Learning to Receive Help: Intervention-Aware Concept Embedding Models
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces "intervention-aware concept embedding models" - a new approach to machine learning that aims to improve the ability of models to learn from and provide helpful interventions.
- The key idea is to explicitly model how concepts are affected by interventions, allowing models to better understand how to provide useful assistance.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach through experiments on various tasks, showing improvements over standard concept bottleneck models.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new way of training machine learning models to be better at providing helpful assistance. Standard models often struggle to understand how their actions will impact the underlying concepts or knowledge they are working with. 1
The researchers' approach, called "intervention-aware concept embedding models", aims to explicitly model how different concepts are affected by potential interventions or actions the model could take. 2 This allows the model to better anticipate the consequences of its choices and select interventions that will be most effective.
For example, imagine a model trying to help a student learn a new math concept. A standard model might struggle to predict how its explanations or hints would actually impact the student's understanding. But an intervention-aware model could learn how different teaching strategies tend to affect the student's grasp of the core mathematical ideas. 3 This would enable it to provide more tailored and impactful assistance.
The paper demonstrates through experiments that this intervention-aware approach leads to better performance on various tasks compared to traditional concept bottleneck models. 4 This suggests it could be a valuable technique for building AI systems that are more effective at providing useful help and support.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces "intervention-aware concept embedding models", which build on the idea of concept bottleneck models. 5 Concept bottleneck models try to learn a mid-level representation of high-level concepts, which can then be used to make predictions.
The key innovation in the intervention-aware models is that they explicitly model how these mid-level concepts are affected by potential interventions or actions the model could take. This is done by learning a mapping from the concept representations to a distribution over how the concepts would change under different interventions. 6
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach through experiments on tasks like image classification, where the model needs to provide helpful hints to users, and causal discovery, where the model must infer the effects of potential interventions. 7 Compared to standard concept bottleneck models, the intervention-aware models show improved performance, suggesting they are better able to reason about the consequences of their actions.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising new direction for building more helpful and effective AI systems. By explicitly modeling the relationship between concepts and interventions, these models can better anticipate the impact of their actions and provide more useful assistance.
One potential limitation is that the approach requires additional modeling complexity to capture the intervention-concept relationships. 8 This could make the models more challenging to train and scale, especially for domains with a large number of possible interventions.
Additionally, the paper focuses on relatively simple, well-defined tasks. It would be valuable to see how well the intervention-aware approach generalizes to more open-ended, real-world settings where the space of possible interventions is less constrained. 9 Further research is needed to understand the limitations and tradeoffs of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an innovative new technique for building machine learning models that are better able to learn from and provide helpful interventions. By explicitly modeling the relationship between concepts and the effects of potential actions, intervention-aware models can make more informed choices and deliver more impactful assistance. 10
While further research is needed to fully understand the strengths and weaknesses of this approach, the results presented in the paper suggest it could be a valuable tool for developing AI systems that are more effective at supporting and collaborating with users. As AI becomes increasingly prevalent in our lives, techniques like this that enhance the helpfulness and reliability of these systems will be crucial.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Learning to Receive Help: Intervention-Aware Concept Embedding Models
Mateo Espinosa Zarlenga, Katherine M. Collins, Krishnamurthy Dvijotham, Adrian Weller, Zohreh Shams, Mateja Jamnik
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) tackle the opacity of neural architectures by constructing and explaining their predictions using a set of high-level concepts. A special property of these models is that they permit concept interventions, wherein users can correct mispredicted concepts and thus improve the model's performance. Recent work, however, has shown that intervention efficacy can be highly dependent on the order in which concepts are intervened on and on the model's architecture and training hyperparameters. We argue that this is rooted in a CBM's lack of train-time incentives for the model to be appropriately receptive to concept interventions. To address this, we propose Intervention-aware Concept Embedding models (IntCEMs), a novel CBM-based architecture and training paradigm that improves a model's receptiveness to test-time interventions. Our model learns a concept intervention policy in an end-to-end fashion from where it can sample meaningful intervention trajectories at train-time. This conditions IntCEMs to effectively select and receive concept interventions when deployed at test-time. Our experiments show that IntCEMs significantly outperform state-of-the-art concept-interpretable models when provided with test-time concept interventions, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach.
Read more9/27/2024
0
Improving Intervention Efficacy via Concept Realignment in Concept Bottleneck Models
Nishad Singhi, Jae Myung Kim, Karsten Roth, Zeynep Akata
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) ground image classification on human-understandable concepts to allow for interpretable model decisions. Crucially, the CBM design inherently allows for human interventions, in which expert users are given the ability to modify potentially misaligned concept choices to influence the decision behavior of the model in an interpretable fashion. However, existing approaches often require numerous human interventions per image to achieve strong performances, posing practical challenges in scenarios where obtaining human feedback is expensive. In this paper, we find that this is noticeably driven by an independent treatment of concepts during intervention, wherein a change of one concept does not influence the use of other ones in the model's final decision. To address this issue, we introduce a trainable concept intervention realignment module, which leverages concept relations to realign concept assignments post-intervention. Across standard, real-world benchmarks, we find that concept realignment can significantly improve intervention efficacy; significantly reducing the number of interventions needed to reach a target classification performance or concept prediction accuracy. In addition, it easily integrates into existing concept-based architectures without requiring changes to the models themselves. This reduced cost of human-model collaboration is crucial to enhancing the feasibility of CBMs in resource-constrained environments. Our code is available at: https://github.com/ExplainableML/concept_realignment.
Read more8/7/2024
🔄
0
Learning to Intervene on Concept Bottlenecks
David Steinmann, Wolfgang Stammer, Felix Friedrich, Kristian Kersting
While deep learning models often lack interpretability, concept bottleneck models (CBMs) provide inherent explanations via their concept representations. Moreover, they allow users to perform interventional interactions on these concepts by updating the concept values and thus correcting the predictive output of the model. Up to this point, these interventions were typically applied to the model just once and then discarded. To rectify this, we present concept bottleneck memory models (CB2Ms), which keep a memory of past interventions. Specifically, CB2Ms leverage a two-fold memory to generalize interventions to appropriate novel situations, enabling the model to identify errors and reapply previous interventions. This way, a CB2M learns to automatically improve model performance from a few initially obtained interventions. If no prior human interventions are available, a CB2M can detect potential mistakes of the CBM bottleneck and request targeted interventions. Our experimental evaluations on challenging scenarios like handling distribution shifts and confounded data demonstrate that CB2Ms are able to successfully generalize interventions to unseen data and can indeed identify wrongly inferred concepts. Hence, CB2Ms are a valuable tool for users to provide interactive feedback on CBMs, by guiding a user's interaction and requiring fewer interventions.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Evidential Concept Embedding Models: Towards Reliable Concept Explanations for Skin Disease Diagnosis
Yibo Gao, Zheyao Gao, Xin Gao, Yuanye Liu, Bomin Wang, Xiahai Zhuang
Due to the high stakes in medical decision-making, there is a compelling demand for interpretable deep learning methods in medical image analysis. Concept Bottleneck Models (CBM) have emerged as an active interpretable framework incorporating human-interpretable concepts into decision-making. However, their concept predictions may lack reliability when applied to clinical diagnosis, impeding concept explanations' quality. To address this, we propose an evidential Concept Embedding Model (evi-CEM), which employs evidential learning to model the concept uncertainty. Additionally, we offer to leverage the concept uncertainty to rectify concept misalignments that arise when training CBMs using vision-language models without complete concept supervision. With the proposed methods, we can enhance concept explanations' reliability for both supervised and label-efficient settings. Furthermore, we introduce concept uncertainty for effective test-time intervention. Our evaluation demonstrates that evi-CEM achieves superior performance in terms of concept prediction, and the proposed concept rectification effectively mitigates concept misalignments for label-efficient training. Our code is available at https://github.com/obiyoag/evi-CEM.
Read more6/28/2024