Landscaping Linear Mode Connectivity
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the phenomenon of linear mode connectivity (LMC) in the highly non-convex loss landscapes of neural networks.
- LMC refers to the presence of linear paths in parameter space between different network solutions, which has been observed in certain cases.
- The authors seek to understand the core reasons for the occurrence of LMC, and provide a model of how the loss landscape must behave topographically for LMC (or the lack thereof) to manifest.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores the idea of linear mode connectivity (LMC), which is the observation that sometimes there are straight-line paths connecting different solutions in the complex, non-linear landscape of a neural network's parameters. This is an interesting phenomenon because neural networks are generally thought to have extremely complex, non-convex loss landscapes, so the presence of these linear paths is somewhat surprising.
The authors propose a "mountainside and ridge" perspective to explain how the loss landscape must be shaped in order for LMC to occur (or not occur). They suggest that the landscape needs to have certain geometric features, like barriers or ridges, that allow these linear paths to exist. The paper also provides a theoretical analysis of the height of these barriers, and shows how this can be used to predict whether LMC will be present in different layers of the network.
Overall, the goal is to develop a better understanding of the underlying structure of neural network loss landscapes, which could have implications for training neural networks, finding multiple solutions, and analyzing their behavior.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by noting the significant prior work on both practical algorithms for connecting neural network solutions and more theoretical constructions of paths between them. However, the authors argue that the fundamental reasons for the occurrence of LMC are still not well understood.
To address this, the paper presents a "mountainside and ridge" perspective on the loss landscape. The key idea is that the landscape must contain certain topographical features, like barriers and ridges, in order for LMC to manifest (or not manifest). The authors provide a theoretical analysis of the barrier height, which they show can be used as a predictor of layer-wise LMC.
The paper also includes a toy example that illustrates how these barriers can arise in the first place, helping to build intuition for the proposed model of the loss landscape. Overall, the work aims to provide a working model of the landscape and its topography to explain the occurrence of LMC.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel perspective on understanding the phenomenon of linear mode connectivity in neural networks. The "mountainside and ridge" model offers a concrete framework for thinking about the geometric features of the loss landscape that enable (or prevent) the existence of linear paths between different solutions.
One potential limitation of the work is that the analysis is primarily theoretical, and the empirical support is somewhat limited. While the authors do provide a toy example and some experimental validation of the barrier height metric, a more extensive exploration of the model's predictive power across a wider range of neural network architectures and tasks could further strengthen the claims.
Additionally, the paper does not address the potential implications or applications of this improved understanding of the loss landscape. It would be interesting to see how this knowledge could be leveraged to improve neural network training, visualization, or the discovery of alternative solutions.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the ongoing research on the structure and behavior of neural network loss landscapes. The proposed model offers a promising step towards a more complete understanding of this complex and important topic.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel "mountainside and ridge" perspective to explain the phenomenon of linear mode connectivity (LMC) in the loss landscapes of neural networks. By analyzing the necessary topographical features of the landscape, the authors provide a model for understanding when and why LMC can (or cannot) occur.
The key insights of the work include a theoretical analysis of barrier heights and their predictive power for layer-wise LMC, as well as a illustrative toy example to build intuition. While the analysis is primarily theoretical, the paper lays the groundwork for further exploration of the underlying structure of neural network loss landscapes and its implications for training, visualization, and the discovery of alternative solutions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
Landscaping Linear Mode Connectivity
Sidak Pal Singh, Linara Adilova, Michael Kamp, Asja Fischer, Bernhard Scholkopf, Thomas Hofmann
The presence of linear paths in parameter space between two different network solutions in certain cases, i.e., linear mode connectivity (LMC), has garnered interest from both theoretical and practical fronts. There has been significant research that either practically designs algorithms catered for connecting networks by adjusting for the permutation symmetries as well as some others that more theoretically construct paths through which networks can be connected. Yet, the core reasons for the occurrence of LMC, when in fact it does occur, in the highly non-convex loss landscapes of neural networks are far from clear. In this work, we take a step towards understanding it by providing a model of how the loss landscape needs to behave topographically for LMC (or the lack thereof) to manifest. Concretely, we present a `mountainside and ridge' perspective that helps to neatly tie together different geometric features that can be spotted in the loss landscape along the training runs. We also complement this perspective by providing a theoretical analysis of the barrier height, for which we provide empirical support, and which additionally extends as a faithful predictor of layer-wise LMC. We close with a toy example that provides further intuition on how barriers arise in the first place, all in all, showcasing the larger aim of the work -- to provide a working model of the landscape and its topography for the occurrence of LMC.
Read more6/26/2024
↗️
0
Linear Mode Connectivity in Differentiable Tree Ensembles
Ryuichi Kanoh, Mahito Sugiyama
Linear Mode Connectivity (LMC) refers to the phenomenon that performance remains consistent for linearly interpolated models in the parameter space. For independently optimized model pairs from different random initializations, achieving LMC is considered crucial for validating the stable success of the non-convex optimization in modern machine learning models and for facilitating practical parameter-based operations such as model merging. While LMC has been achieved for neural networks by considering the permutation invariance of neurons in each hidden layer, its attainment for other models remains an open question. In this paper, we first achieve LMC for soft tree ensembles, which are tree-based differentiable models extensively used in practice. We show the necessity of incorporating two invariances: subtree flip invariance and splitting order invariance, which do not exist in neural networks but are inherent to tree architectures, in addition to permutation invariance of trees. Moreover, we demonstrate that it is even possible to exclude such additional invariances while keeping LMC by designing decision list-based tree architectures, where such invariances do not exist by definition. Our findings indicate the significance of accounting for architecture-specific invariances in achieving LMC.
Read more5/24/2024
0
Exploring Neural Network Landscapes: Star-Shaped and Geodesic Connectivity
Zhanran Lin, Puheng Li, Lei Wu
One of the most intriguing findings in the structure of neural network landscape is the phenomenon of mode connectivity: For two typical global minima, there exists a path connecting them without barrier. This concept of mode connectivity has played a crucial role in understanding important phenomena in deep learning. In this paper, we conduct a fine-grained analysis of this connectivity phenomenon. First, we demonstrate that in the overparameterized case, the connecting path can be as simple as a two-piece linear path, and the path length can be nearly equal to the Euclidean distance. This finding suggests that the landscape should be nearly convex in a certain sense. Second, we uncover a surprising star-shaped connectivity: For a finite number of typical minima, there exists a center on minima manifold that connects all of them simultaneously via linear paths. These results are provably valid for linear networks and two-layer ReLU networks under a teacher-student setup, and are empirically supported by models trained on MNIST and CIFAR-10.
Read more4/10/2024
0
Input Space Mode Connectivity in Deep Neural Networks
Jakub Vrabel, Ori Shem-Ur, Yaron Oz, David Krueger
We extend the concept of loss landscape mode connectivity to the input space of deep neural networks. Mode connectivity was originally studied within parameter space, where it describes the existence of low-loss paths between different solutions (loss minimizers) obtained through gradient descent. We present theoretical and empirical evidence of its presence in the input space of deep networks, thereby highlighting the broader nature of the phenomenon. We observe that different input images with similar predictions are generally connected, and for trained models, the path tends to be simple, with only a small deviation from being a linear path. Our methodology utilizes real, interpolated, and synthetic inputs created using the input optimization technique for feature visualization. We conjecture that input space mode connectivity in high-dimensional spaces is a geometric effect that takes place even in untrained models and can be explained through percolation theory. We exploit mode connectivity to obtain new insights about adversarial examples and demonstrate its potential for adversarial detection. Additionally, we discuss applications for the interpretability of deep networks.
Read more9/10/2024