Learning from Mistakes: a Weakly-supervised Method for Mitigating the Distribution Shift in Autonomous Vehicle Planning
2406.01544
0
0
Abstract
The planning problem constitutes a fundamental aspect of the autonomous driving framework. Recent strides in representation learning have empowered vehicles to comprehend their surrounding environments, thereby facilitating the integration of learning-based planning strategies. Among these approaches, Imitation Learning stands out due to its notable training efficiency. However, traditional Imitation Learning methodologies encounter challenges associated with the co-variate shift phenomenon. We propose Learn from Mistakes (LfM) as a remedy to address this issue. The essence of LfM lies in deploying a pre-trained planner across diverse scenarios. Instances where the planner deviates from its immediate objectives, such as maintaining a safe distance from obstacles or adhering to traffic rules, are flagged as mistakes. The environments corresponding to these mistakes are categorized as out-of-distribution states and compiled into a new dataset termed closed-loop mistakes dataset. Notably, the absence of expert annotations for the closed-loop data precludes the applicability of standard imitation learning approaches. To facilitate learning from the closed-loop mistakes, we introduce Validity Learning, a weakly supervised method, which aims to discern valid trajectories within the current environmental context. Experimental evaluations conducted on the InD and Nuplan datasets reveal substantial enhancements in closed-loop metrics such as Progress and Collision Rate, underscoring the effectiveness of the proposed methodology.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a weakly-supervised method to mitigate distribution shift in autonomous vehicle planning.
- Distribution shift occurs when the training data for a model differs from the real-world environment the model is deployed in, leading to performance degradation.
- The method aims to enable autonomous vehicles to learn from their own mistakes during deployment and adapt to new environments.
Plain English Explanation
Autonomous vehicles use machine learning models to plan their movements and navigate the world. However, these models can struggle when the real-world conditions differ from the data they were trained on. This is known as the "distribution shift" problem.
The researchers in this paper developed a new technique to help autonomous vehicles adapt to these changing conditions. Their key idea is to let the vehicles "learn from their mistakes" during real-world driving.
Normally, autonomous vehicles are trained on large datasets collected in advance. But this training data may not capture all the complex situations the vehicle will encounter in the real world. The new method allows the vehicle to continuously update its model based on the mistakes it makes during operation.
This builds on prior work in areas like ,[object Object], LASIL: Learner-Aware Supervised Imitation Learning, and Can Vehicle Motion Planning Generalize to Realistic Environments?.
The goal is to enable autonomous vehicles to become more robust and adaptable, so they can handle a wider range of driving scenarios safely and effectively. This could help accelerate the deployment of self-driving technology and make it more reliable in the real world.
Technical Explanation
The core of the proposed method is a weakly-supervised learning framework that allows the autonomous vehicle to refine its motion planning model during deployment.
The vehicle starts with an initial motion planning model trained on offline data. During deployment, the vehicle continuously monitors its own performance and detects when it makes a "mistake" - i.e. when its planned trajectory deviates significantly from the optimal one.
This builds on prior work in areas like ,[object Object] and Evaluating Uncertainty-based Failure Detection in Closed-Loop Control.
When a mistake is detected, the vehicle uses a weakly-supervised learning procedure to update its motion planning model. This involves generating pseudo-labels for the mistake regions and retraining the model to better handle those situations.
The experiments show this approach can significantly improve the vehicle's performance on challenging test scenarios that differ from the original training data. The vehicle is able to adapt and generalize better to new environments.
Critical Analysis
The proposed method represents an important step towards making autonomous vehicles more robust and adaptable. By enabling the vehicle to learn from its own mistakes during deployment, it can overcome limitations in the initial training data.
However, the paper does not fully address potential safety concerns with this approach. Relying on the vehicle to detect its own mistakes and perform unsupervised updates could introduce new failure modes if the mistake detection is unreliable. Further research is needed to ensure the safety and reliability of this approach.
Additionally, the experiments focus on a relatively limited set of test scenarios. More comprehensive real-world testing would be required to validate the broader applicability of this method. There may also be opportunities to further build on this work by incorporating ideas from ,[object Object].
Overall, this paper presents a promising direction for enhancing the robustness of autonomous vehicle planning, but additional research and validation is needed before widespread deployment.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new weakly-supervised learning method to help autonomous vehicles adapt to distribution shift during real-world deployment. By enabling the vehicles to learn from their own mistakes, the approach aims to improve the generalization and robustness of motion planning models.
The experiments demonstrate the potential of this technique to boost performance on challenging test scenarios. However, further work is needed to fully address safety and reliability concerns, as well as validate the method's broader applicability.
If successfully implemented, this type of adaptive learning capability could be a key enabler for the large-scale deployment of reliable, safe, and adaptable autonomous driving technology.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
Beyond Imitation: A Life-long Policy Learning Framework for Path Tracking Control of Autonomous Driving
C. Gong, C. Lu, Z. Li, Z. Liu, J. Gong, X. Chen
0
0
Model-free learning-based control methods have recently shown significant advantages over traditional control methods in avoiding complex vehicle characteristic estimation and parameter tuning. As a primary policy learning method, imitation learning (IL) is capable of learning control policies directly from expert demonstrations. However, the performance of IL policies is highly dependent on the data sufficiency and quality of the demonstrations. To alleviate the above problems of IL-based policies, a lifelong policy learning (LLPL) framework is proposed in this paper, which extends the IL scheme with lifelong learning (LLL). First, a novel IL-based model-free control policy learning method for path tracking is introduced. Even with imperfect demonstration, the optimal control policy can be learned directly from historical driving data. Second, by using the LLL method, the pre-trained IL policy can be safely updated and fine-tuned with incremental execution knowledge. Third, a knowledge evaluation method for policy learning is introduced to avoid learning redundant or inferior knowledge, thus ensuring the performance improvement of online policy learning. Experiments are conducted using a high-fidelity vehicle dynamic model in various scenarios to evaluate the performance of the proposed method. The results show that the proposed LLPL framework can continuously improve the policy performance with collected incremental driving data, and achieves the best accuracy and control smoothness compared to other baseline methods after evolving on a 7 km curved road. Through learning and evaluation with noisy real-life data collected in an off-road environment, the proposed LLPL framework also demonstrates its applicability in learning and evolving in real-life scenarios.
4/29/2024
LASIL: Learner-Aware Supervised Imitation Learning For Long-term Microscopic Traffic Simulation
Ke Guo, Zhenwei Miao, Wei Jing, Weiwei Liu, Weizi Li, Dayang Hao, Jia Pan
0
0
Microscopic traffic simulation plays a crucial role in transportation engineering by providing insights into individual vehicle behavior and overall traffic flow. However, creating a realistic simulator that accurately replicates human driving behaviors in various traffic conditions presents significant challenges. Traditional simulators relying on heuristic models often fail to deliver accurate simulations due to the complexity of real-world traffic environments. Due to the covariate shift issue, existing imitation learning-based simulators often fail to generate stable long-term simulations. In this paper, we propose a novel approach called learner-aware supervised imitation learning to address the covariate shift problem in multi-agent imitation learning. By leveraging a variational autoencoder simultaneously modeling the expert and learner state distribution, our approach augments expert states such that the augmented state is aware of learner state distribution. Our method, applied to urban traffic simulation, demonstrates significant improvements over existing state-of-the-art baselines in both short-term microscopic and long-term macroscopic realism when evaluated on the real-world dataset pNEUMA.
5/24/2024
Can Vehicle Motion Planning Generalize to Realistic Long-tail Scenarios?
Marcel Hallgarten, Julian Zapata, Martin Stoll, Katrin Renz, Andreas Zell
0
0
Real-world autonomous driving systems must make safe decisions in the face of rare and diverse traffic scenarios. Current state-of-the-art planners are mostly evaluated on real-world datasets like nuScenes (open-loop) or nuPlan (closed-loop). In particular, nuPlan seems to be an expressive evaluation method since it is based on real-world data and closed-loop, yet it mostly covers basic driving scenarios. This makes it difficult to judge a planner's capabilities to generalize to rarely-seen situations. Therefore, we propose a novel closed-loop benchmark interPlan containing several edge cases and challenging driving scenarios. We assess existing state-of-the-art planners on our benchmark and show that neither rule-based nor learning-based planners can safely navigate the interPlan scenarios. A recently evolving direction is the usage of foundation models like large language models (LLM) to handle generalization. We evaluate an LLM-only planner and introduce a novel hybrid planner that combines an LLM-based behavior planner with a rule-based motion planner that achieves state-of-the-art performance on our benchmark.
4/12/2024
Towards Scalable & Efficient Interaction-Aware Planning in Autonomous Vehicles using Knowledge Distillation
Piyush Gupta, David Isele, Sangjae Bae
0
0
Real-world driving involves intricate interactions among vehicles navigating through dense traffic scenarios. Recent research focuses on enhancing the interaction awareness of autonomous vehicles to leverage these interactions in decision-making. These interaction-aware planners rely on neural-network-based prediction models to capture inter-vehicle interactions, aiming to integrate these predictions with traditional control techniques such as Model Predictive Control. However, this integration of deep learning-based models with traditional control paradigms often results in computationally demanding optimization problems, relying on heuristic methods. This study introduces a principled and efficient method for combining deep learning with constrained optimization, employing knowledge distillation to train smaller and more efficient networks, thereby mitigating complexity. We demonstrate that these refined networks maintain the problem-solving efficacy of larger models while significantly accelerating optimization. Specifically, in the domain of interaction-aware trajectory planning for autonomous vehicles, we illustrate that training a smaller prediction network using knowledge distillation speeds up optimization without sacrificing accuracy.
4/3/2024