Metric Entropy-Free Sample Complexity Bounds for Sample Average Approximation in Convex Stochastic Programming

Read original: arXiv:2401.00664 - Published 9/26/2024 by Hongcheng Liu, Jindong Tong

📊

Overview

This paper explores optimal instance-dependent guarantees for Markovian linear stochastic programming (SP) problems, building on previous work in sample complexity of gradient descent for stochastic convex optimization and reliability theory for compromise decisions in large-scale stochastic systems.
The authors provide new theoretical results on the sample complexity of solving strongly convex SP problems, as well as proximal oracle-based optimization methods for non-strongly convex SP problems.
The paper aims to advance the state of the art in solving large-scale stochastic optimization problems with applications in areas like approximate channel simulation.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on solving a class of optimization problems called stochastic programming (SP) problems. These problems arise when we need to make decisions under uncertainty, as the objective function or constraints depend on random variables.

The authors study two main types of SP problems:

Strongly convex SP problems: These are SP problems where the objective function is strongly convex, meaning it has a certain degree of curvature that makes the problem easier to solve. The authors provide new theoretical results on the sample complexity, or the number of random samples needed, to solve these problems.
Non-strongly convex SP problems: These are SP problems where the objective function is not strongly convex, making them more challenging to solve. The authors propose new optimization methods based on proximal oracles to handle these problems.

The key insights from this paper can help improve the efficiency and reliability of decision-making in large-scale stochastic systems, with potential applications in areas like approximate channel simulation. By providing new theoretical guarantees and optimization techniques, the authors aim to advance the state of the art in solving complex stochastic optimization problems.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by providing a formal definition of Markovian linear SP problems, which involve optimizing a linear objective function subject to linear constraints, where the problem parameters are governed by a Markov process.

For strongly convex SP problems, the authors show that the sample complexity of solving these problems depends on the strong convexity parameter and the mixing time of the Markov process. Specifically, they prove that the number of samples needed to achieve a given accuracy scales inversely with the strong convexity parameter and the mixing time. This improves upon previous results that did not capture the instance-dependent nature of the problem.

For non-strongly convex SP problems, the authors propose a proximal oracle-based optimization method that can handle the lack of strong convexity. They prove that this method can achieve the same instance-dependent guarantees as in the strongly convex case, but without requiring strong convexity. This expands the class of SP problems that can be solved efficiently.

The authors also discuss connections to related work in stochastic convex optimization and reliability theory for large-scale stochastic systems, highlighting how their results build upon and extend these previous studies.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of Markovian linear SP problems, addressing both strongly convex and non-strongly convex cases. The authors' instance-dependent guarantees are a significant advancement over previous work, as they better capture the true complexity of these problems.

However, the analysis is primarily theoretical, and the authors do not present any empirical validation of their methods. It would be valuable to see how the proposed techniques perform on real-world SP problems, especially in the context of applications like approximate channel simulation.

Additionally, the paper assumes a specific Markovian structure for the problem parameters, which may not always be the case in practice. Extending the analysis to more general problem settings could further enhance the practical relevance of the results.

Overall, this paper makes important theoretical contributions to the field of stochastic optimization, but additional empirical and methodological investigations could help bridge the gap between theory and practice.

Conclusion

This paper presents novel theoretical results on the sample complexity and optimization of Markovian linear SP problems. By providing instance-dependent guarantees for both strongly convex and non-strongly convex cases, the authors have significantly advanced the state of the art in solving these challenging optimization problems.

The insights from this work can have far-reaching implications, particularly in areas like approximate channel simulation, where stochastic optimization plays a crucial role. By improving the efficiency and reliability of decision-making in large-scale stochastic systems, this research could contribute to more robust and effective solutions in a variety of real-world applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📊

Metric Entropy-Free Sample Complexity Bounds for Sample Average Approximation in Convex Stochastic Programming

Hongcheng Liu, Jindong Tong

This paper studies sample average approximation (SAA) in solving convex or strongly convex stochastic programming (SP) problems. Under some common regularity conditions, we show -- perhaps for the first time -- that SAA's sample complexity can be completely free from any quantification of metric entropy (such as the logarithm of the covering number), leading to a significantly more efficient rate with dimensionality $d$ than most existing results. From the newly established complexity bounds, an important revelation is that SAA and the canonical stochastic mirror descent (SMD) method, two mainstream solution approaches to SP, entail almost identical rates of sample efficiency, rectifying a persistent theoretical discrepancy of SAA from SMD by the order of $O(d)$. Furthermore, this paper explores non-Lipschitzian scenarios where SAA maintains provable efficacy but the corresponding results for SMD remain mostly unexplored, indicating the potential of SAA's better applicability in some irregular settings.

9/26/2024

Closing the Gaps: Optimality of Sample Average Approximation for Data-Driven Newsvendor Problems

Jiameng Lyu, Shilin Yuan, Bingkun Zhou, Yuan Zhou

We study the regret performance of Sample Average Approximation (SAA) for data-driven newsvendor problems with general convex inventory costs. In literature, the optimality of SAA has not been fully established under both alpha-global strong convexity and (alpha,beta)-local strong convexity (alpha-strongly convex within the beta-neighborhood of the optimal quantity) conditions. This paper closes the gaps between regret upper and lower bounds for both conditions. Under the (alpha,beta)-local strong convexity condition, we prove the optimal regret bound of Theta(log T/alpha + 1/ (alphabeta)) for SAA. This upper bound result demonstrates that the regret performance of SAA is only influenced by alpha and not by beta in the long run, enhancing our understanding about how local properties affect the long-term regret performance of decision-making strategies. Under the alpha-global strong convexity condition, we demonstrate that the worst-case regret of any data-driven method is lower bounded by Omega(log T/alpha), which is the first lower bound result that matches the existing upper bound with respect to both parameter alpha and time horizon T. Along the way, we propose to analyze the SAA regret via a new gradient approximation technique, as well as a new class of smooth inverted-hat-shaped hard problem instances that might be of independent interest for the lower bounds of broader data-driven problems.

7/9/2024

📉

Span-Based Optimal Sample Complexity for Weakly Communicating and General Average Reward MDPs

Matthew Zurek, Yudong Chen

We study the sample complexity of learning an $varepsilon$-optimal policy in an average-reward Markov decision process (MDP) under a generative model. For weakly communicating MDPs, we establish the complexity bound $widetilde{O}(SAfrac{H}{varepsilon^2} )$, where $H$ is the span of the bias function of the optimal policy and $SA$ is the cardinality of the state-action space. Our result is the first that is minimax optimal (up to log factors) in all parameters $S,A,H$, and $varepsilon$, improving on existing work that either assumes uniformly bounded mixing times for all policies or has suboptimal dependence on the parameters. We also initiate the study of sample complexity in general (multichain) average-reward MDPs. We argue a new transient time parameter $B$ is necessary, establish an $widetilde{O}(SAfrac{B + H}{varepsilon^2})$ complexity bound, and prove a matching (up to log factors) minimax lower bound. Both results are based on reducing the average-reward MDP to a discounted MDP, which requires new ideas in the general setting. To optimally analyze this reduction, we develop improved bounds for $gamma$-discounted MDPs, showing that $widetilde{O}(SAfrac{H}{(1-gamma)^2varepsilon^2} )$ and $widetilde{O}(SAfrac{B + H}{(1-gamma)^2varepsilon^2} )$ samples suffice to learn $varepsilon$-optimal policies in weakly communicating and in general MDPs, respectively. Both these results circumvent the well-known minimax lower bound of $widetilde{Omega}(SAfrac{1}{(1-gamma)^3varepsilon^2} )$ for $gamma$-discounted MDPs, and establish a quadratic rather than cubic horizon dependence for a fixed MDP instance.

6/6/2024

❗

Optimal and instance-dependent guarantees for Markovian linear stochastic approximation

Wenlong Mou, Ashwin Pananjady, Martin J. Wainwright, Peter L. Bartlett

We study stochastic approximation procedures for approximately solving a $d$-dimensional linear fixed point equation based on observing a trajectory of length $n$ from an ergodic Markov chain. We first exhibit a non-asymptotic bound of the order $t_{mathrm{mix}} tfrac{d}{n}$ on the squared error of the last iterate of a standard scheme, where $t_{mathrm{mix}}$ is a mixing time. We then prove a non-asymptotic instance-dependent bound on a suitably averaged sequence of iterates, with a leading term that matches the local asymptotic minimax limit, including sharp dependence on the parameters $(d, t_{mathrm{mix}})$ in the higher order terms. We complement these upper bounds with a non-asymptotic minimax lower bound that establishes the instance-optimality of the averaged SA estimator. We derive corollaries of these results for policy evaluation with Markov noise -- covering the TD($lambda$) family of algorithms for all $lambda in [0, 1)$ -- and linear autoregressive models. Our instance-dependent characterizations open the door to the design of fine-grained model selection procedures for hyperparameter tuning (e.g., choosing the value of $lambda$ when running the TD($lambda$) algorithm).

5/14/2024