More is Better: Deep Domain Adaptation with Multiple Sources
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Difficulty in obtaining large-scale labeled data for training state-of-the-art deep neural networks
- Transferring knowledge from a separate, labeled source domain to an unlabeled or sparsely labeled target domain as an alternative
- Direct transfer often results in significant performance decay due to domain shift
- Domain adaptation (DA) aims to align the distributions between the source and target domains
- Multi-source domain adaptation (MDA) leverages labeled data from multiple sources with different distributions
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models, which are at the forefront of many AI applications, typically require a large amount of labeled data to achieve state-of-the-art performance. However, collecting and labeling this data can be difficult and expensive. An alternative approach is to take what a model has learned from a different, labeled dataset (the "source" domain) and apply that knowledge to a new, unlabeled or sparsely labeled dataset (the "target" domain).
The challenge is that the source and target domains may have different statistical properties, a phenomenon known as "domain shift." This can lead to a significant drop in the model's performance when transferred to the new domain. Domain adaptation techniques aim to address this problem by aligning the distributions of the source and target data, effectively "bridging the gap" between the two domains.
Multi-source domain adaptation (MDA) takes this a step further by leveraging labeled data from multiple different source domains, each with its own statistical characteristics. This can be a more practical and powerful approach, as real-world datasets often come from diverse sources with varying properties. By combining knowledge from multiple sources, MDA methods can potentially achieve better performance and robustness in the target domain compared to using a single source.
Technical Explanation
This survey paper first defines various strategies for multi-source domain adaptation (MDA). It then systematically summarizes and compares modern MDA methods in the deep learning era from different perspectives, such as the underlying technical approaches and the types of domain shifts they can handle.
The paper also covers commonly used MDA datasets and provides a brief benchmark of different methods. Finally, it discusses future research directions for MDA that are worth investigating, such as achieving reliable and fair diagnosis in medical applications and developing more efficient MDA techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the MDA field, highlighting the key challenges and describing various techniques to address them. However, the authors also acknowledge the limitations of current MDA methods, such as their sensitivity to certain types of domain shifts and the difficulty in scaling to a large number of source domains.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential ethical concerns of MDA, such as the risk of amplifying biases present in the source domains or the challenges in ensuring fairness and robustness across diverse populations. These are important considerations that should be explored further as MDA techniques become more widely adopted.
Conclusion
This survey paper offers a valuable introduction to the field of multi-source domain adaptation, a powerful extension of standard domain adaptation that can help overcome the challenges of obtaining large-scale labeled data for training deep neural networks. By leveraging knowledge from multiple source domains, MDA methods have the potential to improve the generalization and robustness of AI systems, with applications across a wide range of industries and domains. However, further research is needed to address the remaining limitations and ensure the responsible development and deployment of these techniques.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
More is Better: Deep Domain Adaptation with Multiple Sources
Sicheng Zhao, Hui Chen, Hu Huang, Pengfei Xu, Guiguang Ding
In many practical applications, it is often difficult and expensive to obtain large-scale labeled data to train state-of-the-art deep neural networks. Therefore, transferring the learned knowledge from a separate, labeled source domain to an unlabeled or sparsely labeled target domain becomes an appealing alternative. However, direct transfer often results in significant performance decay due to domain shift. Domain adaptation (DA) aims to address this problem by aligning the distributions between the source and target domains. Multi-source domain adaptation (MDA) is a powerful and practical extension in which the labeled data may be collected from multiple sources with different distributions. In this survey, we first define various MDA strategies. Then we systematically summarize and compare modern MDA methods in the deep learning era from different perspectives, followed by commonly used datasets and a brief benchmark. Finally, we discuss future research directions for MDA that are worth investigating.
Read more5/3/2024
0
FMDA-OT: Federated Multi-source Domain Adaptation Through Optimal Transport
Omar Ghannou, Youn`es Bennani
Multi-source Domain Adaptation (MDA) seeks to adapt models trained on data from multiple labeled source domains to perform effectively on an unlabeled target domain data, assuming access to sources data. To address the challenges of model adaptation and data privacy, we introduce Collaborative MDA Through Optimal Transport (CMDA-OT), a novel framework consisting of two key phases. In the first phase, each source domain is independently adapted to the target domain using optimal transport methods. In the second phase, a centralized collaborative learning architecture is employed, which aggregates the N models from the N sources without accessing their data, thereby safeguarding privacy. During this process, the server leverages a small set of pseudo-labeled samples from the target domain, known as the target validation subset, to refine and guide the adaptation. This dual-phase approach not only improves model performance on the target domain but also addresses vital privacy challenges inherent in domain adaptation.
Read more8/20/2024
🤷
0
Multi-source Unsupervised Domain Adaptation on Graphs with Transferability Modeling
Tianxiang Zhao, Dongsheng Luo, Xiang Zhang, Suhang Wang
In this paper, we tackle a new problem of textit{multi-source unsupervised domain adaptation (MSUDA) for graphs}, where models trained on annotated source domains need to be transferred to the unsupervised target graph for node classification. Due to the discrepancy in distribution across domains, the key challenge is how to select good source instances and how to adapt the model. Diverse graph structures further complicate this problem, rendering previous MSUDA approaches less effective. In this work, we present the framework Selective Multi-source Adaptation for Graph ({method}), with a graph-modeling-based domain selector, a sub-graph node selector, and a bi-level alignment objective for the adaptation. Concretely, to facilitate the identification of informative source data, the similarity across graphs is disentangled and measured with the transferability of a graph-modeling task set, and we use it as evidence for source domain selection. A node selector is further incorporated to capture the variation in transferability of nodes within the same source domain. To learn invariant features for adaptation, we align the target domain to selected source data both at the embedding space by minimizing the optimal transport distance and at the classification level by distilling the label function. Modules are explicitly learned to select informative source data and conduct the alignment in virtual training splits with a meta-learning strategy. Experimental results on five graph datasets show the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Read more6/26/2024
0
Overcoming Negative Transfer by Online Selection: Distant Domain Adaptation for Fault Diagnosis
Ziyan Wang, Mohamed Ragab, Wenmian Yang, Min Wu, Sinno Jialin Pan, Jie Zhang, Zhenghua Chen
Unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) has achieved remarkable success in fault diagnosis, bringing significant benefits to diverse industrial applications. While most UDA methods focus on cross-working condition scenarios where the source and target domains are notably similar, real-world applications often grapple with severe domain shifts. We coin the term `distant domain adaptation problem' to describe the challenge of adapting from a labeled source domain to a significantly disparate unlabeled target domain. This problem exhibits the risk of negative transfer, where extraneous knowledge from the source domain adversely affects the target domain performance. Unfortunately, conventional UDA methods often falter in mitigating this negative transfer, leading to suboptimal performance. In response to this challenge, we propose a novel Online Selective Adversarial Alignment (OSAA) approach. Central to OSAA is its ability to dynamically identify and exclude distant source samples via an online gradient masking approach, focusing primarily on source samples that closely resemble the target samples. Furthermore, recognizing the inherent complexities in bridging the source and target domains, we construct an intermediate domain to act as a transitional domain and ease the adaptation process. Lastly, we develop a class-conditional adversarial adaptation to address the label distribution disparities while learning domain invariant representation to account for potential label distribution disparities between the domains. Through detailed experiments and ablation studies on two real-world datasets, we validate the superior performance of the OSAA method over state-of-the-art methods, underscoring its significant utility in practical scenarios with severe domain shifts.
Read more5/29/2024