Lifted Algorithms for Symmetric Weighted First-Order Model Sampling

Overview

• Weighted model counting (WMC) is the task of computing the weighted sum of all satisfying assignments (i.e., models) of a propositional formula.
• Weighted model sampling (WMS) aims to randomly generate models with probability proportional to their respective weights.
• Both WMC and WMS are computationally hard problems, but can be tractable if the propositional formula can be compactly represented and expressed in first-order logic.
• This paper explores whether the tractability of WMC, known as domain-liftability, also extends to WMS.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at the problem of weighted model sampling, which is about randomly generating solutions to a logic-based problem in a way that gives more weight to certain solutions over others. This is a difficult problem in general, but the researchers found that it can become easier to solve if the problem is expressed in a certain way using first-order logic.

Specifically, the paper shows that for a particular type of first-order logic problem involving counting quantifiers (like "there exist at least 3 things that..."), an efficient sampling algorithm can be developed that runs quickly, even for large problem sizes. This extends previous work on the tractability of counting the number of solutions, showing that the same concept of "domain-liftability" also applies to randomly generating the solutions.

The researchers tested their approach on various first-order logic problems designed for generating combinatorial structures and sampling in statistical-relational models. The results demonstrate that their algorithm outperforms other state-of-the-art weighted sampling methods, confirming the theoretical benefits.

Technical Explanation

The paper proves the domain-liftability under sampling for the two-variables fragment of first-order logic with counting quantifiers. Specifically, the authors devise an efficient sampling algorithm for this fragment that runs in time polynomial in the domain size.

The key insight is that for this restricted fragment of first-order logic, the probability distribution over the models (i.e., satisfying assignments) can be compactly represented and efficiently sampled from. This extends previous work on the tractability of model counting for this fragment, showing that the same principles of "domain-liftability" apply to both counting and sampling.

The authors further show that their sampling algorithm continues to work efficiently even in the presence of cardinality constraints, which are additional constraints on the number of objects satisfying certain properties.

To evaluate their approach, the researchers conduct experiments over various first-order formulas designed for the uniform generation of combinatorial structures and sampling in statistical-relational models. The results demonstrate that their algorithm outperforms a state-of-the-art weighted model sampling (WMS) technique by a substantial margin, confirming the theoretical benefits of the domain-liftable approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for the domain-liftability of weighted model sampling, extending previous results on the tractability of model counting. The authors carefully prove the sampling algorithm's efficiency for the two-variable fragment of first-order logic with counting quantifiers, and show that this result holds even in the presence of cardinality constraints.

One potential limitation is that the paper focuses on a relatively restricted fragment of first-order logic, and it is not immediately clear how the techniques would generalize to more expressive logics. Additionally, the experimental evaluation, while promising, is limited to synthetic formulas and may not fully reflect the performance on real-world applications.

Further research could explore the applicability of these domain-liftable sampling techniques to a broader class of problems, and investigate ways to integrate them with other sampling and inference methods to tackle more complex scenarios. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in understanding the computational tractability of weighted model sampling, with potential implications for a wide range of fields, from statistical relational learning to combinatorial optimization.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that the concept of domain-liftability, which has been established for the tractability of model counting, can also be extended to the problem of weighted model sampling. By devising an efficient sampling algorithm for the two-variable fragment of first-order logic with counting quantifiers, the authors show that this restricted, yet expressive, class of problems can be solved in polynomial time, even when considering weighted distributions over the models.

The empirical results further confirm the theoretical benefits of this domain-liftable approach, outperforming state-of-the-art weighted sampling techniques. This work opens up new opportunities for the application of efficient sampling methods in areas like statistical relational learning, combinatorial optimization, and beyond, where the ability to generate weighted samples can lead to significant improvements in modeling and inference capabilities.