Matching the Statistical Query Lower Bound for k-sparse Parity Problems with Stochastic Gradient Descent
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the problem of k-sparse parity, which involves finding a small set of relevant features from a large number of input features.
- The authors show that stochastic gradient descent (SGD) can achieve the statistical query lower bound for this problem, matching the best known information-theoretic limit.
- The paper provides theoretical guarantees on the sample complexity and runtime of their SGD-based algorithm, demonstrating its strong performance compared to previous approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a challenging machine learning problem called k-sparse parity. Imagine you have a large number of potential features, but only a small subset of them are actually relevant for predicting some target variable. The goal is to efficiently identify this small set of relevant features.
The authors show that a technique called stochastic gradient descent (SGD) can be used to solve this problem in an optimal way. SGD is a widely-used optimization algorithm in machine learning, and the authors prove that it can achieve the best possible performance in terms of the number of samples (or observations) required and the computational runtime.
This is an important result because it demonstrates the power of SGD, which is often used in practice but not always understood from a theoretical standpoint. By showing that SGD can match the information-theoretic limits for this problem, the authors provide strong theoretical justification for using SGD in similar settings.
Technical Explanation
The paper studies the problem of k-sparse parity, which involves finding a small set of relevant features from a large number of input features. Formally, the goal is to recover a k-sparse Boolean function that determines the target variable, given access to samples from this function.
The authors show that stochastic gradient descent (SGD) can achieve the statistical query lower bound for this problem. Specifically, they provide algorithms based on SGD that can provably recover the k-sparse parity function using a number of samples that matches the information-theoretic lower bound, up to logarithmic factors.
Technically, the authors analyze the performance of SGD-based algorithms in the high-probability convergence setting, where the algorithm is guaranteed to succeed with high probability. They show that their algorithms have optimal oracle complexity, meaning they achieve the best possible tradeoff between sample complexity and computational runtime.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a strong theoretical analysis of the performance of SGD-based algorithms for the k-sparse parity problem. The authors carefully address several technical challenges, such as handling the non-convexity of the problem and establishing high-probability guarantees on the algorithm's performance.
One potential limitation of the work is that it focuses on the theoretical aspects of the problem, without extensive empirical validation. While the theoretical results are compelling, it would be helpful to see how the proposed algorithms perform on real-world datasets or more practical benchmarks.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations or caveats of the k-sparse parity problem formulation. In practice, real-world feature selection tasks may involve more complex structures or assumptions that are not captured by this idealized problem setup.
Further research could explore extensions or variations of the k-sparse parity problem, such as incorporating additional structural constraints or considering more general classes of target functions. Investigating the robustness of the proposed algorithms to model misspecification or other real-world challenges would also be a valuable direction.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to the theoretical understanding of stochastic gradient descent for feature selection problems. By showing that SGD can achieve the statistical query lower bound for the k-sparse parity problem, the authors demonstrate the strong performance and optimality of this widely-used optimization technique.
The results have broader implications for the design and analysis of machine learning algorithms, suggesting that SGD-based approaches may be well-suited for a range of high-dimensional feature selection tasks. Overall, this work advances our understanding of the theoretical foundations of efficient machine learning, with potential applications in a variety of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Matching the Statistical Query Lower Bound for k-sparse Parity Problems with Stochastic Gradient Descent
Yiwen Kou, Zixiang Chen, Quanquan Gu, Sham M. Kakade
The $k$-parity problem is a classical problem in computational complexity and algorithmic theory, serving as a key benchmark for understanding computational classes. In this paper, we solve the $k$-parity problem with stochastic gradient descent (SGD) on two-layer fully-connected neural networks. We demonstrate that SGD can efficiently solve the $k$-sparse parity problem on a $d$-dimensional hypercube ($kle O(sqrt{d})$) with a sample complexity of $tilde{O}(d^{k-1})$ using $2^{Theta(k)}$ neurons, thus matching the established $Omega(d^{k})$ lower bounds of Statistical Query (SQ) models. Our theoretical analysis begins by constructing a good neural network capable of correctly solving the $k$-parity problem. We then demonstrate how a trained neural network with SGD can effectively approximate this good network, solving the $k$-parity problem with small statistical errors. Our theoretical results and findings are supported by empirical evidence, showcasing the efficiency and efficacy of our approach.
Read more4/19/2024
0
On the Complexity of Learning Sparse Functions with Statistical and Gradient Queries
Nirmit Joshi, Theodor Misiakiewicz, Nathan Srebro
The goal of this paper is to investigate the complexity of gradient algorithms when learning sparse functions (juntas). We introduce a type of Statistical Queries ($mathsf{SQ}$), which we call Differentiable Learning Queries ($mathsf{DLQ}$), to model gradient queries on a specified loss with respect to an arbitrary model. We provide a tight characterization of the query complexity of $mathsf{DLQ}$ for learning the support of a sparse function over generic product distributions. This complexity crucially depends on the loss function. For the squared loss, $mathsf{DLQ}$ matches the complexity of Correlation Statistical Queries $(mathsf{CSQ})$--potentially much worse than $mathsf{SQ}$. But for other simple loss functions, including the $ell_1$ loss, $mathsf{DLQ}$ always achieves the same complexity as $mathsf{SQ}$. We also provide evidence that $mathsf{DLQ}$ can indeed capture learning with (stochastic) gradient descent by showing it correctly describes the complexity of learning with a two-layer neural network in the mean field regime and linear scaling.
Read more7/9/2024
🛠️
0
Closing the Computational-Query Depth Gap in Parallel Stochastic Convex Optimization
Arun Jambulapati, Aaron Sidford, Kevin Tian
We develop a new parallel algorithm for minimizing Lipschitz, convex functions with a stochastic subgradient oracle. The total number of queries made and the query depth, i.e., the number of parallel rounds of queries, match the prior state-of-the-art, [CJJLLST23], while improving upon the computational depth by a polynomial factor for sufficiently small accuracy. When combined with previous state-of-the-art methods our result closes a gap between the best-known query depth and the best-known computational depth of parallel algorithms. Our method starts with a ball acceleration framework of previous parallel methods, i.e., [CJJJLST20, ACJJS21], which reduce the problem to minimizing a regularized Gaussian convolution of the function constrained to Euclidean balls. By developing and leveraging new stability properties of the Hessian of this induced function, we depart from prior parallel algorithms and reduce these ball-constrained optimization problems to stochastic unconstrained quadratic minimization problems. Although we are unable to prove concentration of the asymmetric matrices that we use to approximate this Hessian, we nevertheless develop an efficient parallel method for solving these quadratics. Interestingly, our algorithms can be improved using fast matrix multiplication and use nearly-linear work if the matrix multiplication exponent is 2.
Read more6/12/2024
0
Neural network learns low-dimensional polynomials with SGD near the information-theoretic limit
Jason D. Lee, Kazusato Oko, Taiji Suzuki, Denny Wu
We study the problem of gradient descent learning of a single-index target function $f_*(boldsymbol{x}) = textstylesigma_*left(langleboldsymbol{x},boldsymbol{theta}rangleright)$ under isotropic Gaussian data in $mathbb{R}^d$, where the link function $sigma_*:mathbb{R}tomathbb{R}$ is an unknown degree $q$ polynomial with information exponent $p$ (defined as the lowest degree in the Hermite expansion). Prior works showed that gradient-based training of neural networks can learn this target with $ngtrsim d^{Theta(p)}$ samples, and such statistical complexity is predicted to be necessary by the correlational statistical query lower bound. Surprisingly, we prove that a two-layer neural network optimized by an SGD-based algorithm learns $f_*$ of arbitrary polynomial link function with a sample and runtime complexity of $n asymp T asymp C(q) cdot dmathrm{polylog} d$, where constant $C(q)$ only depends on the degree of $sigma_*$, regardless of information exponent; this dimension dependence matches the information theoretic limit up to polylogarithmic factors. Core to our analysis is the reuse of minibatch in the gradient computation, which gives rise to higher-order information beyond correlational queries.
Read more6/4/2024