LLaQo: Towards a Query-Based Coach in Expressive Music Performance Assessment
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents LLaQo, a system that uses large language models to provide expressive feedback on music performance.
- LLaQo allows users to ask questions about their piano performance, and it generates relevant feedback using natural language processing.
- The goal is to create a "query-based coach" that can help music students improve their expressiveness and technique.
Plain English Explanation
LLaQo: Towards a Query-Based Coach in Expressive Music Performance Assessment describes a new system that uses powerful language models to provide feedback on music performances. The key idea is to let students ask questions about their playing, and then have the system generate helpful responses.
For example, a student might ask "How can I make the melody sound more emotional?" The LLaQo system would then analyze the performance and provide suggestions, such as "Try playing the melody with more dynamic contrast - make the quiet parts even softer and the loud parts more powerful." The goal is to create an interactive "coach" that can guide students towards more expressive and technically proficient performances.
This is an interesting approach because it allows students to get tailored feedback on their specific needs, rather than just generic tips. The language model can understand the nuances of the student's question and give a relevant, natural-sounding response. This could be more effective than just providing a list of generic tips or comments.
Technical Explanation
The LLaQo system uses a large language model that has been trained on a vast amount of text data, including musical terminology and concepts. When a student asks a question about their performance, the system uses this language understanding to analyze the audio recording and generate an appropriate response.
The key components are:
- Audio feature extraction: The system extracts various acoustic features from the student's performance, such as pitch, dynamics, and tempo.
- Language understanding: It uses natural language processing to understand the intent and context of the student's question.
- Feedback generation: Based on the audio features and the language understanding, the system generates a relevant response to provide feedback and suggestions.
This allows the LLaQo system to engage in a back-and-forth dialogue with the student, addressing their specific needs and questions. The researchers tested the system with both professional musicians and music students, and found that it was able to provide useful and meaningful feedback.
Critical Analysis
The LLaQo paper presents an innovative approach to using large language models for music education and assessment. The key strength is the ability to provide personalized, query-based feedback, which could be more effective than generic instruction.
However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations and areas for further research:
- Subjective nature of expressiveness: Assessing the "expressiveness" of a music performance is inherently subjective, and the system may not always capture nuances that human instructors can.
- Limited training data: The language model was trained on a relatively small corpus of musical texts, which may limit its understanding and ability to generate relevant feedback.
- Integration with other modalities: The current system only uses audio input, but incorporating video, sheet music, or other modalities could provide a more comprehensive assessment.
Additionally, it would be valuable to see more longitudinal studies on the effectiveness of the LLaQo system in improving student learning and performance over time. Ongoing evaluation and refinement of the system will be important as it is deployed in real-world educational settings.
Conclusion
Overall, the LLaQo paper presents an exciting step towards using large language models to create interactive, query-based systems for music education and assessment. By allowing students to ask questions and receive tailored feedback, this approach has the potential to be more engaging and effective than traditional teaching methods.
As language models continue to advance, systems like LLaQo could become powerful tools for supporting music learning and helping students develop their expressive and technical abilities. The key will be to continue refining the technology and integrating it seamlessly into educational workflows.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
LLaQo: Towards a Query-Based Coach in Expressive Music Performance Assessment
Huan Zhang, Vincent Cheung, Hayato Nishioka, Simon Dixon, Shinichi Furuya
Research in music understanding has extensively explored composition-level attributes such as key, genre, and instrumentation through advanced representations, leading to cross-modal applications using large language models. However, aspects of musical performance such as stylistic expression and technique remain underexplored, along with the potential of using large language models to enhance educational outcomes with customized feedback. To bridge this gap, we introduce LLaQo, a Large Language Query-based music coach that leverages audio language modeling to provide detailed and formative assessments of music performances. We also introduce instruction-tuned query-response datasets that cover a variety of performance dimensions from pitch accuracy to articulation, as well as contextual performance understanding (such as difficulty and performance techniques). Utilizing AudioMAE encoder and Vicuna-7b LLM backend, our model achieved state-of-the-art (SOTA) results in predicting teachers' performance ratings, as well as in identifying piece difficulty and playing techniques. Textual responses from LLaQo was moreover rated significantly higher compared to other baseline models in a user study using audio-text matching. Our proposed model can thus provide informative answers to open-ended questions related to musical performance from audio data.
Read more9/17/2024
0
Pronunciation Assessment with Multi-modal Large Language Models
Kaiqi Fu, Linkai Peng, Nan Yang, Shuran Zhou
Large language models (LLMs), renowned for their powerful conversational abilities, are widely recognized as exceptional tools in the field of education, particularly in the context of automated intelligent instruction systems for language learning. In this paper, we propose a scoring system based on LLMs, motivated by their positive impact on text-related scoring tasks. Specifically, the speech encoder first maps the learner's speech into contextual features. The adapter layer then transforms these features to align with the text embedding in latent space. The assessment task-specific prefix and prompt text are embedded and concatenated with the features generated by the modality adapter layer, enabling the LLMs to predict accuracy and fluency scores. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed scoring systems achieve competitive results compared to the baselines on the Speechocean762 datasets. Moreover, we also conducted an ablation study to better understand the contributions of the prompt text and training strategy in the proposed scoring system.
Read more7/19/2024
0
LOVA3: Learning to Visual Question Answering, Asking and Assessment
Henry Hengyuan Zhao, Pan Zhou, Difei Gao, Mike Zheng Shou
Question answering, asking, and assessment are three innate human traits crucial for understanding the world and acquiring knowledge. By enhancing these capabilities, humans can more effectively utilize data, leading to better comprehension and learning outcomes. However, current Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) primarily focus on question answering, often neglecting the full potential of questioning and assessment skills. In this study, we introduce LOVA3, an innovative framework named ``Learning tO Visual Question Answering, Asking and Assessment,'' designed to equip MLLMs with these additional capabilities. Our approach involves the creation of two supplementary training tasks GenQA and EvalQA, aiming at fostering the skills of asking and assessing questions in the context of images. To develop the questioning ability, we compile a comprehensive set of multimodal foundational tasks. For assessment, we introduce a new benchmark called EvalQABench, comprising 64,000 training samples (split evenly between positive and negative samples) and 5,000 testing samples. We posit that enhancing MLLMs with the capabilities to answer, ask, and assess questions will improve their multimodal comprehension and lead to better performance. We validate our hypothesis by training an MLLM using the LOVA3 framework and testing it on 10 multimodal benchmarks. The results demonstrate consistent performance improvements, thereby confirming the efficacy of our approach.
Read more5/27/2024
0
Just ASR + LLM? A Study on Speech Large Language Models' Ability to Identify and Understand Speaker in Spoken Dialogue
Junkai Wu, Xulin Fan, Bo-Ru Lu, Xilin Jiang, Nima Mesgarani, Mark Hasegawa-Johnson, Mari Ostendorf
In recent years, we have observed a rapid advancement in speech language models (SpeechLLMs), catching up with humans' listening and reasoning abilities. Remarkably, SpeechLLMs have demonstrated impressive spoken dialogue question-answering (SQA) performance in benchmarks like Gaokao, the English listening test of the college entrance exam in China, which seemingly requires understanding both the spoken content and voice characteristics of speakers in a conversation. However, after carefully examining Gaokao's questions, we find the correct answers to many questions can be inferred from the conversation context alone without identifying the speaker asked in the question. Our evaluation of state-of-the-art models Qwen-Audio and WavLLM in both Gaokao and our proposed What Do You Like? dataset shows a significantly higher accuracy in these context-based questions than in identity-critical questions, which can only be answered correctly with correct speaker identification. Our results and analysis suggest that when solving SQA, the current SpeechLLMs exhibit limited speaker awareness from the audio and behave similarly to an LLM reasoning from the conversation transcription without sound. We propose that our definitions and automated classification of context-based and identity-critical questions could offer a more accurate evaluation framework of SpeechLLMs in SQA tasks.
Read more9/10/2024