Machine Learning in Orbit Estimation: a Survey

Overview

• Increasing number of objects orbiting the Earth poses risks of collisions, known as Kessler Syndrome
• Current physics-based methods for tracking and predicting debris and satellite orbits have errors in the order of kilometers for 7-day predictions
• Factors contributing to this inaccuracy include uncertainty in initial conditions, errors in environmental forecasting, and unknown object characteristics
• Machine learning techniques can help improve orbit determination, prediction, and atmospheric modeling to address these challenges

Plain English Explanation

The number of objects orbiting the Earth has steadily grown since the launch of the first artificial satellite in the late 1950s. It's estimated that around 1 million objects larger than 1 cm are currently in orbit, with only 30,000 larger than 10 cm being actively tracked. This increasing clutter in space poses a risk of collisions, known as the Kessler Syndrome, where a chain reaction of impacts could severely damage or destroy satellites.

To avoid this, it's crucial to accurately track and predict the orbits of these objects. However, the current physics-based methods used to do this have significant errors, often in the range of kilometers for predictions 7 days out. This is not accurate enough when dealing with space debris, which can be less than a meter in size.

The main reasons for these inaccuracies are:

1. Uncertainty about the initial state or conditions of the object when tracking begins
2. Errors in forecasting environmental factors like atmospheric drag that affect the object's movement
3. Lack of knowledge about the object's characteristics, such as its mass or shape

Researchers are exploring the use of machine learning techniques to help address these challenges. By using data-driven approaches, they aim to better determine the unmeasured properties of objects and improve the modeling of the non-conservative forces, like atmospheric drag, that impact their orbits. This could lead to more accurate orbit prediction and help prevent collisions in the increasingly crowded space environment.

Technical Explanation

The paper provides an overview of research applying machine learning techniques to the problems of orbit determination, orbit prediction, and atmospheric density modeling.

Current physics-based methods for tracking and forecasting the orbits of space debris and satellites have errors on the order of kilometers for 7-day predictions. This level of inaccuracy is problematic when dealing with objects that can be less than a meter in size. The key factors contributing to these errors include:

1. Uncertainty in initial conditions: The initial state or conditions of the object when tracking begins are not perfectly known, leading to compounding errors in the prediction.
2. Forecasting errors: Inaccuracies in predicting environmental factors like atmospheric drag that influence the object's movement over time.
3. Unknown object characteristics: Lack of information about the mass, geometry, and other properties of the space object that affect its orbit.

To address these challenges, researchers are exploring the use of data-driven machine learning approaches to:

• Derive the unmeasured characteristics of space objects
• Improve the modeling of non-conservative forces, such as atmospheric drag, that impact orbit predictions

By leveraging machine learning, the goal is to enhance the accuracy of orbit determination and prediction, which is crucial for mitigating the risks of collisions in the growing population of objects in Earth's orbit.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the research in applying machine learning techniques to address the challenges of orbit determination, prediction, and atmospheric modeling. The authors acknowledge the significant errors in current physics-based methods and the need for more accurate tracking and forecasting to prevent Kessler Syndrome.

One potential limitation of the research discussed in the paper is the reliance on data-driven approaches, which may require large and diverse datasets of space object characteristics and environmental conditions. Gathering and curating such datasets could be a significant challenge, especially for less-studied or newly launched objects.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific machine learning architectures, algorithms, or training approaches being used in the reviewed research. A deeper technical discussion of these aspects could provide more insight into the strengths, weaknesses, and trade-offs of the different methods.

While the paper highlights the potential of machine learning to improve orbit prediction, it does not address the potential computational or operational challenges of deploying such techniques in real-world space tracking and monitoring systems. The integration of these data-driven methods with existing physical models and infrastructure may require further research and engineering efforts.

Overall, the paper provides a valuable overview of the current state of the art in using machine learning for space object tracking and prediction. Readers are encouraged to think critically about the potential benefits, limitations, and practical considerations of these emerging techniques as the field continues to evolve.

Conclusion

The steady increase in the number of objects orbiting the Earth, including both active satellites and space debris, poses a growing risk of collisions that could trigger a cascading effect known as the Kessler Syndrome. To mitigate this threat, it is essential to accurately track and predict the orbits of these space objects.

Current physics-based methods for orbit determination and prediction have significant errors, often in the range of kilometers for 7-day forecasts. This level of inaccuracy is insufficient when dealing with small space debris that can be less than a meter in size.

To address these challenges, researchers are exploring the use of machine learning techniques to enhance the tracking and prediction of space object orbits. By leveraging data-driven approaches, they aim to better determine the unmeasured characteristics of objects and improve the modeling of non-conservative forces, such as atmospheric drag, that impact their movements.

The successful application of machine learning in this domain could lead to more accurate orbit prediction and help prevent collisions in the increasingly crowded space environment, ultimately contributing to the long-term sustainability of space operations.