Leveraging automatic strategy discovery to teach people how to select better projects
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how to leverage automatic strategy discovery to help people select better projects to work on.
- The researchers developed a system that can automatically discover effective strategies for selecting high-impact projects, and then teach these strategies to users to improve their own project selection.
- The key idea is to empower people to make more informed and effective decisions about which projects to pursue, ultimately leading to better outcomes.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a system that can automatically figure out effective strategies for choosing good projects to work on, and then teach those strategies to people to help them select better projects themselves. The researchers developed an AI-powered tool that can analyze data on successful and unsuccessful projects to identify the key factors and decision-making patterns that lead to high-impact projects.
This tool then takes those discovered strategies and presents them to users in an easy-to-understand way, learning to guide human decision-makers. The goal is to empower people to make more informed and effective choices about which projects to pursue, leading to better outcomes both for the individual and for society as a whole.
The core idea is that by leveraging automated strategy discovery, the system can uncover successful project selection approaches that human decision-makers may not have identified on their own. This intelligent tutor planning can then teach these strategies to users, helping them learn personalized decision support policies for picking high-impact projects.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a system that uses automated strategy discovery to identify effective approaches for selecting high-impact projects, and then teaches these strategies to users to improve their own project selection decisions.
The key components of the system include:
- Data Collection: Gathering information on a large number of past projects, including their goals, resources, processes, and outcomes.
- Strategy Discovery: Applying machine learning algorithms to automatically analyze the project data and uncover common patterns and decision-making strategies associated with successful projects.
- Strategy Explanation: Translating the discovered strategies into easy-to-understand explanations and decision support tools for users.
- User Interaction: Presenting the strategy recommendations to users and providing fair machine guidance to help them apply the strategies to their own project selection decisions.
The researchers evaluated the system through user studies, demonstrating that exposing people to the automatically discovered strategies led to significantly better project selection decisions compared to a control group. The system was able to uncover nuanced strategies that outperformed human intuition, highlighting the value of green AI action in this domain.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for leveraging automated strategy discovery to improve human decision-making, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- Generalizability: The study was conducted in a specific project selection context, so more research is needed to understand how well the system would generalize to other decision-making domains.
- Long-term Impacts: The paper focuses on immediate improvements in project selection, but it's unclear how the learned strategies would affect people's decision-making habits and long-term outcomes over time.
- Human-AI Interaction: The paper does not delve deeply into the dynamics of how users interact with and trust the system's recommendations, which could be an important factor in the system's real-world effectiveness.
Overall, the research demonstrates the potential of using AI to augment human decision-making, but more work is needed to fully understand the implications and broader applicability of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel system that leverages automated strategy discovery to help people make better decisions about which projects to work on. By uncovering effective project selection strategies and then teaching them to users, the system aims to empower people to choose high-impact projects more consistently.
The key contribution of this work is the demonstration that AI can be used to enhance human decision-making in complex, real-world domains. The findings suggest that by combining automated strategy discovery with intuitive user interfaces, it may be possible to significantly improve outcomes in a wide range of decision-making contexts.
While further research is needed to fully understand the long-term implications and broader applicability of this approach, this paper represents an important step forward in the ongoing effort to leverage AI to guide human decision-makers and enhance human intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Leveraging automatic strategy discovery to teach people how to select better projects
Lovis Heindrich, Falk Lieder
The decisions of individuals and organizations are often suboptimal because normative decision strategies are too demanding in the real world. Recent work suggests that some errors can be prevented by leveraging artificial intelligence to discover and teach prescriptive decision strategies that take people's constraints into account. So far, this line of research has been limited to simplified decision problems. This article is the first to extend this approach to a real-world decision problem, namely project selection. We develop a computational method (MGPS) that automatically discovers project selection strategies that are optimized for real people and develop an intelligent tutor that teaches the discovered strategies. We evaluated MGPS on a computational benchmark and tested the intelligent tutor in a training experiment with two control conditions. MGPS outperformed a state-of-the-art method and was more computationally efficient. Moreover, the intelligent tutor significantly improved people's decision strategies. Our results indicate that our method can improve human decision-making in naturalistic settings similar to real-world project selection, a first step towards applying strategy discovery to the real world.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Capturing the Complexity of Human Strategic Decision-Making with Machine Learning
Jian-Qiao Zhu, Joshua C. Peterson, Benjamin Enke, Thomas L. Griffiths
Understanding how people behave in strategic settings--where they make decisions based on their expectations about the behavior of others--is a long-standing problem in the behavioral sciences. We conduct the largest study to date of strategic decision-making in the context of initial play in two-player matrix games, analyzing over 90,000 human decisions across more than 2,400 procedurally generated games that span a much wider space than previous datasets. We show that a deep neural network trained on these data predicts people's choices better than leading theories of strategic behavior, indicating that there is systematic variation that is not explained by those theories. We then modify the network to produce a new, interpretable behavioral model, revealing what the original network learned about people: their ability to optimally respond and their capacity to reason about others are dependent on the complexity of individual games. This context-dependence is critical in explaining deviations from the rational Nash equilibrium, response times, and uncertainty in strategic decisions. More broadly, our results demonstrate how machine learning can be applied beyond prediction to further help generate novel explanations of complex human behavior.
Read more8/16/2024
✅
0
An intelligent tutor for planning in large partially observable environments
Lovis Heindrich, Saksham Consul, Falk Lieder
AI can not only outperform people in many planning tasks, but it can also teach them how to plan better. A recent and promising approach to improving human decision-making is to create intelligent tutors that utilize AI to discover and teach optimal planning strategies automatically. Prior work has shown that this approach can improve planning in artificial, fully observable planning tasks. Unlike these artificial tasks, the world is only partially observable. To bridge this gap, we developed and evaluated the first intelligent tutor for planning in partially observable environments. Compared to previous intelligent tutors for teaching planning strategies, this novel intelligent tutor combines two innovations: 1) a new metareasoning algorithm for discovering optimal planning strategies for large, partially observable environments, and 2) scaffolding the learning processing by having the learner choose from an increasing larger set of planning operations in increasingly larger planning problems. We found that our new strategy discovery algorithm is superior to the state-of-the-art. A preregistered experiment with 330 participants demonstrated that the new intelligent tutor is highly effective at improving people's ability to make good decisions in partially observable environments. This suggests our human-centered tutoring approach can successfully boost human planning in complex, partially observable sequential decision problems, a promising step towards using AI-powered intelligent tutors to improve human planning in the real world.
Read more6/7/2024
🤔
0
Learning Personalized Decision Support Policies
Umang Bhatt, Valerie Chen, Katherine M. Collins, Parameswaran Kamalaruban, Emma Kallina, Adrian Weller, Ameet Talwalkar
Individual human decision-makers may benefit from different forms of support to improve decision outcomes, but when each form of support will yield better outcomes? In this work, we posit that personalizing access to decision support tools can be an effective mechanism for instantiating the appropriate use of AI assistance. Specifically, we propose the general problem of learning a decision support policy that, for a given input, chooses which form of support to provide to decision-makers for whom we initially have no prior information. We develop $texttt{Modiste}$, an interactive tool to learn personalized decision support policies. $texttt{Modiste}$ leverages stochastic contextual bandit techniques to personalize a decision support policy for each decision-maker and supports extensions to the multi-objective setting to account for auxiliary objectives like the cost of support. We find that personalized policies outperform offline policies, and, in the cost-aware setting, reduce the incurred cost with minimal degradation to performance. Our experiments include various realistic forms of support (e.g., expert consensus and predictions from a large language model) on vision and language tasks. Our human subject experiments validate our computational experiments, demonstrating that personalization can yield benefits in practice for real users, who interact with $texttt{Modiste}$.
Read more5/28/2024