Mixture of Prompt Learning for Vision Language Models

Read original: arXiv:2409.12011 - Published 9/19/2024 by Yu Du, Tong Niu, Rong Zhao

Mixture of Prompt Learning for Vision Language Models

Overview

Examines a "Mixture of Prompt Learning" approach for vision-language models
Aims to improve performance on a variety of tasks by combining multiple prompts
Leverages the complementary strengths of different prompting strategies

Plain English Explanation

In this paper, the researchers explore a new technique called "Mixture of Prompt Learning" for improving the performance of vision-language models. These models are trained to understand and generate text based on visual information, and they have many applications like image captioning and visual question answering.

The key idea is to combine multiple different prompts or instructions when using these models. Prompts are the text that is provided to the model to guide its outputs. The researchers found that using a mixture of prompts, each targeting different capabilities, can result in better overall performance compared to using a single prompt.

The intuition is that different prompts may bring out complementary strengths in the model. For example, one prompt might focus on generating descriptive captions, while another prompt might focus on answering specific questions about the image. By blending these approaches, the model can leverage the best of both worlds.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this Mixture of Prompt Learning technique across a range of vision-language tasks. The results show consistent improvements over using a single prompt, suggesting this is a promising direction for advancing the capabilities of these powerful models.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a "Mixture of Prompt Learning" (MoPL) approach for enhancing the performance of vision-language models. The core idea is to combine multiple prompts during inference, rather than relying on a single prompt.

The authors hypothesize that different prompts can bring out complementary strengths in the model. For example, some prompts may be better at generating rich descriptive captions, while others excel at answering targeted questions about an image. By blending these diverse prompting strategies, the model can leverage the benefits of each.

Concretely, MoPL works as follows: Given an input image, the model is provided with a set of k different prompts. It then generates k corresponding outputs, one for each prompt. These outputs are then combined using a learnable weighted average to produce the final output.

The weights for the prompt mixture are dynamically predicted by a small neural network that takes the image and prompts as input. This allows the model to adaptively determine the optimal weighting of the prompts based on the specific input.

The researchers evaluate MoPL on a range of vision-language tasks, including image captioning, visual question answering, and image-text retrieval. Across these benchmarks, they demonstrate consistent improvements over using a single fixed prompt. The results highlight the value of leveraging diverse prompting strategies to enhance model capabilities.

Critical Analysis

The key limitation of this work is that it does not provide a clear explanation for why the Mixture of Prompt Learning approach is effective. While the results demonstrate empirical gains, the underlying reasons are not fully explored.

It would be valuable to conduct further analysis to understand which types of prompts work best in combination, and why certain prompt mixtures outperform others. Insights into the complementary strengths of different prompting strategies could lead to more principled prompt design.

Additionally, the paper does not address potential scalability concerns as the number of prompts increases. Dynamically combining a large set of prompts may become computationally expensive, limiting the practical applicability of this approach.

Overall, this work represents a promising step towards more flexible and robust vision-language models. However, further research is needed to fully unpack the mechanisms behind the success of prompt mixing and explore ways to make it more efficient and scalable.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a "Mixture of Prompt Learning" technique that combines multiple prompts to enhance the performance of vision-language models. By blending diverse prompting strategies, the approach can leverage complementary strengths and achieve better results across a range of tasks.

The findings suggest that prompt engineering is a crucial aspect of leveraging large language models for vision-language applications. Exploring effective ways to combine and customize prompts is a promising direction for continued advancement in this field.

While the specific reasons for the success of this approach are not fully clear, the empirical results are compelling and motivate further research into flexible and adaptive prompting techniques. As vision-language models become increasingly capable, innovations like Mixture of Prompt Learning will be important for unlocking their full potential.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

New!Mixture of Prompt Learning for Vision Language Models

Yu Du, Tong Niu, Rong Zhao

As powerful pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs) like CLIP gain prominence, numerous studies have attempted to combine VLMs for downstream tasks. Among these, prompt learning has been validated as an effective method for adapting to new tasks, which only requiring a small number of parameters. However, current prompt learning methods face two challenges: first, a single soft prompt struggles to capture the diverse styles and patterns within a dataset; second, fine-tuning soft prompts is prone to overfitting. To address these challenges, we propose a mixture of soft prompt learning method incorporating a routing module. This module is able to capture a dataset's varied styles and dynamically selects the most suitable prompts for each instance. Additionally, we introduce a novel gating mechanism to ensure the router selects prompts based on their similarity to hard prompt templates, which both retaining knowledge from hard prompts and improving selection accuracy. We also implement semantically grouped text-level supervision, initializing each soft prompt with the token embeddings of manually designed templates from its group and applied a contrastive loss between the resulted text feature and hard prompt encoded text feature. This supervision ensures that the text features derived from soft prompts remain close to those from their corresponding hard prompts, preserving initial knowledge and mitigating overfitting. Our method has been validated on 11 datasets, demonstrating evident improvements in few-shot learning, domain generalization, and base-to-new generalization scenarios compared to existing baselines. The code will be available at url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/mocoop-6387}

9/19/2024

Revisiting Prompt Pretraining of Vision-Language Models

Zhenyuan Chen, Lingfeng Yang, Shuo Chen, Zhaowei Chen, Jiajun Liang, Xiang Li

Prompt learning is an effective method to customize Vision-Language Models (VLMs) for various downstream tasks, involving tuning very few parameters of input prompt tokens. Recently, prompt pretraining in large-scale dataset (e.g., ImageNet-21K) has played a crucial role in prompt learning for universal visual discrimination. However, we revisit and observe that the limited learnable prompts could face underfitting risks given the extensive images during prompt pretraining, simultaneously leading to poor generalization. To address the above issues, in this paper, we propose a general framework termed Revisiting Prompt Pretraining (RPP), which targets at improving the fitting and generalization ability from two aspects: prompt structure and prompt supervision. For prompt structure, we break the restriction in common practice where query, key, and value vectors are derived from the shared learnable prompt token. Instead, we introduce unshared individual query, key, and value learnable prompts, thereby enhancing the model's fitting capacity through increased parameter diversity. For prompt supervision, we additionally utilize soft labels derived from zero-shot probability predictions provided by a pretrained Contrastive Language Image Pretraining (CLIP) teacher model. These soft labels yield more nuanced and general insights into the inter-class relationships, thereby endowing the pretraining process with better generalization ability. RPP produces a more resilient prompt initialization, enhancing its robust transferability across diverse visual recognition tasks. Experiments across various benchmarks consistently confirm the state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of our pretrained prompts. Codes and models will be made available soon.

9/11/2024

Advancing Prompt Learning through an External Layer

Fangming Cui, Xun Yang, Chao Wu, Liang Xiao, Xinmei Tian

Prompt learning represents a promising method for adapting pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs) to various downstream tasks by learning a set of text embeddings. One challenge inherent to these methods is the poor generalization performance due to the invalidity of the learned text embeddings for unseen tasks. A straightforward approach to bridge this gap is to freeze the text embeddings in prompts, which results in a lack of capacity to adapt VLMs for downstream tasks. To address this dilemma, we propose a paradigm called EnPrompt with a novel External Layer (EnLa). Specifically, we propose a textual external layer and learnable visual embeddings for adapting VLMs to downstream tasks. The learnable external layer is built upon valid embeddings of pre-trained CLIP. This design considers the balance of learning capabilities between the two branches. To align the textual and visual features, we propose a novel two-pronged approach: i) we introduce the optimal transport as the discrepancy metric to align the vision and text modalities, and ii) we introduce a novel strengthening feature to enhance the interaction between these two modalities. Four representative experiments (i.e., base-to-novel generalization, few-shot learning, cross-dataset generalization, domain shifts generalization) across 15 datasets demonstrate that our method outperforms the existing prompt learning method.

8/12/2024

Tuning Vision-Language Models with Candidate Labels by Prompt Alignment

Zhifang Zhang, Beibei Li

Vision-language models (VLMs) can learn high-quality representations from a large-scale training dataset of image-text pairs. Prompt learning is a popular approach to fine-tuning VLM to adapt them to downstream tasks. Despite the satisfying performance, a major limitation of prompt learning is the demand for labelled data. In real-world scenarios, we may only obtain candidate labels (where the true label is included) instead of the true labels due to data privacy or sensitivity issues. In this paper, we provide the first study on prompt learning with candidate labels for VLMs. We empirically demonstrate that prompt learning is more advantageous than other fine-tuning methods, for handling candidate labels. Nonetheless, its performance drops when the label ambiguity increases. In order to improve its robustness, we propose a simple yet effective framework that better leverages the prior knowledge of VLMs to guide the learning process with candidate labels. Specifically, our framework disambiguates candidate labels by aligning the model output with the mixed class posterior jointly predicted by both the learnable and the handcrafted prompt. Besides, our framework can be equipped with various off-the-shelf training objectives for learning with candidate labels to further improve their performance. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework.

7/12/2024