Model-based Subsampling for Knowledge Graph Completion

Overview

• Subsampling is an effective technique in Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE) to reduce overfitting caused by the sparsity of Knowledge Graph (KG) datasets.
• Current subsampling approaches only consider the frequencies of queries consisting of entities and their relations, potentially underestimating the appearance probabilities of infrequent queries with high-frequency entities or relations.
• The paper proposes two new subsampling methods, Model-based Subsampling (MBS) and Mixed Subsampling (MIX), to better estimate the appearance probabilities of queries using KGE model predictions.
• Evaluation on popular KGE models, including RotatE, TransE, HAKE, ComplEx, and DistMult, showed improved KG completion performance using the proposed subsampling methods.

Plain English Explanation

Knowledge graphs are structured databases that represent information as a network of interconnected entities and their relationships. When training models to understand and predict these knowledge graphs, researchers often encounter a problem called "sparsity," where the data is spread out and incomplete. This makes it challenging for the models to learn effectively.

To address this, the researchers in this paper explored a technique called "subsampling." Subsampling involves selectively choosing a subset of the data to train on, which can help the model learn better. However, the current subsampling approaches only consider the frequency of the individual entities and relationships, and can sometimes underestimate the importance of less common queries.

To improve upon this, the researchers proposed two new subsampling methods: Model-based Subsampling (MBS) and Mixed Subsampling (MIX). These methods use the predictions of the knowledge graph embedding models themselves to better estimate the appearance probabilities of different queries, including the less common ones.

The researchers tested these new subsampling methods on several popular knowledge graph embedding models, and found that they actually improved the models' performance in completing missing information in the knowledge graphs. This suggests that their approach of using the model's own predictions to guide the subsampling process is an effective way to overcome the challenges posed by sparse knowledge graph data.

Technical Explanation

The paper addresses the problem of subsampling in Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE), a technique used to represent entities and relations in a knowledge graph as vectors. Subsampling is an effective way to reduce overfitting caused by the sparsity of KG datasets, but current approaches only consider the frequencies of queries consisting of entities and relations.

The authors propose two new subsampling methods to better estimate the appearance probabilities of queries:

1. Model-based Subsampling (MBS): This method uses the predictions of a KGE model to estimate the appearance probabilities of queries. The model is first trained on the full dataset, then used to predict the probabilities of different queries. These predicted probabilities are then used to guide the subsampling process.

2. Mixed Subsampling (MIX): This method combines the frequency-based subsampling approach with the model-based approach from MBS. It aims to leverage the strengths of both methods to better capture the importance of queries.

The authors evaluate these subsampling methods on several popular KGE models, including RotatE, TransE, HAKE, ComplEx, and DistMult, using the FB15k-237, WN18RR, and YAGO3-10 datasets. The results show that the proposed subsampling methods can improve the KG completion performance of these models compared to the standard frequency-based subsampling approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel approach to subsampling in KGE that addresses the limitations of existing methods. By incorporating the predictions of KGE models to estimate query appearance probabilities, the proposed MBS and MIX methods show promising results in improving KG completion performance.

One potential limitation is that the performance of the subsampling methods may be dependent on the accuracy of the underlying KGE models. If the models struggle to make accurate predictions, the subsampling process may not effectively capture the true importance of different queries.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the computational and memory overhead introduced by the model-based subsampling approaches. Incorporating model predictions into the subsampling process may incur additional overhead, which could be a consideration for practical deployments.

Further research could investigate the robustness of the proposed methods to different types of KG datasets, as well as explore ways to minimize the computational impact of the model-based subsampling approach. Incorporating other types of information, such as the semantic or structural properties of the knowledge graph, could also be an interesting direction to enhance the subsampling process.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to subsampling in Knowledge Graph Embedding that addresses the limitations of current frequency-based methods. By leveraging the predictions of KGE models to estimate the appearance probabilities of queries, the proposed Model-based Subsampling (MBS) and Mixed Subsampling (MIX) methods demonstrate improved performance in KG completion tasks across various popular KGE models.

The key contribution of this work is the insight that incorporating model-based information can help better capture the importance of less frequent queries, which are often underestimated by traditional subsampling approaches. This research highlights the potential benefits of using model-guided techniques to enhance data sampling strategies in knowledge graph learning, and could inspire further developments in this direction.