Learning from String Sequences

Read original: arXiv:2405.06301 - Published 5/13/2024 by David Lindsay, Sian Lindsay

🤷

Overview

The paper introduces the Universal Similarity Metric (USM) as an alternative distance metric for K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN) learning on variable-length sequence data.
The USM-based K-NN learner is compared to the commonly used string-to-word vector approach on two datasets: spam email filtering and protein subcellular localization.
The results show that the USM-based K-NN learner provides higher classification accuracy and can generate reliable probability forecasts.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at a new way of measuring how similar two pieces of data are, called the Universal Similarity Metric (USM). This metric is useful for machine learning tasks that involve comparing variable-length sequences of data, like text or DNA sequences.

The researchers used the USM as part of a K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN) machine learning model. K-NN is a technique that classifies new data by looking at the 'nearest neighbours' - the most similar pieces of data in the training set. By using the USM instead of the more common 'string-to-word vector' approach, the K-NN model was able to make more accurate predictions on two very different datasets: identifying spam emails and predicting where proteins are located inside cells.

The key benefits of the USM-based K-NN approach are:

Higher classification accuracy compared to string-to-word vector methods
The ability to provide reliable probability estimates for the predictions, not just binary classifications

This shows the USM can be a powerful alternative to existing techniques for working with variable-length sequence data in machine learning.

Technical Explanation

The paper evaluates the use of the Universal Similarity Metric (USM) as a distance metric in a K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN) classifier, compared to the commonly used string-to-word vector approach.

The researchers conducted experiments on two real-world datasets:

Spam email filtering
Protein subcellular localization

For each dataset, they trained and evaluated both a USM-based K-NN model and a string-to-word vector K-NN model. The USM is a recently developed technique that can effectively measure similarity between variable-length sequences, in contrast to the fixed-length word vector representations.

The results show that the USM-based K-NN learner outperformed the string-to-word vector approach in terms of classification accuracy. Importantly, the USM-based model was also able to generate reliable probability forecasts, rather than just binary classifications.

The paper demonstrates the benefits of using more sophisticated similarity metrics like the USM for tasks involving variable-length sequence data, compared to the limitations of simpler string-based representations.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a convincing proof-of-concept for using the USM as an effective distance metric in K-NN learning. However, a few caveats and areas for further research are worth noting:

The experiments were limited to two specific datasets. More extensive testing on a wider range of real-world sequence data would be needed to fully validate the generalizability of the USM-based approach.
The paper does not deeply explore the limitations or failure cases of the USM metric itself. Potential issues with similarity metrics should be investigated further.
While the probability forecasting capability of the USM-based K-NN is highlighted as a benefit, the paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the reliability and calibration of these probability estimates.
Combining the USM with other advanced techniques for time series similarity or text similarity could potentially yield even stronger performance.

Overall, this paper makes a promising case for the USM as an effective distance metric, but additional research is needed to fully understand its strengths, weaknesses, and optimal applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces the use of the Universal Similarity Metric (USM) as an alternative distance metric in K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN) learning for variable-length sequence data. Experiments on spam email filtering and protein subcellular localization datasets show that the USM-based K-NN learner outperforms the common string-to-word vector approach in terms of classification accuracy and probability forecasting capabilities.

The findings highlight the benefits of using more sophisticated similarity metrics like the USM when working with complex, variable-length sequence data in machine learning. While further research is needed, this paper demonstrates the potential for the USM to enable more effective pattern recognition and prediction across a range of real-world applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤷

Learning from String Sequences

David Lindsay, Sian Lindsay

The Universal Similarity Metric (USM) has been demonstrated to give practically useful measures of similarity between sequence data. Here we have used the USM as an alternative distance metric in a K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN) learner to allow effective pattern recognition of variable length sequence data. We compare this USM approach with the commonly used string-to-word vector approach. Our experiments have used two data sets of divergent domains: (1) spam email filtering and (2) protein subcellular localization. Our results with this data reveal that the USM-based K-NN learner (1) gives predictions with higher classification accuracy than those output by techniques that use the string-to-word vector approach, and (2) can be used to generate reliable probability forecasts.

5/13/2024

Automated Similarity Metric Generation for Recommendation

Liang Qu, Yun Lin, Wei Yuan, Xiaojun Wan, Yuhui Shi, Hongzhi Yin

The embedding-based architecture has become the dominant approach in modern recommender systems, mapping users and items into a compact vector space. It then employs predefined similarity metrics, such as the inner product, to calculate similarity scores between user and item embeddings, thereby guiding the recommendation of items that align closely with a user's preferences. Given the critical role of similarity metrics in recommender systems, existing methods mainly employ handcrafted similarity metrics to capture the complex characteristics of user-item interactions. Yet, handcrafted metrics may not fully capture the diverse range of similarity patterns that can significantly vary across different domains. To address this issue, we propose an Automated Similarity Metric Generation method for recommendations, named AutoSMG, which can generate tailored similarity metrics for various domains and datasets. Specifically, we first construct a similarity metric space by sampling from a set of basic embedding operators, which are then integrated into computational graphs to represent metrics. We employ an evolutionary algorithm to search for the optimal metrics within this metric space iteratively. To improve search efficiency, we utilize an early stopping strategy and a surrogate model to approximate the performance of candidate metrics instead of fully training models. Notably, our proposed method is model-agnostic, which can seamlessly plugin into different recommendation model architectures. The proposed method is validated on three public recommendation datasets across various domains in the Top-K recommendation task, and experimental results demonstrate that AutoSMG outperforms both commonly used handcrafted metrics and those generated by other search strategies.

4/19/2024

A Universal Metric of Dataset Similarity for Cross-silo Federated Learning

Ahmed Elhussein, Gamze Gursoy

Federated Learning is increasingly used in domains such as healthcare to facilitate collaborative model training without data-sharing. However, datasets located in different sites are often non-identically distributed, leading to degradation of model performance in FL. Most existing methods for assessing these distribution shifts are limited by being dataset or task-specific. Moreover, these metrics can only be calculated by exchanging data, a practice restricted in many FL scenarios. To address these challenges, we propose a novel metric for assessing dataset similarity. Our metric exhibits several desirable properties for FL: it is dataset-agnostic, is calculated in a privacy-preserving manner, and is computationally efficient, requiring no model training. In this paper, we first establish a theoretical connection between our metric and training dynamics in FL. Next, we extensively evaluate our metric on a range of datasets including synthetic, benchmark, and medical imaging datasets. We demonstrate that our metric shows a robust and interpretable relationship with model performance and can be calculated in privacy-preserving manner. As the first federated dataset similarity metric, we believe this metric can better facilitate successful collaborations between sites.

4/30/2024

Efficient Retrieval with Learned Similarities

Bailu Ding, Jiaqi Zhai

Retrieval plays a fundamental role in recommendation systems, search, and natural language processing by efficiently finding relevant items from a large corpus given a query. Dot products have been widely used as the similarity function in such retrieval tasks, thanks to Maximum Inner Product Search (MIPS) that enabled efficient retrieval based on dot products. However, state-of-the-art retrieval algorithms have migrated to learned similarities. Such algorithms vary in form; the queries can be represented with multiple embeddings, complex neural networks can be deployed, the item ids can be decoded directly from queries using beam search, and multiple approaches can be combined in hybrid solutions. Unfortunately, we lack efficient solutions for retrieval in these state-of-the-art setups. Our work investigates techniques for approximate nearest neighbor search with learned similarity functions. We first prove that Mixture-of-Logits (MoL) is a universal approximator, and can express all learned similarity functions. We next propose techniques to retrieve the approximate top K results using MoL with a tight bound. We finally compare our techniques with existing approaches, showing that MoL sets new state-of-the-art results on recommendation retrieval tasks, and our approximate top-k retrieval with learned similarities outperforms baselines by up to two orders of magnitude in latency, while achieving > .99 recall rate of exact algorithms.

8/15/2024