Knowledge of Knowledge: Exploring Known-Unknowns Uncertainty with Large Language Models
2305.13712
0
0
š¬
Abstract
This paper investigates the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the context of understanding their knowledge and uncertainty over questions. Specifically, we focus on addressing known-unknown questions, characterized by high uncertainty due to the absence of definitive answers. To facilitate our study, we collect a new dataset with Known-Unknown Questions (KUQ) and establish a categorization framework to clarify the origins of uncertainty in such queries. Subsequently, we examine the performance of open-source LLMs, fine-tuned using this dataset, in distinguishing between known and unknown queries within open-ended question-answering scenarios. The fine-tuned models demonstrated a significant improvement, achieving a considerable increase in F1-score relative to their pre-fine-tuning state. Through a comprehensive analysis, we reveal insights into the models' improved uncertainty articulation and their consequent efficacy in multi-agent debates. These findings help us understand how LLMs can be trained to identify and express uncertainty, improving our knowledge of how they understand and express complex or unclear information.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to understand their own knowledge and uncertainty around questions.
- The researchers focus on "known-unknown" questions, where the answer is highly uncertain due to a lack of definitive information.
- They create a new dataset of known-unknown questions and use it to fine-tune open-source LLMs, examining how well the models can distinguish between known and unknown queries.
- The fine-tuned models show significant improvements in identifying and expressing uncertainty, which has implications for how LLMs can be trained to handle complex or unclear information.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are AI systems that can generate human-like text. This paper looks at how well these models can recognize the limits of their own knowledge.
The researchers were interested in known-unknown questions - questions where there is no clear answer, often because the information doesn't exist. They created a dataset of these types of questions to train LLMs.
After training, the models were better able to distinguish between questions they could answer and those they couldn't. They became more aware of their own uncertainty and could express that more effectively.
This is important because it helps us understand how LLMs comprehend complex or unclear information and where the boundaries of their knowledge lie. It could lead to LLMs that are better equipped to handle messy, real-world questions.
Technical Explanation
The researchers collected a new dataset of "known-unknown" questions - queries that have a high degree of uncertainty due to a lack of definitive answers. They established a categorization framework to better understand the sources of this uncertainty.
They then fine-tuned several open-source LLMs using this dataset, evaluating how well the models could distinguish between known and unknown queries in open-ended question-answering scenarios. The fine-tuned models demonstrated a significant improvement, achieving a substantial increase in F1-score compared to their pre-fine-tuning state.
Through comprehensive analysis, the researchers reveal insights into the models' improved ability to articulate uncertainty. They also examine the models' consequent effectiveness in multi-agent debates, where the expression of uncertainty is crucial.
These findings contribute to our understanding of how LLMs can be trained to better identify and convey uncertainty, which is an important aspect of their ability to comprehend and communicate complex or unclear information.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of LLM capabilities, particularly around the models' awareness of their own knowledge boundaries. The researchers' approach of focusing on known-unknown questions and developing a categorization framework is a thoughtful way to study this issue.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the research. For example, the dataset of known-unknown questions may not fully capture the breadth of uncertainty encountered in real-world scenarios. Additionally, the performance improvements observed in the fine-tuned models may be specific to the particular dataset and tasks used in the study, and their generalizability to other domains or applications is not extensively explored.
Further research could investigate how these findings apply to LLMs in more diverse and open-ended contexts, as well as the potential risks or downsides of models that are overly confident in their uncertainty assessments. Exploring ways to balance uncertainty expression with informative and helpful responses would also be a valuable avenue for future study.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to our understanding of how Large Language Models can be trained to better identify and express uncertainty. By focusing on known-unknown questions and fine-tuning models using a specialized dataset, the researchers demonstrate that LLMs can significantly improve their ability to distinguish between queries they can answer and those they cannot.
These findings have implications for the development of LLMs that are more adept at handling complex or unclear information, as well as for improving the transparency and trustworthiness of these powerful AI systems. As LLMs become more widely deployed, understanding and addressing their limitations around uncertainty will be crucial for ensuring they are used responsibly and effectively.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Harnessing the Power of Large Language Model for Uncertainty Aware Graph Processing
Zhenyu Qian, Yiming Qian, Yuting Song, Fei Gao, Hai Jin, Chen Yu, Xia Xie
0
0
Handling graph data is one of the most difficult tasks. Traditional techniques, such as those based on geometry and matrix factorization, rely on assumptions about the data relations that become inadequate when handling large and complex graph data. On the other hand, deep learning approaches demonstrate promising results in handling large graph data, but they often fall short of providing interpretable explanations. To equip the graph processing with both high accuracy and explainability, we introduce a novel approach that harnesses the power of a large language model (LLM), enhanced by an uncertainty-aware module to provide a confidence score on the generated answer. We experiment with our approach on two graph processing tasks: few-shot knowledge graph completion and graph classification. Our results demonstrate that through parameter efficient fine-tuning, the LLM surpasses state-of-the-art algorithms by a substantial margin across ten diverse benchmark datasets. Moreover, to address the challenge of explainability, we propose an uncertainty estimation based on perturbation, along with a calibration scheme to quantify the confidence scores of the generated answers. Our confidence measure achieves an AUC of 0.8 or higher on seven out of the ten datasets in predicting the correctness of the answer generated by LLM.
4/15/2024
Large Language Models Must Be Taught to Know What They Don't Know
Sanyam Kapoor, Nate Gruver, Manley Roberts, Katherine Collins, Arka Pal, Umang Bhatt, Adrian Weller, Samuel Dooley, Micah Goldblum, Andrew Gordon Wilson
0
0
When using large language models (LLMs) in high-stakes applications, we need to know when we can trust their predictions. Some works argue that prompting high-performance LLMs is sufficient to produce calibrated uncertainties, while others introduce sampling methods that can be prohibitively expensive. In this work, we first argue that prompting on its own is insufficient to achieve good calibration and then show that fine-tuning on a small dataset of correct and incorrect answers can create an uncertainty estimate with good generalization and small computational overhead. We show that a thousand graded examples are sufficient to outperform baseline methods and that training through the features of a model is necessary for good performance and tractable for large open-source models when using LoRA. We also investigate the mechanisms that enable reliable LLM uncertainty estimation, finding that many models can be used as general-purpose uncertainty estimators, applicable not just to their own uncertainties but also the uncertainty of other models. Lastly, we show that uncertainty estimates inform human use of LLMs in human-AI collaborative settings through a user study.
6/13/2024
Know the Unknown: An Uncertainty-Sensitive Method for LLM Instruction Tuning
Jiaqi Li, Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across various tasks but still face challenges such as hallucinations. One potential reason for hallucinations is the lack of relevant knowledge or context. Thus, a promising solution to mitigate this issue involves instructing LLMs to respond with I do not know when a question falls outside their knowledge domain or the provided context. However, in this work, we observed that LLMs struggle to admit their lack of knowledge, primarily due to existing instruction datasets designed to encourage specific answers. To improve large language models' capability to recognize the boundaries of their knowledge, we propose a novel approach called uncertainty-sensitive tuning. This method involves two-stage training designed for uncertainty recognition and prompt-sensitive activation. In the first stage, we guide the LLM to reject unknown questions. In the second stage, we recover the decreased performance in QA tasks by incorporating designed causal instructions. By leveraging this method, we aim to enhance the model's ability to identify areas of uncertainty. The experimental results demonstrate that our proposed uncertainty-sensitive tuning method significantly improves the performance of the Llama2-chat-7B model. Specifically, it achieves a substantial 34.7% improvement in handling questions involving knowledge gaps compared to the original model. Moreover, our approach outperforms GPT-4, exhibiting a 9.4% increase in overall performance. We open-source the model and code on GitHub.
6/17/2024
Can I understand what I create? Self-Knowledge Evaluation of Large Language Models
Zhiquan Tan, Lai Wei, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Weiran Huang
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in linguistic tasks, necessitating robust evaluation frameworks to understand their capabilities and limitations. Inspired by Feynman's principle of understanding through creation, we introduce a self-knowledge evaluation framework that is easy to implement, evaluating models on their ability to comprehend and respond to self-generated questions. Our findings, based on testing multiple models across diverse tasks, reveal significant gaps in the model's self-knowledge ability. Further analysis indicates these gaps may be due to misalignment with human attention mechanisms. Additionally, fine-tuning on self-generated math task may enhance the model's math performance, highlighting the potential of the framework for efficient and insightful model evaluation and may also contribute to the improvement of LLMs.
6/11/2024