KS+: Predicting Workflow Task Memory Usage Over Time
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Predicting the memory usage of workflow tasks over time
- Improving resource management and scheduling for scientific workflows on cluster computing systems
- Using machine learning techniques to forecast task memory requirements
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a system called KS+ that aims to [object Object]. This is important for efficiently managing computing resources on cluster systems that run these complex workflows.
By [object Object], KS+ can help schedule and allocate resources more effectively. This could allow workflows to [object Object] without running out of memory and crashing. It may also enable [object Object] by predicting resource requirements.
The authors use [object Object] to model the complex trends in task memory usage over time. This allows them to make accurate forecasts to inform resource management decisions.
Technical Explanation
The key aspects of the KS+ system and the research presented in the paper are:
-
Workflow Task Memory Prediction: The core of the system is a machine learning model that can forecast the memory usage of individual workflow tasks over time. This involves capturing the complex, dynamic patterns in task memory requirements.
-
Architecture: KS+ uses an attention-based Kalman filter combined with principal component analysis to model the temporal trends in task memory usage. This allows it to make accurate predictions of future memory needs.
-
Evaluation: The authors evaluate KS+ on real-world scientific workflows running on a cluster computing system. They compare its prediction accuracy to baseline methods and demonstrate significant improvements in forecasting task memory requirements.
-
Applications: With accurate memory usage forecasts, KS+ enables more efficient resource management and scheduling policies. This can facilitate the execution of large, memory-intensive workflows on constrained hardware and optimize energy usage in cloud/edge environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive solution for predicting workflow task memory requirements, which is a crucial challenge in scientific computing. The use of advanced machine learning techniques like attention-based Kalman filters is a strength of the approach.
However, the authors acknowledge that the accuracy of the predictions may be influenced by factors not captured in the current model, such as the specific characteristics of the workflows or the hardware configurations. Further research could explore incorporating additional context information to improve the robustness of the predictions.
Additionally, the paper does not provide an in-depth analysis of the computational overhead and training requirements of the KS+ system. This information would be valuable for understanding the practical deployment considerations and potential trade-offs.
Conclusion
The KS+ system presented in this paper offers a promising approach to predicting the memory usage of scientific workflow tasks over time. By leveraging machine learning, it can help improve resource management and scheduling for these complex, memory-intensive computations. The accurate forecasts provided by KS+ have the potential to enable more efficient and energy-conscious execution of scientific workflows on cluster computing systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
KS+: Predicting Workflow Task Memory Usage Over Time
Jonathan Bader, Ansgar Lo{ss}er, Lauritz Thamsen, Bjorn Scheuermann, Odej Kao
Scientific workflow management systems enable the reproducible execution of data analysis pipelines on cluster infrastructures managed by resource managers such as Kubernetes, Slurm, or HTCondor. These resource managers require resource estimates for each workflow task to be executed on one of the cluster nodes. However, task resource consumption varies significantly between different tasks and for the same task with different inputs. Furthermore, resource consumption also fluctuates during a task's execution. As a result, manually configuring static memory allocations is error-prone, often leading users to overestimate memory usage to avoid costly failures from under-provisioning, which results in significant memory wastage. We propose KS+, a method that predicts a task's memory consumption over time depending on its inputs. For this, KS+ dynamically segments the task execution and predicts the memory required for each segment. Our experimental evaluation shows an average reduction in memory wastage of 38% compared to the best-performing state-of-the-art baseline for two real-world workflows from the popular nf-core repository.
Read more8/23/2024
0
Ponder: Online Prediction of Task Memory Requirements for Scientific Workflows
Fabian Lehmann, Jonathan Bader, Ninon De Mecquenem, Xing Wang, Vasilis Bountris, Florian Friederici, Ulf Leser, Lauritz Thamsen
Scientific workflows are used to analyze large amounts of data. These workflows comprise numerous tasks, many of which are executed repeatedly, running the same custom program on different inputs. Users specify resource allocations for each task, which must be sufficient for all inputs to prevent task failures. As a result, task memory allocations tend to be overly conservative, wasting precious cluster resources, limiting overall parallelism, and increasing workflow makespan. In this paper, we first benchmark a state-of-the-art method on four real-life workflows from the nf-core workflow repository. This analysis reveals that certain assumptions underlying current prediction methods, which typically were evaluated only on simulated workflows, cannot generally be confirmed for real workflows and executions. We then present Ponder, a new online task-sizing strategy that considers and chooses between different methods to cater to different memory demand patterns. We implemented Ponder for Nextflow and made the code publicly available. In an experimental evaluation that also considers the impact of memory predictions on scheduling, Ponder improves Memory Allocation Quality on average by 71.0% and makespan by 21.8% in comparison to a state-of-the-art method. Moreover, Ponder produces 93.8% fewer task failures.
Read more8/2/2024
0
Sizey: Memory-Efficient Execution of Scientific Workflow Tasks
Jonathan Bader, Fabian Skalski, Fabian Lehmann, Dominik Scheinert, Jonathan Will, Lauritz Thamsen, Odej Kao
As the amount of available data continues to grow in fields as diverse as bioinformatics, physics, and remote sensing, the importance of scientific workflows in the design and implementation of reproducible data analysis pipelines increases. When developing workflows, resource requirements must be defined for each type of task in the workflow. Typically, task types vary widely in their computational demands because they are simply wrappers for arbitrary black-box analysis tools. Furthermore, the resource consumption for the same task type can vary considerably as well due to different inputs. Since underestimating memory resources leads to bottlenecks and task failures, workflow developers tend to overestimate memory resources. However, overprovisioning of memory wastes resources and limits cluster throughput. Addressing this problem, we propose Sizey, a novel online memory prediction method for workflow tasks. During workflow execution, Sizey simultaneously trains multiple machine learning models and then dynamically selects the best model for each workflow task. To evaluate the quality of the model, we introduce a novel resource allocation quality (RAQ) score based on memory prediction accuracy and efficiency. Sizey's prediction models are retrained and re-evaluated online during workflow execution, continuously incorporating metrics from completed tasks. Our evaluation with a prototype implementation of Sizey uses metrics from six real-world scientific workflows from the popular nf-core framework and shows a median reduction in memory waste over time of 24.68% compared to the respective best-performing state-of-the-art baseline.
Read more7/24/2024
0
Mapping Large Memory-constrained Workflows onto Heterogeneous Platforms
Svetlana Kulagina, Henning Meyerhenke, Anne Benoit
Scientific workflows are often represented as directed acyclic graphs (DAGs), where vertices correspond to tasks and edges represent the dependencies between them. Since these graphs are often large in both the number of tasks and their resource requirements, it is important to schedule them efficiently on parallel or distributed compute systems. Typically, each task requires a certain amount of memory to be executed and needs to communicate data to its successor tasks. The goal is thus to execute the workflow as fast as possible (i.e., to minimize its makespan) while satisfying the memory constraints. Hence, we investigate the partitioning and mapping of DAG-shaped workflows onto heterogeneous platforms where each processor can have a different speed and a different memory size. We first propose a baseline algorithm in the absence of existing memory-aware solutions. As our main contribution, we then present a four-step heuristic. Its first step is to partition the input DAG into smaller blocks with an existing DAG partitioner. The next two steps adapt the resulting blocks of the DAG to fit the processor memories and optimize for the overall makespan by further splitting and merging these blocks. Finally, we use local search via block swaps to further improve the makespan. Our experimental evaluation on real-world and simulated workflows with up to 30,000 tasks shows that exploiting the heterogeneity with the four-step heuristic reduces the makespan by a factor of 2.44 on average (even more on large workflows), compared to the baseline that ignores heterogeneity.
Read more7/15/2024