An incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents an incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting.
- The approach uses a threshold-based multi-criteria sorting (MCS) model to capture complex preference structures.
- The model is learned through an interactive preference elicitation process, where the user provides feedback on sample comparisons.
- The key focus is on handling non-monotonic preferences, which are common in real-world decision-making scenarios.
Plain English Explanation
When making decisions based on multiple criteria, people often have complex and sometimes non-intuitive preferences. For example, when buying a car, you might prefer a larger vehicle for more space, but also a smaller one for better fuel efficiency. This creates a non-monotonic preference structure that can be difficult to capture using traditional models.
The researchers in this paper propose a new approach to learn these types of preferences. Their method uses an interactive process, where the system presents the user with sample comparisons and the user provides feedback. Over time, the system learns the user's underlying preferences and can make better recommendations.
The key innovation is the use of a threshold-based multi-criteria sorting (MCS) model, which can handle non-monotonic preferences. This allows the system to capture more nuanced and realistic decision-making behaviors compared to simpler models.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a threshold-based MCS model to represent potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria decision-making problems. The model assumes that the decision-maker has a set of thresholds for each criterion, and the alternatives are sorted into ordered categories based on how they compare to these thresholds.
The researchers propose an incremental preference elicitation algorithm to learn the parameters of this model from user feedback. At each step, the algorithm selects a pair of alternatives and presents them to the user, who indicates their preference. The algorithm then updates the model parameters to better align with the user's feedback.
A key aspect of the approach is the ability to handle non-monotonic preferences, where an increase in one criterion does not necessarily lead to a better overall ranking. The threshold-based MCS model can capture these complex preference structures, which are common in real-world decision-making scenarios.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and potentially impactful approach to learning user preferences in multi-criteria decision-making problems. The ability to handle non-monotonic preferences is a significant advancement over simpler, linear models.
However, the paper does not address several important practical considerations. For example, it is unclear how the approach would scale to large decision spaces or how robust it would be to noisy or inconsistent user feedback. Additionally, the paper does not explore the computational complexity of the algorithm or provide a thorough evaluation of its performance.
Further research is needed to address these limitations and explore the broader applicability of the threshold-based MCS model. Potential future work could include developing more efficient learning algorithms, investigating the model's ability to generalize to new decision scenarios, and conducting user studies to assess the approach's usability and effectiveness in real-world settings.
Conclusion
This paper presents a promising approach for learning complex, potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria decision-making problems. By using a threshold-based MCS model and an incremental preference elicitation algorithm, the researchers have developed a system that can capture more nuanced and realistic decision-making behaviors compared to traditional models.
While the paper raises several important directions for future research, the core ideas have the potential to significantly improve the accuracy and usefulness of recommendation systems and decision-support tools in a wide range of applications, from product selection to policy planning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
An incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting
Zhuolin Li, Zhen Zhang, Witold Pedrycz
This paper introduces a novel incremental preference elicitation-based approach to learning potentially non-monotonic preferences in multi-criteria sorting (MCS) problems, enabling decision makers to progressively provide assignment example preference information. Specifically, we first construct a max-margin optimization-based model to model potentially non-monotonic preferences and inconsistent assignment example preference information in each iteration of the incremental preference elicitation process. Using the optimal objective function value of the max-margin optimization-based model, we devise information amount measurement methods and question selection strategies to pinpoint the most informative alternative in each iteration within the framework of uncertainty sampling in active learning. Once the termination criterion is satisfied, the sorting result for non-reference alternatives can be determined through the use of two optimization models, i.e., the max-margin optimization-based model and the complexity controlling optimization model. Subsequently, two incremental preference elicitation-based algorithms are developed to learn potentially non-monotonic preferences, considering different termination criteria. Ultimately, we apply the proposed approach to a credit rating problem to elucidate the detailed implementation steps, and perform computational experiments on both artificial and real-world data sets to compare the proposed question selection strategies with several benchmark strategies.
Read more9/5/2024
0
Lexicographic optimization-based approaches to learning a representative model for multi-criteria sorting with non-monotonic criteria
Zhen Zhang, Zhuolin Li, Wenyu Yu
Deriving a representative model using value function-based methods from the perspective of preference disaggregation has emerged as a prominent and growing topic in multi-criteria sorting (MCS) problems. A noteworthy observation is that many existing approaches to learning a representative model for MCS problems traditionally assume the monotonicity of criteria, which may not always align with the complexities found in real-world MCS scenarios. Consequently, this paper proposes some approaches to learning a representative model for MCS problems with non-monotonic criteria through the integration of the threshold-based value-driven sorting procedure. To do so, we first define some transformation functions to map the marginal values and category thresholds into a UTA-like functional space. Subsequently, we construct constraint sets to model non-monotonic criteria in MCS problems and develop optimization models to check and rectify the inconsistency of the decision maker's assignment example preference information. By simultaneously considering the complexity and discriminative power of the models, two distinct lexicographic optimization-based approaches are developed to derive a representative model for MCS problems with non-monotonic criteria. Eventually, we offer an illustrative example and conduct comprehensive simulation experiments to elaborate the feasibility and validity of the proposed approaches.
Read more9/4/2024
🤯
0
Inference of Utilities and Time Preference in Sequential Decision-Making
Haoyang Cao, Zhengqi Wu, Renyuan Xu
This paper introduces a novel stochastic control framework to enhance the capabilities of automated investment managers, or robo-advisors, by accurately inferring clients' investment preferences from past activities. Our approach leverages a continuous-time model that incorporates utility functions and a generic discounting scheme of a time-varying rate, tailored to each client's risk tolerance, valuation of daily consumption, and significant life goals. We address the resulting time inconsistency issue through state augmentation and the establishment of the dynamic programming principle and the verification theorem. Additionally, we provide sufficient conditions for the identifiability of client investment preferences. To complement our theoretical developments, we propose a learning algorithm based on maximum likelihood estimation within a discrete-time Markov Decision Process framework, augmented with entropy regularization. We prove that the log-likelihood function is locally concave, facilitating the fast convergence of our proposed algorithm. Practical effectiveness and efficiency are showcased through two numerical examples, including Merton's problem and an investment problem with unhedgeable risks. Our proposed framework not only advances financial technology by improving personalized investment advice but also contributes broadly to other fields such as healthcare, economics, and artificial intelligence, where understanding individual preferences is crucial.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Greedy SLIM: A SLIM-Based Approach For Preference Elicitation
Claudius Proissl, Amel Vatic, Helmut Waldschmidt
Preference elicitation is an active learning approach to tackle the cold-start problem of recommender systems. Roughly speaking, new users are asked to rate some carefully selected items in order to compute appropriate recommendations for them. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to propose a method for preference elicitation that is based on SLIM , a state-of-the-art technique for top-N recommendation. Our approach mainly consists of a new training technique for SLIM, which we call Greedy SLIM. This technique iteratively selects items for the training in order to minimize the SLIM loss greedily. We conduct offline experiments as well as a user study to assess the performance of this new method. The results are remarkable, especially with respect to the user study. We conclude that Greedy SLIM seems to be more suitable for preference elicitation than widely used methods based on latent factor models.
Read more6/11/2024