Learning Cut Generating Functions for Integer Programming
2405.13992
0
0
🌿
Abstract
The branch-and-cut algorithm is the method of choice to solve large scale integer programming problems in practice. A key ingredient of branch-and-cut is the use of cutting planes which are derived constraints that reduce the search space for an optimal solution. Selecting effective cutting planes to produce small branch-and-cut trees is a critical challenge in the branch-and-cut algorithm. Recent advances have employed a data-driven approach to select optimal cutting planes from a parameterized family, aimed at reducing the branch-and-bound tree size (in expectation) for a given distribution of integer programming instances. We extend this idea to the selection of the best cut generating function (CGF), which is a tool in the integer programming literature for generating a wide variety of cutting planes that generalize the well-known Gomory Mixed-Integer (GMI) cutting planes. We provide rigorous sample complexity bounds for the selection of an effective CGF from certain parameterized families that provably performs well for any specified distribution on the problem instances. Our empirical results show that the selected CGF can outperform the GMI cuts for certain distributions. Additionally, we explore the sample complexity of using neural networks for instance-dependent CGF selection.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a data-driven approach to select effective cutting planes, which are additional constraints that can reduce the search space for optimal solutions in branch-and-cut algorithms used to solve large-scale integer programming problems.
- The researchers extend this idea to the selection of the best cut generating function (CGF), a tool for generating a variety of cutting planes that generalize the well-known Gomory Mixed-Integer (GMI) cuts.
- The paper provides theoretical guarantees on the sample complexity of selecting an effective CGF and demonstrates empirically that the selected CGF can outperform GMI cuts for certain problem distributions.
- The researchers also explore the sample complexity of using neural networks for instance-dependent CGF selection.
Plain English Explanation
Integer programming is a powerful optimization technique used to solve complex real-world problems, such as scheduling, logistics, and resource allocation. However, solving large-scale integer programming problems can be computationally challenging.
The branch-and-cut algorithm is a common method for solving these problems. It works by repeatedly dividing the problem into smaller subproblems (branching) and adding additional constraints (cutting planes) to reduce the search space and find the optimal solution.
Selecting effective cutting planes is crucial for the success of the branch-and-cut algorithm. The researchers in this paper propose a data-driven approach to automatically select the best cutting planes from a family of parameterized cutting plane generators, known as cut generating functions (CGFs).
The key idea is to use machine learning techniques to identify the CGF that is likely to produce the smallest branch-and-bound tree, which corresponds to the fastest solution time. The researchers provide theoretical guarantees on the sample complexity of this approach, meaning they can show how much data is needed to reliably select an effective CGF.
In addition, the researchers explore the use of neural networks for instance-dependent CGF selection, where the choice of CGF can be tailored to the specific problem instance being solved. This can further improve the performance of the branch-and-cut algorithm.
The results show that the data-driven CGF selection can outperform the traditional Gomory Mixed-Integer (GMI) cuts, which are a widely used type of cutting plane. This suggests that the proposed approach has the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of solving large-scale integer programming problems in practice.
Technical Explanation
The core of the paper's contribution is a data-driven framework for selecting the most effective cut generating function (CGF) to use within a branch-and-cut algorithm for solving integer programming problems.
The researchers consider a parameterized family of CGFs, which can generate a wide variety of cutting planes that generalize the well-known Gomory Mixed-Integer (GMI) cuts. They formulate the CGF selection problem as an optimization problem, where the goal is to choose the CGF that (in expectation) minimizes the size of the branch-and-bound tree required to solve a given distribution of integer programming instances.
To solve this optimization problem, the researchers employ a sample-based approach. They prove rigorous theoretical bounds on the sample complexity, which quantify how much data is needed to reliably select an effective CGF with high probability. This provides strong guarantees on the performance of the selected CGF.
Additionally, the paper explores the use of neural networks for instance-dependent CGF selection, where the choice of CGF can be tailored to the specific problem instance being solved. This can further improve the performance of the branch-and-cut algorithm, as shown in the empirical results.
The experiments demonstrate that the selected CGF can outperform the traditional GMI cuts for certain problem distributions, highlighting the potential of the data-driven approach to enhance the efficiency of solving large-scale integer programming problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and theoretically grounded approach to the critical challenge of selecting effective cutting planes in the branch-and-cut algorithm. The theoretical guarantees on sample complexity provide a strong foundation for the practical deployment of the proposed method.
One potential limitation is the reliance on a parameterized family of CGFs, which may not capture the full range of cutting planes that could be beneficial for a given problem distribution. Extending the framework to learn cutting planes from more general, potentially neural network-based, representations could further improve its flexibility and performance.
Additionally, the paper focuses on minimizing the size of the branch-and-bound tree as the objective, which is a proxy for solution time. While this is a reasonable and widely-used metric, it may not always align perfectly with the true goal of minimizing solution time, especially for problems with complex objective functions or constraints.
Further research could explore alternative objective functions or incorporate other performance metrics, such as the tightness of the cutting planes or the overall computational effort, to provide a more comprehensive optimization framework.
Moreover, the paper does not address the potential sensitivity of the selected CGF to changes in the problem distribution or the robustness of the approach to noisy or incomplete data. Investigating these aspects could enhance the practical applicability of the method.
Despite these considerations, the paper makes a valuable contribution by demonstrating the potential of data-driven approaches to improve the performance of the branch-and-cut algorithm, a widely used technique in the field of integer programming. The ideas presented in this work could inspire further advancements in the integration of machine learning and optimization and the development of more efficient solvers for complex real-world problems.
Conclusion
This paper proposes a data-driven approach to selecting effective cutting planes in the branch-and-cut algorithm, a widely used method for solving large-scale integer programming problems. The key idea is to leverage machine learning techniques to identify the cut generating function (CGF) that is likely to produce the smallest branch-and-bound tree for a given distribution of problem instances.
The researchers provide rigorous theoretical guarantees on the sample complexity of this approach, ensuring that the selected CGF will perform well with high probability. They also explore the use of neural networks for instance-dependent CGF selection, which can further improve the efficiency of the branch-and-cut algorithm.
The empirical results demonstrate that the data-driven CGF selection can outperform the traditional Gomory Mixed-Integer (GMI) cuts, suggesting that the proposed framework has the potential to significantly enhance the solving of large-scale integer programming problems in practice. This work highlights the benefits of integrating machine learning and optimization techniques to tackle complex real-world challenges.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
New!Learning to Remove Cuts in Integer Linear Programming
Pol Puigdemont, Stratis Skoulakis, Grigorios Chrysos, Volkan Cevher
0
0
Cutting plane methods are a fundamental approach for solving integer linear programs (ILPs). In each iteration of such methods, additional linear constraints (cuts) are introduced to the constraint set with the aim of excluding the previous fractional optimal solution while not affecting the optimal integer solution. In this work, we explore a novel approach within cutting plane methods: instead of only adding new cuts, we also consider the removal of previous cuts introduced at any of the preceding iterations of the method under a learnable parametric criteria. We demonstrate that in fundamental combinatorial optimization settings such cut removal policies can lead to significant improvements over both human-based and machine learning-guided cut addition policies even when implemented with simple models.
6/28/2024
Sample Complexity of Algorithm Selection Using Neural Networks and Its Applications to Branch-and-Cut
Hongyu Cheng, Sammy Khalife, Barbara Fiedorowicz, Amitabh Basu
0
0
Data-driven algorithm design is a paradigm that uses statistical and machine learning techniques to select from a class of algorithms for a computational problem an algorithm that has the best expected performance with respect to some (unknown) distribution on the instances of the problem. We build upon recent work in this line of research by considering the setup where, instead of selecting a single algorithm that has the best performance, we allow the possibility of selecting an algorithm based on the instance to be solved, using neural networks. In particular, given a representative sample of instances, we learn a neural network that maps an instance of the problem to the most appropriate algorithm for that instance. We formalize this idea and derive rigorous sample complexity bounds for this learning problem, in the spirit of recent work in data-driven algorithm design. We then apply this approach to the problem of making good decisions in the branch-and-cut framework for mixed-integer optimization (e.g., which cut to add?). In other words, the neural network will take as input a mixed-integer optimization instance and output a decision that will result in a small branch-and-cut tree for that instance. Our computational results provide evidence that our particular way of using neural networks for cut selection can make a significant impact in reducing branch-and-cut tree sizes, compared to previous data-driven approaches.
6/5/2024
Learning to Cut via Hierarchical Sequence/Set Model for Efficient Mixed-Integer Programming
Jie Wang, Zhihai Wang, Xijun Li, Yufei Kuang, Zhihao Shi, Fangzhou Zhu, Mingxuan Yuan, Jia Zeng, Yongdong Zhang, Feng Wu
0
0
Cutting planes (cuts) play an important role in solving mixed-integer linear programs (MILPs), which formulate many important real-world applications. Cut selection heavily depends on (P1) which cuts to prefer and (P2) how many cuts to select. Although modern MILP solvers tackle (P1)-(P2) by human-designed heuristics, machine learning carries the potential to learn more effective heuristics. However, many existing learning-based methods learn which cuts to prefer, neglecting the importance of learning how many cuts to select. Moreover, we observe that (P3) what order of selected cuts to prefer significantly impacts the efficiency of MILP solvers as well. To address these challenges, we propose a novel hierarchical sequence/set model (HEM) to learn cut selection policies. Specifically, HEM is a bi-level model: (1) a higher-level module that learns how many cuts to select, (2) and a lower-level module -- that formulates the cut selection as a sequence/set to sequence learning problem -- to learn policies selecting an ordered subset with the cardinality determined by the higher-level module. To the best of our knowledge, HEM is the first data-driven methodology that well tackles (P1)-(P3) simultaneously. Experiments demonstrate that HEM significantly improves the efficiency of solving MILPs on eleven challenging MILP benchmarks, including two Huawei's real problems.
4/22/2024
🤿
Deep learning enhanced mixed integer optimization: Learning to reduce model dimensionality
Niki Triantafyllou, Maria M. Papathanasiou
0
0
This work introduces a framework to address the computational complexity inherent in Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP) models by harnessing the potential of deep learning. By employing deep learning, we construct problem-specific heuristics that identify and exploit common structures across MIP instances. We train deep learning models to estimate complicating binary variables for target MIP problem instances. The resulting reduced MIP models are solved using standard off-the-shelf solvers. We present an algorithm for generating synthetic data enhancing the robustness and generalizability of our models across diverse MIP instances. We compare the effectiveness of (a) feed-forward neural networks (ANN) and (b) convolutional neural networks (CNN). To enhance the framework's performance, we employ Bayesian optimization for hyperparameter tuning, aiming to maximize the occurrence of global optimum solutions. We apply this framework to a flow-based facility location allocation MIP formulation that describes long-term investment planning and medium-term tactical scheduling in a personalized medicine supply chain.
5/13/2024