Jump to Conclusions: Short-Cutting Transformers With Linear Transformations

Overview

• Transformer-based language models create hidden representations at every layer, but only use the final-layer representations for prediction
• This obscures the internal decision-making process and the utility of the intermediate representations
• This paper introduces a simple method to "cast" the hidden representations as final representations, bypassing the transformer computation in-between
• This approach allows for better understanding of the model's internal representations and decision-making

Plain English Explanation

Transformer-based language models, like GPT-2 and BERT, create complex internal representations of the text they process. However, these models only use the final layer of representations to make their predictions, obscuring the insights that could be gained from the intermediate layers.

The researchers in this paper propose a simple way to "map" the hidden representations from the intermediate layers directly to the final prediction, bypassing the full transformer computation. This allows them to better understand how the model is making decisions at each stage of the process, rather than just looking at the final output.

The researchers find that this linear mapping approach is more effective at extracting useful information from the intermediate layers than the common practice of inspecting the hidden representations directly. They also show that in many cases, the model is actually able to predict the final output quite early in the processing, suggesting that the later layers may not be contributing as much new information as one might expect.

Additionally, the researchers demonstrate how this technique can be used to develop more efficient models that can make accurate predictions using fewer computational layers, potentially leading to faster and more resource-efficient language models.

Technical Explanation

The key idea behind this work is to bypass the full transformer computation and instead directly map the hidden representations from the intermediate layers to the final prediction. The researchers achieve this by learning a set of linear transformations that can approximate the model's internal decision-making process.

Specifically, they take the hidden representations from each layer of the transformer and use them to predict the final output of the model, rather than just using the representations from the last layer. This allows them to understand how the model is making decisions at each stage of the processing pipeline, rather than just looking at the final result.

The researchers find that this linear mapping approach significantly outperforms the common practice of inspecting the hidden representations directly, in terms of the ability to accurately predict the final output. They also show that for many language modeling tasks, the model is often able to make accurate predictions quite early in the processing, suggesting that the later layers may not be contributing as much new information as one might expect.

Furthermore, the researchers demonstrate how this technique can be used to develop more efficient models that can make accurate predictions using fewer computational layers, potentially leading to faster and more resource-efficient language models.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several caveats and limitations of their approach. First, they note that the linear mapping may not be able to fully capture the complex non-linear transformations happening inside the transformer model. There may be important information being lost or distorted by the linear approximation.

Additionally, the researchers only evaluate their method on language modeling tasks, and it's unclear how well it would generalize to other types of transformer-based models and applications. Further research would be needed to understand the broader applicability of this technique.

Another potential issue is that the learned linear mappings may not be interpretable or generalizable, limiting their usefulness for gaining a deeper understanding of the model's internal representations and decision-making processes. It's possible that more structured approaches could provide more meaningful insights.

Finally, the researchers do not provide a thorough analysis of the computational and memory overhead introduced by their method, which could be an important practical consideration, especially when scaling to larger models.

Overall, this work presents an interesting and potentially useful approach for better understanding the inner workings of transformer-based language models. However, further research is needed to address the limitations and explore the broader applicability of this technique.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a simple method for "casting" the hidden representations of transformer-based language models as final representations, bypassing the full transformer computation. This allows for a better understanding of the model's internal decision-making process and the utility of its intermediate representations.

The researchers find that this linear mapping approach significantly outperforms the common practice of inspecting the hidden representations directly, and it can also be used to develop more efficient language models that make accurate predictions using fewer computational layers.

While the technique has some limitations, it represents an interesting step towards improving the interpretability and efficiency of transformer-based models, which are becoming increasingly important in a wide range of natural language processing applications.