadeVLM, an innovative framework that overcomes the constraints of previous CLIP-based methods by effectively leveraging the granular knowledge encapsulated within large vision-language models (LVLMs). Experiments across various fine-grained image datasets demonstrate that CascadeVLM significantly outperforms existing models, specifically on the Stanford Cars dataset, achieving an impressive 85.6% zero-shot accuracy. Performance gain analysis validates that LVLMs produce more accurate predictions for challenging images that CLIPs are uncertain about, bringing the overall accuracy boost. Our framework sheds light on a holistic integration of VLMs and LVLMs for effective and efficient fine-grained image classification.
5/21/2024
🤔
The devil is in the fine-grained details: Evaluating open-vocabulary object detectors for fine-grained understanding
Lorenzo Bianchi, Fabio Carrara, Nicola Messina, Claudio Gennaro, Fabrizio Falchi
0
0
Recent advancements in large vision-language models enabled visual object detection in open-vocabulary scenarios, where object classes are defined in free-text formats during inference. In this paper, we aim to probe the state-of-the-art methods for open-vocabulary object detection to determine to what extent they understand fine-grained properties of objects and their parts. To this end, we introduce an evaluation protocol based on dynamic vocabulary generation to test whether models detect, discern, and assign the correct fine-grained description to objects in the presence of hard-negative classes. We contribute with a benchmark suite of increasing difficulty and probing different properties like color, pattern, and material. We further enhance our investigation by evaluating several state-of-the-art open-vocabulary object detectors using the proposed protocol and find that most existing solutions, which shine in standard open-vocabulary benchmarks, struggle to accurately capture and distinguish finer object details. We conclude the paper by highlighting the limitations of current methodologies and exploring promising research directions to overcome the discovered drawbacks. Data and code are available at https://lorebianchi98.github.io/FG-OVD/.
4/9/2024
ECOR: Explainable CLIP for Object Recognition
Ali Rasekh, Sepehr Kazemi Ranjbar, Milad Heidari, Wolfgang Nejdl
0
0
Large Vision Language Models (VLMs), such as CLIP, have significantly contributed to various computer vision tasks, including object recognition and object detection. Their open vocabulary feature enhances their value. However, their black-box nature and lack of explainability in predictions make them less trustworthy in critical domains. Recently, some work has been done to force VLMs to provide reasonable rationales for object recognition, but this often comes at the expense of classification accuracy. In this paper, we first propose a mathematical definition of explainability in the object recognition task based on the joint probability distribution of categories and rationales, then leverage this definition to fine-tune CLIP in an explainable manner. Through evaluations of different datasets, our method demonstrates state-of-the-art performance in explainable classification. Notably, it excels in zero-shot settings, showcasing its adaptability. This advancement improves explainable object recognition, enhancing trust across diverse applications. The code will be made available online upon publication.
4/22/2024