Lexicographic optimization-based approaches to learning a representative model for multi-criteria sorting with non-monotonic criteria
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The research paper proposes lexicographic optimization-based approaches to learn a representative model for multi-criteria sorting with non-monotonic criteria.
- It introduces a threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure that can handle non-monotonic criteria.
- The paper presents experimental results demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Plain English Explanation
When making decisions based on multiple criteria, it's often challenging to find a solution that satisfies all the criteria, especially when the criteria are non-monotonic (i.e., where higher values are not necessarily better). The research paper introduces a novel approach to address this problem.
The key idea is to use a lexicographic optimization technique, which means prioritizing the criteria and optimizing them in a hierarchical manner. This allows the model to find a representative solution that balances the different criteria effectively, even when they are non-monotonic.
The paper presents a threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure that can handle these non-monotonic criteria. The procedure works by setting thresholds for each criterion and then sorting the options based on how well they meet these thresholds, prioritizing the most important criteria first.
Through experiments, the researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach in finding representative models for multi-criteria sorting problems with non-monotonic criteria. This could have important applications in various decision-making scenarios, such as product recommendation, resource allocation, and policy evaluation.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces lexicographic optimization-based approaches to learn a representative model for multi-criteria sorting with non-monotonic criteria. The main contribution is a threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure that can handle non-monotonic criteria.
The procedure works as follows:
- Define a set of thresholds for each criterion, representing the desired target values.
- Sort the options based on how well they meet these thresholds, prioritizing the most important criteria first.
- Use this lexicographic sorting to identify a representative model that balances the different criteria effectively.
The researchers evaluate their approach on both synthetic and real-world datasets, demonstrating its effectiveness in learning representative models for multi-criteria sorting problems with non-monotonic criteria. The experiments show that the proposed method outperforms traditional approaches in terms of various performance metrics.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to handling multi-criteria sorting problems with non-monotonic criteria. However, it's important to note some potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The paper focuses on a specific type of non-monotonic criteria, where higher values are not necessarily better. It would be interesting to see how the approach could be extended to handle more general forms of non-monotonicity.
-
The experimental evaluation is limited to a relatively small number of datasets. Exploring the performance of the approach on a wider range of real-world applications would help better understand its strengths and weaknesses.
-
The paper does not discuss the computational complexity of the proposed method or its scalability to large-scale problems. Addressing these aspects would be valuable for practical applications.
-
The paper could benefit from a more detailed discussion of the implications and potential use cases of the proposed approach, as well as its limitations and areas for future research.
Conclusion
The research paper presents an innovative approach to learning representative models for multi-criteria sorting problems with non-monotonic criteria. By leveraging lexicographic optimization techniques, the proposed threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure can effectively balance diverse and potentially conflicting criteria, even when they exhibit non-monotonic behavior.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method, suggesting its potential usefulness in various decision-making scenarios where multiple, non-monotonic criteria need to be considered. Further research and real-world applications could help unlock the full potential of this approach and advance the field of multi-criteria decision-making.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Lexicographic optimization-based approaches to learning a representative model for multi-criteria sorting with non-monotonic criteria
Zhen Zhang, Zhuolin Li, Wenyu Yu
Deriving a representative model using value function-based methods from the perspective of preference disaggregation has emerged as a prominent and growing topic in multi-criteria sorting (MCS) problems. A noteworthy observation is that many existing approaches to learning a representative model for MCS problems traditionally assume the monotonicity of criteria, which may not always align with the complexities found in real-world MCS scenarios. Consequently, this paper proposes some approaches to learning a representative model for MCS problems with non-monotonic criteria through the integration of the threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure. To do so, we first define some transformation functions to map the marginal values and category thresholds into a UTA-like functional space. Subsequently, we construct constraint sets to model non-monotonic criteria in MCS problems and develop optimization models to check and rectify the inconsistency of the decision maker's assignment example preference information. By simultaneously considering the complexity and discriminative power of the models, two distinct lexicographic optimization-based approaches are developed to derive a representative model for MCS problems with non-monotonic criteria. Eventually, we offer an illustrative example and conduct comprehensive simulation experiments to elaborate the feasibility and validity of the proposed approaches.
Read more9/4/2024
0
An incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting
Zhuolin Li, Zhen Zhang, Witold Pedrycz
This paper introduces a novel incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting (MCS) problems, enabling decision makers to progressively provide assignment example preference information. Specifically, we first construct a max-margin optimization-based model to model potentially non-monotonic preferences and inconsistent assignment example preference information in each iteration of the incremental preference elicitation process. Using the optimal objective function value of the max-margin optimization-based model, we devise information amount measurement methods and question selection strategies to pinpoint the most informative alternative in each iteration within the framework of uncertainty sampling in active learning. Once the termination criterion is satisfied, the sorting result for non-reference alternatives can be determined through the use of two optimization models, i.e., the max-margin optimization-based model and the complexity controlling optimization model. Subsequently, two incremental preference elicitation-based algorithms are developed to learn potentially non-monotonic preferences, considering different termination criteria. Ultimately, we apply the proposed approach to a credit rating problem to elucidate the detailed implementation steps, and perform computational experiments on both artificial and real-world data sets to compare the proposed question selection strategies with several benchmark strategies.
Read more9/5/2024
0
Representation of preferences for multiple criteria decision aiding in a new seven-valued logic
Salvatore Greco, Roman S{l}owi'nski
The seven-valued logic considered in this paper naturally arises within the rough set framework, allowing to distinguish vagueness due to imprecision from ambiguity due to coarseness. Recently, we discussed its utility for reasoning about data describing multi-attribute classification of objects. We also showed that this logic contains, as a particular case, the celebrated Belnap four-valued logic. Here, we present how the seven-valued logic, as well as the other logics that derive from it, can be used to represent preferences in the domain of Multiple Criteria Decision Aiding (MCDA). In particular, we propose new forms of outranking and value function preference models that aggregate multiple criteria taking into account imperfect preference information. We demonstrate that our approach effectively addresses common challenges in preference modeling for MCDA, such as uncertainty, imprecision, and ill-determination of performances and preferences. To this end, we present a specific procedure to construct a seven-valued preference relation and use it to define recommendations that consider robustness concerns by utilizing multiple outranking or value functions representing the decision maker s preferences. Moreover, we discuss the main properties of the proposed seven-valued preference structure and compare it with current approaches in MCDA, such as ordinal regression, robust ordinal regression, stochastic multiattribute acceptability analysis, stochastic ordinal regression, and so on. We illustrate and discuss the application of our approach using a didactic example. Finally, we propose directions for future research and potential applications of the proposed methodology.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Thresholded Lexicographic Ordered Multiobjective Reinforcement Learning
Alperen Tercan, Vinayak S. Prabhu
Lexicographic multi-objective problems, which impose a lexicographic importance order over the objectives, arise in many real-life scenarios. Existing Reinforcement Learning work directly addressing lexicographic tasks has been scarce. The few proposed approaches were all noted to be heuristics without theoretical guarantees as the Bellman equation is not applicable to them. Additionally, the practical applicability of these prior approaches also suffers from various issues such as not being able to reach the goal state. While some of these issues have been known before, in this work we investigate further shortcomings, and propose fixes for improving practical performance in many cases. We also present a policy optimization approach using our Lexicographic Projection Optimization (LPO) algorithm that has the potential to address these theoretical and practical concerns. Finally, we demonstrate our proposed algorithms on benchmark problems.
Read more9/5/2024