Learning to grok: Emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in modular arithmetic tasks
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This research paper explores the emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in modular arithmetic tasks using large language models.
- The study examines how models can learn to "grok" the underlying principles of modular arithmetic through exposure to relevant tasks, without explicit training on those principles.
- The findings offer insights into the capabilities and limitations of language models in learning compositional skills and generalizing knowledge to new contexts.
Plain English Explanation
The paper investigates how large language models, such as those used for tasks like text generation and question answering, can learn to understand and apply the principles of modular arithmetic. Modular arithmetic is a type of mathematics that deals with numbers and operations that "wrap around" a fixed value, like the hours on a clock.
The researchers found that when these models are trained on a variety of modular arithmetic problems, they can start to "grok" or intuitively grasp the underlying rules, even without being explicitly taught them. This suggests that language models have the potential to learn compositional skills - the ability to combine and apply different concepts in novel ways - simply by being exposed to relevant information and tasks.
However, the paper also highlights limitations in the models' ability to fully generalize this knowledge. While they can apply what they've learned to new problems within the same context, they struggle to adapt their skills to significantly different types of modular arithmetic tasks. This points to challenges in building models that can truly understand and flexibly apply mathematical and logical principles.
Overall, the research provides valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of current language models when it comes to learning and composing complex skills. It suggests exciting possibilities for models that can intuitively grasp underlying principles, but also highlights the need for continued advancements to achieve more robust and broadly applicable learning abilities.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in large language models trained on modular arithmetic tasks. The researchers design a series of experiments where models are exposed to a variety of modular arithmetic problems, without being explicitly taught the underlying rules and principles.
Through this training process, the models are able to "grok" the concepts of modular arithmetic, demonstrating an intuitive understanding of how to solve new problems within the same context. This suggests that language models have the potential to learn compositional skills - the ability to combine and flexibly apply different concepts - simply by being exposed to relevant information and tasks, rather than requiring explicit instruction.
The paper also explores the limitations of this in-context learning. While the models can generalize their skills within the same modular arithmetic context, they struggle to adapt those skills to significantly different types of modular arithmetic tasks. This points to challenges in building models that can truly understand and flexibly apply mathematical and logical principles, rather than just memorizing patterns.
The findings of this research offer important insights into the capabilities and limitations of current language models when it comes to learning and composing complex skills. The ability to grok underlying principles through exposure is an exciting capability, but the lack of robust generalization highlights the need for continued advancements to achieve more flexible and adaptable learning abilities.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of current language models in learning and composing complex skills. The researchers' findings suggest that these models have the potential to intuitively grasp underlying principles, such as the rules of modular arithmetic, through exposure to relevant tasks. This is an exciting capability that could have significant implications for how we approach teaching and learning, both for humans and machines.
However, the paper also highlights the challenges in achieving truly flexible and generalizable learning. While the models can apply their skills within the same context, they struggle to adapt those skills to significantly different types of modular arithmetic tasks. This points to a need for further research and advancements to build models that can understand and apply logical and mathematical principles more robustly.
One potential area for further exploration is the role of task diversity and the structure of training data in enabling more flexible learning. The research on context learning and generalization suggests that the breadth and structure of the training data can have a significant impact on a model's ability to generalize its skills. Investigating how to curate training data to foster more robust compositional learning could be a fruitful direction.
Additionally, the paper's findings align with other research on the limitations of transformer language models in learning to compose and the challenges of multi-task training. These studies suggest that while language models can excel at certain tasks, they may struggle to truly understand and flexibly apply higher-level principles and reasoning. Exploring architectural and training innovations to address these limitations could be a valuable area of future research.
Overall, this paper provides important insights into the capabilities and limitations of current language models when it comes to learning and composing complex skills. While the ability to grok underlying principles is an exciting development, the lack of robust generalization highlights the need for continued advancements to achieve more flexible and adaptable learning abilities.
Conclusion
The research paper "Learning to grok: Emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in modular arithmetic tasks" explores the intriguing possibility that large language models can learn to intuitively grasp the underlying principles of modular arithmetic through exposure to relevant tasks, without explicit training.
The study's findings suggest that these models have the potential to learn compositional skills - the ability to combine and apply different concepts in novel ways - simply by being exposed to relevant information and tasks. This points to exciting possibilities for how we approach teaching and learning, both for humans and machines.
However, the paper also highlights the limitations of this in-context learning, as the models struggle to adapt their skills to significantly different types of modular arithmetic tasks. This suggests that while language models can excel at certain tasks, they may still face challenges in truly understanding and flexibly applying higher-level principles and reasoning.
Overall, this research provides valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of current language models when it comes to learning and composing complex skills. It suggests that continued advancements in areas like model architecture and training methods will be crucial to achieving more robust and broadly applicable learning abilities in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Learning to grok: Emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in modular arithmetic tasks
Tianyu He, Darshil Doshi, Aritra Das, Andrey Gromov
Large language models can solve tasks that were not present in the training set. This capability is believed to be due to in-context learning and skill composition. In this work, we study the emergence of in-context learning and skill composition in a collection of modular arithmetic tasks. Specifically, we consider a finite collection of linear modular functions $z = a , x + b , y ;mathrm{mod}; p$ labeled by the vector $(a, b) in mathbb{Z}_p^2$. We use some of these tasks for pre-training and the rest for out-of-distribution testing. We empirically show that a GPT-style transformer exhibits a transition from in-distribution to out-of-distribution generalization as the number of pre-training tasks increases. We find that the smallest model capable of out-of-distribution generalization requires two transformer blocks, while for deeper models, the out-of-distribution generalization phase is emph{transient}, necessitating early stopping. Finally, we perform an interpretability study of the pre-trained models, revealing the highly structured representations in both phases; and discuss the learnt algorithm.
Read more6/5/2024
✨
0
When can transformers compositionally generalize in-context?
Seijin Kobayashi, Simon Schug, Yassir Akram, Florian Redhardt, Johannes von Oswald, Razvan Pascanu, Guillaume Lajoie, Jo~ao Sacramento
Many tasks can be composed from a few independent components. This gives rise to a combinatorial explosion of possible tasks, only some of which might be encountered during training. Under what circumstances can transformers compositionally generalize from a subset of tasks to all possible combinations of tasks that share similar components? Here we study a modular multitask setting that allows us to precisely control compositional structure in the data generation process. We present evidence that transformers learning in-context struggle to generalize compositionally on this task despite being in principle expressive enough to do so. Compositional generalization becomes possible only when introducing a bottleneck that enforces an explicit separation between task inference and task execution.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Asymptotic theory of in-context learning by linear attention
Yue M. Lu, Mary I. Letey, Jacob A. Zavatone-Veth, Anindita Maiti, Cengiz Pehlevan
Transformers have a remarkable ability to learn and execute tasks based on examples provided within the input itself, without explicit prior training. It has been argued that this capability, known as in-context learning (ICL), is a cornerstone of Transformers' success, yet questions about the necessary sample complexity, pretraining task diversity, and context length for successful ICL remain unresolved. Here, we provide a precise answer to these questions in an exactly solvable model of ICL of a linear regression task by linear attention. We derive sharp asymptotics for the learning curve in a phenomenologically-rich scaling regime where the token dimension is taken to infinity; the context length and pretraining task diversity scale proportionally with the token dimension; and the number of pretraining examples scales quadratically. We demonstrate a double-descent learning curve with increasing pretraining examples, and uncover a phase transition in the model's behavior between low and high task diversity regimes: In the low diversity regime, the model tends toward memorization of training tasks, whereas in the high diversity regime, it achieves genuine in-context learning and generalization beyond the scope of pretrained tasks. These theoretical insights are empirically validated through experiments with both linear attention and full nonlinear Transformer architectures.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Out-of-distribution generalization via composition: a lens through induction heads in Transformers
Jiajun Song, Zhuoyan Xu, Yiqiao Zhong
Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 sometimes appear to be creative, solving novel tasks often with a few demonstrations in the prompt. These tasks require the models to generalize on distributions different from those from training data -- which is known as out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization. Despite the tremendous success of LLMs, how they approach OOD generalization remains an open and underexplored question. We examine OOD generalization in settings where instances are generated according to hidden rules, including in-context learning with symbolic reasoning. Models are required to infer the hidden rules behind input prompts without any fine-tuning. We empirically examined the training dynamics of Transformers on a synthetic example and conducted extensive experiments on a variety of pretrained LLMs, focusing on a type of components known as induction heads. We found that OOD generalization and composition are tied together -- models can learn rules by composing two self-attention layers, thereby achieving OOD generalization. Furthermore, a shared latent subspace in the embedding (or feature) space acts as a bridge for composition by aligning early layers and later layers, which we refer to as the common bridge representation hypothesis.
Read more8/20/2024