LucidPPN: Unambiguous Prototypical Parts Network for User-centric Interpretable Computer Vision

Read original: arXiv:2405.14331 - Published 5/24/2024 by Mateusz Pach, Dawid Rymarczyk, Koryna Lewandowska, Jacek Tabor, Bartosz Zieli'nski

🌐

Overview

Prototypical parts networks combine deep learning and case-based reasoning to make accurate, interpretable decisions.
They represent each prototypical part with patches from training images, but a single image patch contains multiple visual features like color, shape, and texture, making it hard for users to identify the important features.
To address this, the paper introduces the Lucid Prototypical Parts Network (LucidPPN), which separates color prototypes from other visual features.

Plain English Explanation

Prototypical parts networks are a type of AI model that combine the power of deep learning with the explainability of case-based reasoning. They work by representing different parts of an object using example patches from training images. For example, if you're classifying birds, the model might learn prototypical wing, beak, and eye patches.

However, a single image patch can contain multiple visual features like color, shape, and texture. This makes it hard for users to understand which specific features the model is using to make its decisions. Other prototypical parts networks have struggled with this ambiguity.

To address this, the researchers developed the Lucid Prototypical Parts Network (LucidPPN). LucidPPN has two separate reasoning branches - one that focuses only on color information, and another that processes grayscale images to look at shape and texture. This separation allows the model to clearly indicate whether its decisions are based on color, shape, or texture. It also helps the model identify prototypical parts that correspond to semantic object parts, making it easier for users to understand the model's reasoning.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in LucidPPN is the separation of color prototypes from other visual features. Traditionally, prototypical parts networks represent each part using a single image patch, which can contain a mix of color, shape, and texture information. This makes it difficult to determine which specific visual cues the model is using to make its decisions.

To address this, LucidPPN employs two parallel reasoning branches. One branch processes grayscale images to focus on non-color features like shape and texture. The other branch concentrates solely on color information. By separating these two types of visual features, LucidPPN can more clearly indicate whether its decisions are based on color, shape, or texture.

Additionally, LucidPPN is designed to identify prototypical parts that correspond to semantic object parts, like the belly or wings of a bird. This makes it easier for users to intuitively understand how the model is reasoning about different object classes, such as how two bird species might differ primarily in their belly coloration.

The experiments in the paper demonstrate that the two reasoning branches are complementary, and together they achieve performance comparable to baseline methods. More importantly, the separation of color and non-color features in LucidPPN generates less ambiguous prototypical parts, enhancing user understanding of the model's decision-making process.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the interpretability of prototypical parts networks. By separating color and non-color features, LucidPPN addresses a key limitation of previous models and generates more transparent, intuitive explanations of its decisions.

However, the paper does not extensively explore the potential limitations or caveats of this approach. For example, it would be valuable to understand how LucidPPN performs on datasets with more nuanced color variations, or how well it generalizes to object classes where color is not a primary distinguishing feature.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential biases that could arise from the model's focus on semantic object parts. While this approach enhances interpretability, it may also lead the model to overlook or underweight other relevant visual features that do not align with human-defined object parts.

Further research could also investigate the role of the relative weighting between the color and non-color reasoning branches, and explore ways to dynamically adjust this balance based on the specific classification task or dataset.

Overall, the Lucid Prototypical Parts Network represents an important step forward in making deep learning models more transparent and intuitive for users. However, ongoing research is needed to fully understand the limitations and potential biases of this approach, as well as to explore avenues for further improving the interpretability and robustness of such models.

Conclusion

The Lucid Prototypical Parts Network (LucidPPN) introduces a novel approach to improving the interpretability of prototypical parts networks, a type of deep learning model that combines the power of deep learning with the explainability of case-based reasoning. By separating color prototypes from other visual features like shape and texture, LucidPPN can more clearly indicate whether its decisions are based on color, shape, or texture, enhancing user understanding of the model's decision-making process.

This separation also allows LucidPPN to identify prototypical parts that correspond to semantic object parts, making it easier for users to intuitively compare and contrast how different object classes are represented by the model. While the paper demonstrates the complementary nature of the color and non-color reasoning branches, further research is needed to fully explore the limitations and potential biases of this approach.

Overall, the Lucid Prototypical Parts Network represents an important step forward in the ongoing effort to make deep learning models more transparent and interpretable, with potential applications in a wide range of domains where accurate, explainable decisions are crucial.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🌐

LucidPPN: Unambiguous Prototypical Parts Network for User-centric Interpretable Computer Vision

Mateusz Pach, Dawid Rymarczyk, Koryna Lewandowska, Jacek Tabor, Bartosz Zieli'nski

Prototypical parts networks combine the power of deep learning with the explainability of case-based reasoning to make accurate, interpretable decisions. They follow the this looks like that reasoning, representing each prototypical part with patches from training images. However, a single image patch comprises multiple visual features, such as color, shape, and texture, making it difficult for users to identify which feature is important to the model. To reduce this ambiguity, we introduce the Lucid Prototypical Parts Network (LucidPPN), a novel prototypical parts network that separates color prototypes from other visual features. Our method employs two reasoning branches: one for non-color visual features, processing grayscale images, and another focusing solely on color information. This separation allows us to clarify whether the model's decisions are based on color, shape, or texture. Additionally, LucidPPN identifies prototypical parts corresponding to semantic parts of classified objects, making comparisons between data classes more intuitive, e.g., when two bird species might differ primarily in belly color. Our experiments demonstrate that the two branches are complementary and together achieve results comparable to baseline methods. More importantly, LucidPPN generates less ambiguous prototypical parts, enhancing user understanding.

5/24/2024

This Looks Better than That: Better Interpretable Models with ProtoPNeXt

Frank Willard, Luke Moffett, Emmanuel Mokel, Jon Donnelly, Stark Guo, Julia Yang, Giyoung Kim, Alina Jade Barnett, Cynthia Rudin

Prototypical-part models are a popular interpretable alternative to black-box deep learning models for computer vision. However, they are difficult to train, with high sensitivity to hyperparameter tuning, inhibiting their application to new datasets and our understanding of which methods truly improve their performance. To facilitate the careful study of prototypical-part networks (ProtoPNets), we create a new framework for integrating components of prototypical-part models -- ProtoPNeXt. Using ProtoPNeXt, we show that applying Bayesian hyperparameter tuning and an angular prototype similarity metric to the original ProtoPNet is sufficient to produce new state-of-the-art accuracy for prototypical-part models on CUB-200 across multiple backbones. We further deploy this framework to jointly optimize for accuracy and prototype interpretability as measured by metrics included in ProtoPNeXt. Using the same resources, this produces models with substantially superior semantics and changes in accuracy between +1.3% and -1.5%. The code and trained models will be made publicly available upon publication.

6/24/2024

New!Multi-Scale Grouped Prototypes for Interpretable Semantic Segmentation

Hugo Porta, Emanuele Dalsasso, Diego Marcos, Devis Tuia

Prototypical part learning is emerging as a promising approach for making semantic segmentation interpretable. The model selects real patches seen during training as prototypes and constructs the dense prediction map based on the similarity between parts of the test image and the prototypes. This improves interpretability since the user can inspect the link between the predicted output and the patterns learned by the model in terms of prototypical information. In this paper, we propose a method for interpretable semantic segmentation that leverages multi-scale image representation for prototypical part learning. First, we introduce a prototype layer that explicitly learns diverse prototypical parts at several scales, leading to multi-scale representations in the prototype activation output. Then, we propose a sparse grouping mechanism that produces multi-scale sparse groups of these scale-specific prototypical parts. This provides a deeper understanding of the interactions between multi-scale object representations while enhancing the interpretability of the segmentation model. The experiments conducted on Pascal VOC, Cityscapes, and ADE20K demonstrate that the proposed method increases model sparsity, improves interpretability over existing prototype-based methods, and narrows the performance gap with the non-interpretable counterpart models. Code is available at github.com/eceo-epfl/ScaleProtoSeg.

9/17/2024

🖼️

Deformable ProtoPNet: An Interpretable Image Classifier Using Deformable Prototypes

Jon Donnelly, Alina Jade Barnett, Chaofan Chen

We present a deformable prototypical part network (Deformable ProtoPNet), an interpretable image classifier that integrates the power of deep learning and the interpretability of case-based reasoning. This model classifies input images by comparing them with prototypes learned during training, yielding explanations in the form of this looks like that. However, while previous methods use spatially rigid prototypes, we address this shortcoming by proposing spatially flexible prototypes. Each prototype is made up of several prototypical parts that adaptively change their relative spatial positions depending on the input image. Consequently, a Deformable ProtoPNet can explicitly capture pose variations and context, improving both model accuracy and the richness of explanations provided. Compared to other case-based interpretable models using prototypes, our approach achieves state-of-the-art accuracy and gives an explanation with greater context. The code is available at https://github.com/jdonnelly36/Deformable-ProtoPNet.

5/6/2024