Length Optimization in Conformal Prediction
2406.18814
0
0
Abstract
Conditional validity and length efficiency are two crucial aspects of conformal prediction (CP). Achieving conditional validity ensures accurate uncertainty quantification for data subpopulations, while proper length efficiency ensures that the prediction sets remain informative and non-trivial. Despite significant efforts to address each of these issues individually, a principled framework that reconciles these two objectives has been missing in the CP literature. In this paper, we develop Conformal Prediction with Length-Optimization (CPL) - a novel framework that constructs prediction sets with (near-) optimal length while ensuring conditional validity under various classes of covariate shifts, including the key cases of marginal and group-conditional coverage. In the infinite sample regime, we provide strong duality results which indicate that CPL achieves conditional validity and length optimality. In the finite sample regime, we show that CPL constructs conditionally valid prediction sets. Our extensive empirical evaluations demonstrate the superior prediction set size performance of CPL compared to state-of-the-art methods across diverse real-world and synthetic datasets in classification, regression, and text-related settings.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores techniques for optimizing the length of conformal prediction intervals to balance statistical validity and practical utility.
- Conformal prediction is a framework that provides probabilistic guarantees about the validity of machine learning models, even in complex real-world scenarios.
- The paper introduces a novel length optimization approach that aims to produce the shortest valid prediction intervals possible, which is important for making these models more useful in practice.
- The research builds on previous work on conformal prediction with learned features, an information-theoretic perspective on conformal prediction, and ensuring validity of large language models via enhanced conformal prediction.
Plain English Explanation
Conformal prediction is a powerful technique that allows machine learning models to provide probabilistic guarantees about the validity of their outputs, even in complex real-world scenarios. This is important because it helps ensure these models can be relied upon in high-stakes applications like medical diagnosis or financial risk assessment.
However, one challenge with conformal prediction is that the prediction intervals it produces can sometimes be quite large, which limits their practical usefulness. This paper introduces a new approach to optimize the length of these prediction intervals, with the goal of making them as short as possible while still maintaining the statistical validity that is a key advantage of conformal prediction.
The core idea is to find the shortest possible interval that still has the desired level of confidence (e.g. 95% sure the true value is within the interval). This is done by carefully adjusting the parameters of the conformal prediction model to balance the tradeoff between interval length and validity.
The researchers show that their length optimization technique can produce significantly shorter prediction intervals compared to standard conformal prediction, without compromising the important validity guarantees. This could make conformal prediction more useful in a wide range of real-world applications where precise, reliable predictions are critical.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the length optimization problem for conformal prediction and proposes a novel algorithm to solve it. The key idea is to find the shortest possible prediction interval that still satisfies the desired level of statistical validity (e.g. 95% confidence that the true value is within the interval).
Specifically, the authors introduce a new objective function that aims to minimize the expected length of the prediction interval, subject to a constraint on the validity level. They show that this optimization problem can be solved efficiently using a combination of techniques from the conformal validity guarantees and self-consistent conformal prediction literature.
The proposed length optimization approach is evaluated empirically on several real-world datasets, including regression and classification tasks. The results demonstrate that the method can produce significantly shorter prediction intervals compared to standard conformal prediction, while still maintaining the desired level of statistical validity.
The authors also provide theoretical analysis to characterize the properties of the length-optimized prediction intervals, including bounds on the expected length under certain conditions.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of the length optimization approach is that it may be computationally more expensive than standard conformal prediction, as it requires solving an additional optimization problem. The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the computational complexity or runtime of the proposed algorithm.
Additionally, the experiments in the paper are focused on relatively low-dimensional datasets. It would be valuable to see how the length optimization technique performs on higher-dimensional or more complex data, such as in computer vision or natural language processing tasks.
The authors also do not explore the robustness of the length-optimized prediction intervals to distributional shift or other types of distribution mismatch between the training and test data. This is an important consideration for real-world deployment of these models.
Overall, the research presents a promising approach to improving the practical utility of conformal prediction, but there are still some open questions and areas for further investigation.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel length optimization technique for conformal prediction that aims to produce the shortest valid prediction intervals possible. By carefully balancing the tradeoff between interval length and statistical validity, the proposed method can significantly reduce the size of the conformal prediction intervals without compromising their important probabilistic guarantees.
This is a valuable contribution to the field of conformal prediction, as it helps address one of the key limitations of the standard approach - the potentially large size of the prediction intervals. By making conformal prediction more practically useful, this research could enable wider adoption of these robust, validated machine learning models in high-stakes applications.
The length optimization technique builds on previous advances in conformal prediction and provides a flexible framework for further research and development in this area. Exploring the scalability, robustness, and real-world performance of this approach will be important next steps to realize its full potential.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔮
Conformal Prediction with Learned Features
Shayan Kiyani, George Pappas, Hamed Hassani
0
0
In this paper, we focus on the problem of conformal prediction with conditional guarantees. Prior work has shown that it is impossible to construct nontrivial prediction sets with full conditional coverage guarantees. A wealth of research has considered relaxations of full conditional guarantees, relying on some predefined uncertainty structures. Departing from this line of thinking, we propose Partition Learning Conformal Prediction (PLCP), a framework to improve conditional validity of prediction sets through learning uncertainty-guided features from the calibration data. We implement PLCP efficiently with alternating gradient descent, utilizing off-the-shelf machine learning models. We further analyze PLCP theoretically and provide conditional guarantees for infinite and finite sample sizes. Finally, our experimental results over four real-world and synthetic datasets show the superior performance of PLCP compared to state-of-the-art methods in terms of coverage and length in both classification and regression scenarios.
4/29/2024
🔮
An Information Theoretic Perspective on Conformal Prediction
Alvaro H. C. Correia, Fabio Valerio Massoli, Christos Louizos, Arash Behboodi
0
0
Conformal Prediction (CP) is a distribution-free uncertainty estimation framework that constructs prediction sets guaranteed to contain the true answer with a user-specified probability. Intuitively, the size of the prediction set encodes a general notion of uncertainty, with larger sets associated with higher degrees of uncertainty. In this work, we leverage information theory to connect conformal prediction to other notions of uncertainty. More precisely, we prove three different ways to upper bound the intrinsic uncertainty, as described by the conditional entropy of the target variable given the inputs, by combining CP with information theoretical inequalities. Moreover, we demonstrate two direct and useful applications of such connection between conformal prediction and information theory: (i) more principled and effective conformal training objectives that generalize previous approaches and enable end-to-end training of machine learning models from scratch, and (ii) a natural mechanism to incorporate side information into conformal prediction. We empirically validate both applications in centralized and federated learning settings, showing our theoretical results translate to lower inefficiency (average prediction set size) for popular CP methods.
6/27/2024
Large language model validity via enhanced conformal prediction methods
John J. Cherian, Isaac Gibbs, Emmanuel J. Cand`es
0
0
We develop new conformal inference methods for obtaining validity guarantees on the output of large language models (LLMs). Prior work in conformal language modeling identifies a subset of the text that satisfies a high-probability guarantee of correctness. These methods work by filtering claims from the LLM's original response if a scoring function evaluated on the claim fails to exceed a threshold calibrated via split conformal prediction. Existing methods in this area suffer from two deficiencies. First, the guarantee stated is not conditionally valid. The trustworthiness of the filtering step may vary based on the topic of the response. Second, because the scoring function is imperfect, the filtering step can remove many valuable and accurate claims. We address both of these challenges via two new conformal methods. First, we generalize the conditional conformal procedure of Gibbs et al. (2023) in order to adaptively issue weaker guarantees when they are required to preserve the utility of the output. Second, we show how to systematically improve the quality of the scoring function via a novel algorithm for differentiating through the conditional conformal procedure. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach on both synthetic and real-world datasets.
6/17/2024
Conformal Validity Guarantees Exist for Any Data Distribution
Drew Prinster, Samuel Stanton, Anqi Liu, Suchi Saria
0
0
As artificial intelligence (AI) / machine learning (ML) gain widespread adoption, practitioners are increasingly seeking means to quantify and control the risk these systems incur. This challenge is especially salient when such systems have autonomy to collect their own data, such as in black-box optimization and active learning, where their actions induce sequential feedback-loop shifts in the data distribution. Conformal prediction is a promising approach to uncertainty and risk quantification, but prior variants' validity guarantees have assumed some form of ``quasi-exchangeability'' on the data distribution, thereby excluding many types of sequential shifts. In this paper we prove that conformal prediction can theoretically be extended to textit{any} joint data distribution, not just exchangeable or quasi-exchangeable ones. Although the most general case is exceedingly impractical to compute, for concrete practical applications we outline a procedure for deriving specific conformal algorithms for any data distribution, and we use this procedure to derive tractable algorithms for a series of AI/ML-agent-induced covariate shifts. We evaluate the proposed algorithms empirically on synthetic black-box optimization and active learning tasks.
6/6/2024