List-Decodable Sparse Mean Estimation via Difference-of-Pairs Filtering

Overview

• The paper studies the problem of list-decodable sparse mean estimation.
• For a parameter α between 0 and 1/2, the researchers are given m points in n-dimensional space, where ⌊αm⌋ of them are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) samples from a distribution D with an unknown k-sparse mean μ.
• The remaining points, which form the majority of the dataset, have no assumptions made about them.
• The goal is to return a small list of candidate vectors ŵμ such that the Euclidean distance |ŵμ - μ|₂ is small.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers are looking at a challenging statistical problem where they have a set of data points, most of which are "outliers" and don't follow a known pattern. However, a small portion of the data points (proportional to the parameter α) are samples from a distribution with an unknown "sparse" mean, meaning the mean vector has only a few non-zero entries.

The researchers want to find a short list of candidate vectors that are close to the true unknown mean of the "inlier" data points. This is a difficult task because the majority of the data is not following the same pattern as the small subset of "inlier" points.

The key innovation in this work is a new, simpler technique for solving this list-decodable mean estimation problem, especially in the case where the underlying distribution has certain properties like bounded moments and light tails. Their algorithm can achieve good accuracy with a reasonable number of samples and computational complexity.

Technical Explanation

The researchers are studying the list-decodable mean estimation problem, but in the sparse setting. This means they are given a dataset where a small fraction α of the points are i.i.d. samples from a distribution D with an unknown k-sparse mean μ, and the remaining points have no assumptions made about them.

The goal is to return a small list of candidate vectors ŵμ such that the Euclidean distance |ŵμ - μ|₂ is small. This is a challenging task because the majority of the dataset is "corrupted" or does not follow the same pattern as the small subset of "inlier" points.

The researchers develop a new, conceptually simpler technique for solving this list-decodable mean estimation problem. As a key application, they provide the first sample and computationally efficient algorithm for list-decodable sparse mean estimation.

For distributions with certifiably bounded t-th moments in k-sparse directions and sufficiently light tails, their algorithm achieves an error of (1/α)^(O(1/t)) using m = (k log(n))^(O(t))/α samples and running in poly(mn^t) time. For Gaussian inliers, their algorithm achieves the optimal error of Θ(sqrt(log(1/α))) with quasi-polynomial sample and computational complexity.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that their algorithm has some limitations, such as the dependence on the t-th moment and tail properties of the underlying distribution. They also note that their lower bounds, while nearly matching the upper bounds, still leave some gaps in the understanding of the problem's inherent difficulty.

One potential concern is the scalability of the algorithm, as the running time depends polynomially on the dimension n and the number of samples m. This could make the approach less practical for very high-dimensional problems or extremely large datasets.

Additionally, the researchers do not provide extensive experimental validation of their algorithm's performance, which would be helpful to further assess its practical applicability and understand its behavior on real-world data.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel and conceptually simpler technique for the list-decodable sparse mean estimation problem. The researchers' algorithm achieves state-of-the-art performance in terms of sample complexity and computational efficiency, particularly for distributions with bounded moments and light tails.

The work represents an important advance in the field of robust and high-dimensional statistical estimation, with potential applications in machine learning, signal processing, and other areas where dealing with corrupted or heterogeneous data is a common challenge. The theoretical insights and algorithmic techniques developed in this paper could inspire further research and practical developments in this domain.