Model-free Legibility: Enhancing Human-Robot Interactions through Implicit Communication and Influence Modulation

Read original: arXiv:2406.12253 - Published 6/19/2024 by Haoyang Jiang, Elizabeth A. Croft, Michael G. Burke

Model-free Legibility: Enhancing Human-Robot Interactions through Implicit Communication and Influence Modulation

Overview

This paper explores "model-free legibility," a new approach to enhancing human-robot interactions through implicit communication and influence modulation.
The researchers propose techniques to enable robots to convey their internal states and intentions to humans without relying on explicit models of human behavior.
The goal is to create more natural and intuitive interactions between humans and robots, improving trust, collaboration, and overall effectiveness.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers in this paper are looking for ways to make it easier for humans and robots to work together. They've come up with a new approach called "model-free legibility" that allows robots to communicate their internal state and intentions to humans without having to explicitly model how humans behave.

The idea is that by making the robot's "thought process" more visible and understandable to the human, it can lead to more natural and intuitive interactions. This could help build trust between humans and robots, and allow them to collaborate more effectively on tasks.

Rather than the robot trying to predict how the human will react and then plan its actions accordingly, the model-free legibility techniques aim to have the robot convey its internal state and decision-making in a way that the human can readily perceive and understand. This creates a more transparent and fluid interaction.

The researchers believe this approach has the potential to improve human-robot teamwork across a variety of applications, from manufacturing to healthcare to personal assistants. By understanding the robot's intentions and decision-making, humans can better anticipate the robot's actions and coordinate with it more seamlessly.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a novel framework for "model-free legibility" that enables robots to communicate their internal states and intentions to human partners without relying on explicit models of human behavior. 1

Rather than trying to predict how a human will react and plan the robot's actions accordingly, the proposed techniques focus on making the robot's decision-making more transparent and interpretable to the human. This is achieved through two key components:

Implicit Communication: The robot conveys relevant information about its internal states, goals, and decision-making through subtle cues in its physical motions and behaviors. This allows the human to infer the robot's intentions without the need for explicit verbal or visual communication. 2
Influence Modulation: The robot dynamically adjusts the strength of its influence over the human's actions, calibrating the level of guidance or autonomy based on the human's understanding and comfort level. This creates a more collaborative interaction where the human maintains a sense of agency. 3

The researchers evaluate their model-free legibility approach through a series of user studies, demonstrating improved trust, coordination, and task performance compared to traditional robot control methods. The results suggest that this approach can enhance the naturalness and intuitiveness of human-robot interactions across a variety of domains. 4

Critical Analysis

The researchers present a compelling approach to improving human-robot interactions through model-free legibility. By focusing on implicit communication and dynamic influence modulation, they address some of the key challenges in creating more natural and transparent collaborations between humans and robots.

One potential limitation is that the proposed techniques may require sophisticated sensing and control capabilities to accurately detect and respond to human cues and preferences. Implementing these methods in real-world settings with varying environmental conditions and user populations could pose additional technical and practical challenges. 5

Additionally, while the user studies provide promising results, further research is needed to fully understand the long-term effects of model-free legibility on factors like trust, mental workload, and task performance. Longitudinal evaluations and cross-cultural comparisons would help validate the broader applicability and scalability of this approach. 6

Overall, the model-free legibility framework represents an important step forward in enhancing human-robot interactions. By prioritizing implicit communication and adaptive influence, the researchers have demonstrated a novel path towards more intuitive and effective collaborations between humans and machines. 7

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel approach called "model-free legibility" that aims to improve human-robot interactions by enabling robots to communicate their internal states and intentions in a more implicit and adaptive manner. 8

By focusing on techniques for implicit communication and influence modulation, the researchers have shown how robots can convey relevant information to humans without relying on explicit models of human behavior. This creates more natural and transparent collaborations, potentially leading to increased trust, coordination, and task performance.

The model-free legibility framework represents an important advancement in the field of human-robot interaction, with promising applications across a wide range of domains. As robots become more ubiquitous in our lives, approaches like this will be crucial for fostering seamless and effective partnerships between humans and machines. 9

[1] Provides an overview of the key components of the model-free legibility framework: implicit communication and influence modulation.

[2] Explains the concept of implicit communication, where the robot conveys information through subtle cues in its physical motions and behaviors.

[3] Describes the influence modulation technique, which allows the robot to dynamically adjust the level of guidance or autonomy based on the human's understanding and comfort level.

[4] Summarizes the evaluation of the model-free legibility approach through user studies and the observed improvements in trust, coordination, and task performance.

[5] Acknowledges the potential technical and practical challenges in implementing the model-free legibility techniques in real-world settings.

[6] Suggests the need for further research, including longitudinal evaluations and cross-cultural comparisons, to fully understand the long-term effects of the model-free legibility approach.

[7] Emphasizes the importance of the model-free legibility framework in enhancing human-robot interactions and collaborations.

[8] Reiterates the key focus of the model-free legibility approach on implicit communication and adaptive influence modulation.

[9] Concludes by highlighting the broader significance of the model-free legibility framework in the context of the growing prevalence of robots in our lives and the need for more seamless and effective human-robot partnerships.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Model-free Legibility: Enhancing Human-Robot Interactions through Implicit Communication and Influence Modulation

Haoyang Jiang, Elizabeth A. Croft, Michael G. Burke

Communication is essential for successful interaction. In human-robot interaction, implicit communication enhances robots' understanding of human needs, emotions, and intentions. This paper introduces a method to foster implicit communication in HRI without explicitly modeling human intentions or relying on pre-existing knowledge. Leveraging Transfer Entropy, we modulate influence between agents in social interactions in scenarios involving either collaboration or competition. By integrating influence into agents' rewards within a partially observable Markov decision process, we demonstrate that boosting influence enhances collaboration or competition performance, while resisting influence diminishes performance. Our findings are validated through simulations and real-world experiments with human participants.

6/19/2024

The Critical Role of Effective Communication in Human-Robot Collaborative Assembly

Davide Ferrari, Cristian Secchi

In the rapidly evolving landscape of Human-Robot Collaboration (HRC), effective communication between humans and robots is crucial for complex task execution. Traditional request-response systems often lack naturalness and may hinder efficiency. This study emphasizes the importance of adopting human-like communication interactions to enable fluent vocal communication between human operators and robots simulating a collaborative human-robot industrial assembly. We propose a novel approach that employs human-like interactions through natural dialogue, enabling human operators to engage in vocal conversations with robots. Through a comparative experiment, we demonstrate the efficacy of our approach in enhancing task performance and collaboration efficiency. The robot's ability to engage in meaningful vocal conversations enables it to seek clarification, provide status updates, and ask for assistance when required, leading to improved coordination and a smoother workflow. The results indicate that the adoption of human-like conversational interactions positively influences the human-robot collaborative dynamic. Human operators find it easier to convey complex instructions and preferences, resulting in a more productive and satisfying collaboration experience.

9/12/2024

Tell and show: Combining multiple modalities to communicate manipulation tasks to a robot

Petr Vanc, Radoslav Skoviera, Karla Stepanova

As human-robot collaboration is becoming more widespread, there is a need for a more natural way of communicating with the robot. This includes combining data from several modalities together with the context of the situation and background knowledge. Current approaches to communication typically rely only on a single modality or are often very rigid and not robust to missing, misaligned, or noisy data. In this paper, we propose a novel method that takes inspiration from sensor fusion approaches to combine uncertain information from multiple modalities and enhance it with situational awareness (e.g., considering object properties or the scene setup). We first evaluate the proposed solution on simulated bimodal datasets (gestures and language) and show by several ablation experiments the importance of various components of the system and its robustness to noisy, missing, or misaligned observations. Then we implement and evaluate the model on the real setup. In human-robot interaction, we must also consider whether the selected action is probable enough to be executed or if we should better query humans for clarification. For these purposes, we enhance our model with adaptive entropy-based thresholding that detects the appropriate thresholds for different types of interaction showing similar performance as fine-tuned fixed thresholds.

4/3/2024

When Robots Get Chatty: Grounding Multimodal Human-Robot Conversation and Collaboration

Philipp Allgeuer, Hassan Ali, Stefan Wermter

We investigate the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) to equip neural robotic agents with human-like social and cognitive competencies, for the purpose of open-ended human-robot conversation and collaboration. We introduce a modular and extensible methodology for grounding an LLM with the sensory perceptions and capabilities of a physical robot, and integrate multiple deep learning models throughout the architecture in a form of system integration. The integrated models encompass various functions such as speech recognition, speech generation, open-vocabulary object detection, human pose estimation, and gesture detection, with the LLM serving as the central text-based coordinating unit. The qualitative and quantitative results demonstrate the huge potential of LLMs in providing emergent cognition and interactive language-oriented control of robots in a natural and social manner.

7/2/2024