Knowledge-Aware Parsimony Learning: A Perspective from Relational Graphs
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a knowledge-aware parsimony learning framework for relational graphs, which aims to efficiently learn compact and expressive models from knowledge graphs.
- The authors propose a novel approach that leverages prior knowledge to guide the model learning process, striking a balance between model complexity and explanatory power.
- The research explores how incorporating domain knowledge can lead to more parsimonious and interpretable models, addressing challenges in scaling knowledge graph reasoning to real-world applications.
Plain English Explanation
Knowledge graphs are powerful tools for representing and reasoning about complex relationships between entities. However, learning effective models from these graphs can be challenging, as the models need to capture the intricate structure while remaining compact and interpretable.
The researchers in this paper introduce a novel approach called knowledge-aware parsimony learning. The key idea is to leverage prior knowledge about the domain, such as the types of relationships or the hierarchical structure of entities, to guide the model learning process. By incorporating this domain knowledge, the researchers aim to find models that are both expressive and compact, striking a balance between complexity and explanatory power.
The chain-of-thought reasoning approach used in this work is particularly interesting, as it allows the model to integrate knowledge and reasoning in a structured way. This can lead to more scalable and interpretable models, which is crucial for real-world applications of knowledge graph technologies.
Overall, this research offers a promising perspective on how to empower small-scale knowledge graphs by leveraging domain knowledge during the model learning process. The insights on the emergence of scaling laws in this context could also have broader implications for the field of graph-based machine learning.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contribution of this paper is the development of a knowledge-aware parsimony learning framework for relational graphs. The authors propose a novel objective function that jointly optimizes for model complexity and explanatory power, incorporating prior knowledge about the domain.
The framework consists of three main components:
- Relational Graph Representation: The authors use a graph-based representation to capture the entities and relationships in the knowledge graph.
- Knowledge-Aware Parsimony Objective: The objective function balances model complexity (measured by the number of parameters) and the ability to explain the observed data, guided by the provided domain knowledge.
- Optimization Algorithm: The authors develop a specialized optimization algorithm to efficiently solve the knowledge-aware parsimony learning problem, leveraging the structure of the relational graph.
The experiments in the paper demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach on several real-world knowledge graph datasets. The results show that the knowledge-aware parsimony learning framework can learn compact and expressive models that outperform baseline methods in terms of predictive performance and interpretability.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough investigation of the knowledge-aware parsimony learning problem for relational graphs. The authors have clearly identified a relevant and challenging problem in the field of knowledge graph reasoning and have proposed a novel solution that shows promising results.
One potential limitation of the research is the reliance on the availability of high-quality domain knowledge to guide the model learning process. In practice, such knowledge may not always be easily accessible or well-defined, which could limit the applicability of the proposed framework. The authors acknowledge this challenge and suggest that developing techniques to automatically extract or infer relevant domain knowledge could be an important area for future research.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the computational complexity of the proposed optimization algorithm. While the authors demonstrate the efficiency of their approach, a more thorough theoretical and empirical investigation of the scalability of the framework would be valuable, especially as knowledge graphs continue to grow in size and complexity.
Overall, the paper makes a significant contribution to the field of knowledge graph reasoning by introducing a novel perspective on balancing model complexity and explanatory power. The insights and ideas presented in this work could inspire further research on integrating knowledge and reasoning into scalable and interpretable machine learning models.
Conclusion
This paper presents a knowledge-aware parsimony learning framework for relational graphs, which aims to efficiently learn compact and expressive models from knowledge graphs. The key innovation is the incorporation of domain knowledge to guide the model learning process, leading to more parsimonious and interpretable representations.
The research offers a promising perspective on how to leverage prior knowledge to address the challenges of scaling knowledge graph reasoning to real-world applications. The insights on the emergence of scaling laws and the potential for empowering small-scale knowledge graphs could have broader implications for the field of graph-based machine learning.
Overall, this work demonstrates the value of incorporating domain knowledge into the model learning process and highlights the importance of balancing model complexity and explanatory power in knowledge-intensive applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Knowledge-Aware Parsimony Learning: A Perspective from Relational Graphs
Quanming Yao, Yongqi Zhang, Yaqing Wang, Nan Yin, James Kwok, Qiang Yang
The scaling law, a strategy that involves the brute-force scaling of the training dataset and learnable parameters, has become a prevalent approach for developing stronger learning models. In this paper, we examine its rationale in terms of learning from relational graphs. We demonstrate that directly adhering to such a scaling law does not necessarily yield stronger models due to architectural incompatibility and representation bottlenecks. To tackle this challenge, we propose a novel framework for learning from relational graphs via knowledge-aware parsimony learning. Our method draws inspiration from the duality between data and knowledge inherent in these graphs. Specifically, we first extract knowledge (like symbolic logic and physical laws) during the learning process, and then apply combinatorial generalization to the task at hand. This extracted knowledge serves as the ``building blocks'' for achieving parsimony learning. By applying this philosophy to architecture, parameters, and inference, we can effectively achieve versatile, sample-efficient, and interpretable learning. Experimental results show that our proposed framework surpasses methods that strictly follow the traditional scaling-up roadmap. This highlights the importance of incorporating knowledge in the development of next-generation learning technologies.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Neural Scaling Laws on Graphs
Jingzhe Liu, Haitao Mao, Zhikai Chen, Tong Zhao, Neil Shah, Jiliang Tang
Deep graph models (e.g., graph neural networks and graph transformers) have become important techniques for leveraging knowledge across various types of graphs. Yet, the scaling properties of deep graph models have not been systematically investigated, casting doubt on the feasibility of achieving large graph models through enlarging the model and dataset sizes. In this work, we delve into neural scaling laws on graphs from both model and data perspectives. We first verify the validity of such laws on graphs, establishing formulations to describe the scaling behaviors. For model scaling, we investigate the phenomenon of scaling law collapse and identify overfitting as the potential reason. Moreover, we reveal that the model depth of deep graph models can impact the model scaling behaviors, which differ from observations in other domains such as CV and NLP. For data scaling, we suggest that the number of graphs can not effectively metric the graph data volume in scaling law since the sizes of different graphs are highly irregular. Instead, we reform the data scaling law with the number of edges as the metric to address the irregular graph sizes. We further demonstrate the reformed law offers a unified view of the data scaling behaviors for various fundamental graph tasks including node classification, link prediction, and graph classification. This work provides valuable insights into neural scaling laws on graphs, which can serve as an essential step toward large graph models.
Read more6/11/2024
0
Information-Theoretic Foundations for Neural Scaling Laws
Hong Jun Jeon, Benjamin Van Roy
Neural scaling laws aim to characterize how out-of-sample error behaves as a function of model and training dataset size. Such scaling laws guide allocation of a computational resources between model and data processing to minimize error. However, existing theoretical support for neural scaling laws lacks rigor and clarity, entangling the roles of information and optimization. In this work, we develop rigorous information-theoretic foundations for neural scaling laws. This allows us to characterize scaling laws for data generated by a two-layer neural network of infinite width. We observe that the optimal relation between data and model size is linear, up to logarithmic factors, corroborating large-scale empirical investigations. Concise yet general results of the kind we establish may bring clarity to this topic and inform future investigations.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Neural Probabilistic Logic Learning for Knowledge Graph Reasoning
Fengsong Sun, Jinyu Wang, Zhiqing Wei, Xianchao Zhang
Knowledge graph (KG) reasoning is a task that aims to predict unknown facts based on known factual samples. Reasoning methods can be divided into two categories: rule-based methods and KG-embedding based methods. The former possesses precise reasoning capabilities but finds it challenging to reason efficiently over large-scale knowledge graphs. While gaining the ability to reason over large-scale knowledge graphs, the latter sacrifices reasoning accuracy. This paper aims to design a reasoning framework called Neural Probabilistic Logic Learning(NPLL) that achieves accurate reasoning on knowledge graphs. Our approach introduces a scoring module that effectively enhances the expressive power of embedding networks, striking a balance between model simplicity and reasoning capabilities. We improve the interpretability of the model by incorporating a Markov Logic Network based on variational inference. We empirically evaluate our approach on several benchmark datasets, and the experimental results validate that our method substantially enhances the accuracy and quality of the reasoning results.
Read more7/8/2024