MuChin: A Chinese Colloquial Description Benchmark for Evaluating Language Models in the Field of Music
2402.09871
0
0
💬
Abstract
The rapidly evolving multimodal Large Language Models (LLMs) urgently require new benchmarks to uniformly evaluate their performance on understanding and textually describing music. However, due to semantic gaps between Music Information Retrieval (MIR) algorithms and human understanding, discrepancies between professionals and the public, and low precision of annotations, existing music description datasets cannot serve as benchmarks. To this end, we present MuChin, the first open-source music description benchmark in Chinese colloquial language, designed to evaluate the performance of multimodal LLMs in understanding and describing music. We established the Caichong Music Annotation Platform (CaiMAP) that employs an innovative multi-person, multi-stage assurance method, and recruited both amateurs and professionals to ensure the precision of annotations and alignment with popular semantics. Utilizing this method, we built a dataset with multi-dimensional, high-precision music annotations, the Caichong Music Dataset (CaiMD), and carefully selected 1,000 high-quality entries to serve as the test set for MuChin. Based on MuChin, we analyzed the discrepancies between professionals and amateurs in terms of music description, and empirically demonstrated the effectiveness of annotated data for fine-tuning LLMs. Ultimately, we employed MuChin to evaluate existing music understanding models on their ability to provide colloquial descriptions of music. All data related to the benchmark, along with the scoring code and detailed appendices, have been open-sourced (https://github.com/CarlWangChina/MuChin/).
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Researchers have developed a new benchmark called MuChin to evaluate how well large language models can understand and describe music.
- Existing music description datasets have limitations, such as discrepancies between professionals and the public, and low precision of annotations.
- MuChin is the first open-source music description benchmark in Chinese colloquial language, designed to address these issues.
Plain English Explanation
As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to advance, new powerful language models are being developed that can understand and generate human-like text. However, these models still struggle with certain specialized domains, like music. To address this, researchers have created a new benchmark called MuChin that aims to test how well these language models can understand and describe music.
The challenge is that existing datasets for describing music have some problems. For example, there are often differences between how music professionals and the general public describe music. Additionally, the quality of the annotations in these datasets is not always very precise.
MuChin tries to solve these issues by using a novel approach to collect high-quality music descriptions from both amateur and professional listeners. The researchers built a platform called CaiMAP that employed a multi-stage process to ensure the annotations were accurate and aligned with common language. They then selected 1,000 of the best descriptions to create the MuChin benchmark.
By using this benchmark, the researchers were able to study the differences between how professionals and amateurs describe music. They also showed that the annotated data from MuChin can be used to improve the performance of language models on music understanding tasks.
Technical Explanation
The key elements of this paper are:
Benchmark Development: The researchers created a new benchmark called MuChin to evaluate how well large language models can understand and describe music. They built the Caichong Music Annotation Platform (CaiMAP) to collect high-quality music descriptions from both amateur and professional listeners using a multi-stage process. This resulted in the Caichong Music Dataset (CaiMD), from which they selected 1,000 entries to serve as the MuChin test set.
Evaluating Discrepancies: Using the MuChin benchmark, the researchers analyzed the differences between how professionals and amateurs describe music. They found notable discrepancies in the language and semantics used by the two groups.
Model Fine-Tuning: The paper demonstrates that the annotated data from the CaiMD can be effectively used to fine-tune large language models and improve their performance on music understanding tasks.
Open-Source Release: The researchers have open-sourced all the data and code related to the MuChin benchmark, making it available for the research community.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge some limitations of their work, such as the benchmark being focused on Chinese language data, which may limit its applicability to other languages. They also note that the dataset, while large, may not capture the full breadth of music description semantics.
One potential issue not addressed in the paper is the subjective nature of music description, which can vary greatly depending on individual preferences and experiences. It would be interesting to see how the MuChin benchmark handles this aspect of music understanding.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific shortcomings of existing music description datasets that MuChin aims to address. A more detailed comparison would help readers understand the unique contributions of this new benchmark.
Conclusion
The MuChin benchmark represents a significant step forward in the development of tools to evaluate how well large language models can understand and describe music. By addressing the limitations of existing datasets and employing a rigorous data collection process, the researchers have created a valuable resource for the research community.
The insights gained from using MuChin, such as the discrepancies between professional and amateur music descriptions, can inform the development of more robust and inclusive language models for music-related applications. Moreover, the open-sourcing of the benchmark and dataset will facilitate further research and exploration in this important domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
The Music Maestro or The Musically Challenged, A Massive Music Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
Jiajia Li, Lu Yang, Mingni Tang, Cong Chen, Zuchao Li, Ping Wang, Hai Zhao
0
0
Benchmark plays a pivotal role in assessing the advancements of large language models (LLMs). While numerous benchmarks have been proposed to evaluate LLMs' capabilities, there is a notable absence of a dedicated benchmark for assessing their musical abilities. To address this gap, we present ZIQI-Eval, a comprehensive and large-scale music benchmark specifically designed to evaluate the music-related capabilities of LLMs. ZIQI-Eval encompasses a wide range of questions, covering 10 major categories and 56 subcategories, resulting in over 14,000 meticulously curated data entries. By leveraging ZIQI-Eval, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation over 16 LLMs to evaluate and analyze LLMs' performance in the domain of music. Results indicate that all LLMs perform poorly on the ZIQI-Eval benchmark, suggesting significant room for improvement in their musical capabilities. With ZIQI-Eval, we aim to provide a standardized and robust evaluation framework that facilitates a comprehensive assessment of LLMs' music-related abilities. The dataset is available at GitHubfootnote{https://github.com/zcli-charlie/ZIQI-Eval} and HuggingFacefootnote{https://huggingface.co/datasets/MYTH-Lab/ZIQI-Eval}.
6/26/2024
C$^{3}$Bench: A Comprehensive Classical Chinese Understanding Benchmark for Large Language Models
Jiahuan Cao, Yongxin Shi, Dezhi Peng, Yang Liu, Lianwen Jin
0
0
Classical Chinese Understanding (CCU) holds significant value in preserving and exploration of the outstanding traditional Chinese culture. Recently, researchers have attempted to leverage the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) for CCU by capitalizing on their remarkable comprehension and semantic capabilities. However, no comprehensive benchmark is available to assess the CCU capabilities of LLMs. To fill this gap, this paper introduces C$^{3}$bench, a Comprehensive Classical Chinese understanding benchmark, which comprises 50,000 text pairs for five primary CCU tasks, including classification, retrieval, named entity recognition, punctuation, and translation. Furthermore, the data in C$^{3}$bench originates from ten different domains, covering most of the categories in classical Chinese. Leveraging the proposed C$^{3}$bench, we extensively evaluate the quantitative performance of 15 representative LLMs on all five CCU tasks. Our results not only establish a public leaderboard of LLMs' CCU capabilities but also gain some findings. Specifically, existing LLMs are struggle with CCU tasks and still inferior to supervised models. Additionally, the results indicate that CCU is a task that requires special attention. We believe this study could provide a standard benchmark, comprehensive baselines, and valuable insights for the future advancement of LLM-based CCU research. The evaluation pipeline and dataset are available at url{https://github.com/SCUT-DLVCLab/C3bench}.
5/31/2024
💬
MusiLingo: Bridging Music and Text with Pre-trained Language Models for Music Captioning and Query Response
Zihao Deng, Yinghao Ma, Yudong Liu, Rongchen Guo, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen, Wenhao Huang, Emmanouil Benetos
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown immense potential in multimodal applications, yet the convergence of textual and musical domains remains not well-explored. To address this gap, we present MusiLingo, a novel system for music caption generation and music-related query responses. MusiLingo employs a single projection layer to align music representations from the pre-trained frozen music audio model MERT with a frozen LLM, bridging the gap between music audio and textual contexts. We train it on an extensive music caption dataset and fine-tune it with instructional data. Due to the scarcity of high-quality music Q&A datasets, we created the MusicInstruct (MI) dataset from captions in the MusicCaps datasets, tailored for open-ended music inquiries. Empirical evaluations demonstrate its competitive performance in generating music captions and composing music-related Q&A pairs. Our introduced dataset enables notable advancements beyond previous ones.
4/3/2024
AudioBench: A Universal Benchmark for Audio Large Language Models
Bin Wang, Xunlong Zou, Geyu Lin, Shuo Sun, Zhuohan Liu, Wenyu Zhang, Zhengyuan Liu, AiTi Aw, Nancy F. Chen
0
0
We introduce AudioBench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate audio large language models (AudioLLMs). AudioBench encompasses 8 distinct tasks and 26 carefully selected or newly curated datasets, focusing on speech understanding, voice interpretation, and audio scene understanding. Despite the rapid advancement of large language models, including multimodal versions, a significant gap exists in comprehensive benchmarks for thoroughly evaluating their capabilities. AudioBench addresses this gap by providing relevant datasets and evaluation metrics. In our study, we evaluated the capabilities of four models across various aspects and found that no single model excels consistently across all tasks. We outline the research outlook for AudioLLMs and anticipate that our open-source code, data, and leaderboard will offer a robust testbed for future model developments.
6/26/2024