Multi-hop Question Answering
0
🛠️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Question Answering (QA) is a key task for natural language understanding and knowledge retrieval, with growing focus on more complex settings like Multi-Hop QA (MHQA)
- MHQA involves answering questions that require extracting and combining multiple pieces of information and performing multi-step reasoning
- The field has seen significant progress with high-quality datasets, models, and evaluation strategies, but the diversity of MHQA tasks makes it challenging to generalize
- This paper aims to provide a formal definition of MHQA and organize the existing MHQA frameworks, as well as outline best practices for building MHQA datasets
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses the task of Question Answering (QA), which is an important area of research in natural language understanding and knowledge retrieval. The focus has recently shifted to more complex settings like Multi-Hop QA (MHQA).
MHQA involves answering questions that require combining multiple pieces of information and performing multiple steps of reasoning. For example, to answer the question "The Argentine PGA Championship record holder has won how many tournaments worldwide?", you would need to first find out who the record holder is, and then determine how many tournaments that person has won overall.
The ability to answer these types of multi-step, multi-part questions can significantly improve the usefulness of natural language processing (NLP) systems. As a result, the field has seen rapid progress, with high-quality datasets, models, and evaluation strategies being developed.
However, the diverse range of MHQA tasks makes it challenging to generalize and survey the field. This paper aims to provide a clear, formal definition of MHQA and organize the existing MHQA frameworks. It also outlines best practices for building MHQA datasets.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by highlighting the importance of the Question Answering (QA) task, which has attracted significant research interest due to its relevance to language understanding and knowledge retrieval. The authors note that the field has shifted focus to more complex settings, such as Multi-Hop QA (MHQA).
MHQA is defined as the task of answering natural language questions that involve extracting and combining multiple pieces of information and performing multiple steps of reasoning. An example of a multi-hop question is "The Argentine PGA Championship record holder has won how many tournaments worldwide?", which requires finding the record holder and then determining the number of tournaments they have won.
The authors explain that the ability to answer multi-hop questions and perform multi-step reasoning can significantly improve the utility of NLP systems. Consequently, the field has seen a surge in high-quality datasets, models, and evaluation strategies.
However, the authors note that the notion of "multiple hops" is somewhat abstract, leading to a large variety of tasks that require multi-hop reasoning. This diversity makes it challenging to generalize and survey the field.
To address this, the paper aims to provide a formal definition of the MHQA task and organize the existing MHQA frameworks. The authors also outline some best practices for building MHQA datasets.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges the diversity of MHQA tasks as a key challenge in the field, making it difficult to generalize and survey the existing work. This is a valid concern, as the lack of a consistent, formal definition of MHQA can hinder progress and make it harder to compare different approaches.
The authors' goal of providing a clear, formal definition of MHQA and organizing the existing frameworks is a valuable contribution. This could help researchers better understand the scope and requirements of MHQA, as well as identify areas for improvement and future research.
However, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations or caveats of the MHQA task itself. For example, the paper does not discuss the potential biases or shortcomings of the existing MHQA datasets, or the challenges in designing evaluation metrics that accurately capture the multi-step reasoning abilities of systems.
Additionally, the paper does not critically analyze the current state-of-the-art MHQA models and their performance on real-world tasks. Incorporating such an analysis could provide valuable insights and guidance for future research directions.
Conclusion
This paper aims to provide a systematic and thorough introduction to the field of Multi-Hop Question Answering (MHQA), which has become an increasingly important and challenging task in natural language processing.
The key contributions of the paper are:
- Providing a formal definition of the MHQA task, which can help researchers better understand the scope and requirements of this problem.
- Organizing and summarizing the existing MHQA frameworks, which can aid in understanding the diversity of approaches and identifying areas for further research.
- Outlining best practices for building MHQA datasets, which can guide the development of higher-quality benchmarks for evaluating MHQA systems.
By addressing the challenges posed by the diversity of MHQA tasks, this paper lays the groundwork for more cohesive and impactful research in this field. The insights and recommendations presented can help drive the development of more capable and versatile natural language understanding systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
0
Multi-hop Question Answering
Vaibhav Mavi (New York University, United States of America), Anubhav Jangra (Indian Institute of Technology, Patna, India), Adam Jatowt (University of Innsbruck, Austria)
The task of Question Answering (QA) has attracted significant research interest for long. Its relevance to language understanding and knowledge retrieval tasks, along with the simple setting makes the task of QA crucial for strong AI systems. Recent success on simple QA tasks has shifted the focus to more complex settings. Among these, Multi-Hop QA (MHQA) is one of the most researched tasks over the recent years. In broad terms, MHQA is the task of answering natural language questions that involve extracting and combining multiple pieces of information and doing multiple steps of reasoning. An example of a multi-hop question would be The Argentine PGA Championship record holder has won how many tournaments worldwide?. Answering the question would need two pieces of information: Who is the record holder for Argentine PGA Championship tournaments? and How many tournaments did [Answer of Sub Q1] win?. The ability to answer multi-hop questions and perform multi step reasoning can significantly improve the utility of NLP systems. Consequently, the field has seen a surge with high quality datasets, models and evaluation strategies. The notion of 'multiple hops' is somewhat abstract which results in a large variety of tasks that require multi-hop reasoning. This leads to different datasets and models that differ significantly from each other and makes the field challenging to generalize and survey. We aim to provide a general and formal definition of the MHQA task, and organize and summarize existing MHQA frameworks. We also outline some best practices for building MHQA datasets. This book provides a systematic and thorough introduction as well as the structuring of the existing attempts to this highly interesting, yet quite challenging task.
Read more6/3/2024
0
MoreHopQA: More Than Multi-hop Reasoning
Julian Schnitzler, Xanh Ho, Jiahao Huang, Florian Boudin, Saku Sugawara, Akiko Aizawa
Most existing multi-hop datasets are extractive answer datasets, where the answers to the questions can be extracted directly from the provided context. This often leads models to use heuristics or shortcuts instead of performing true multi-hop reasoning. In this paper, we propose a new multi-hop dataset, MoreHopQA, which shifts from extractive to generative answers. Our dataset is created by utilizing three existing multi-hop datasets: HotpotQA, 2WikiMultihopQA, and MuSiQue. Instead of relying solely on factual reasoning, we enhance the existing multi-hop questions by adding another layer of questioning that involves one, two, or all three of the following types of reasoning: commonsense, arithmetic, and symbolic. Our dataset is created through a semi-automated process, resulting in a dataset with 1,118 samples that have undergone human verification. We then use our dataset to evaluate five different large language models: Mistral 7B, Gemma 7B, Llama 3 (8B and 70B), and GPT-4. We also design various cases to analyze the reasoning steps in the question-answering process. Our results show that models perform well on initial multi-hop questions but struggle with our extended questions, indicating that our dataset is more challenging than previous ones. Our analysis of question decomposition reveals that although models can correctly answer questions, only a portion - 38.7% for GPT-4 and 33.4% for Llama3-70B - achieve perfect reasoning, where all corresponding sub-questions are answered correctly. Evaluation code and data are available at https://github.com/Alab-NII/morehopqa
Read more6/21/2024
0
Grounded Multi-Hop VideoQA in Long-Form Egocentric Videos
Qirui Chen, Shangzhe Di, Weidi Xie
This paper considers the problem of Multi-Hop Video Question Answering (MH-VidQA) in long-form egocentric videos. This task not only requires to answer visual questions, but also to localize multiple relevant time intervals within the video as visual evidences. We develop an automated pipeline to create multi-hop question-answering pairs with associated temporal evidence, enabling to construct a large-scale dataset for instruction-tuning. To monitor the progress of this new task, we further curate a high-quality benchmark, MultiHop-EgoQA, with careful manual verification and refinement. Experimental results reveal that existing multi-modal systems exhibit inadequate multi-hop grounding and reasoning abilities, resulting in unsatisfactory performance. We then propose a novel architecture, termed as Grounding Scattered Evidence with Large Language Model (GeLM), that enhances multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) by incorporating a grounding module to retrieve temporal evidence from videos using flexible grounding tokens. Trained on our visual instruction data, GeLM demonstrates improved multi-hop grounding and reasoning capabilities, setting a new baseline for this challenging task. Furthermore, when trained on third-person view videos, the same architecture also achieves state-of-the-art performance on the single-hop VidQA benchmark, ActivityNet-RTL, demonstrating its effectiveness.
Read more8/27/2024
0
Retrieve, Summarize, Plan: Advancing Multi-hop Question Answering with an Iterative Approach
Zhouyu Jiang, Mengshu Sun, Lei Liang, Zhiqiang Zhang
Multi-hop question answering is a challenging task with distinct industrial relevance, and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods based on large language models (LLMs) have become a popular approach to tackle this task. Owing to the potential inability to retrieve all necessary information in a single iteration, a series of iterative RAG methods has been recently developed, showing significant performance improvements. However, existing methods still face two critical challenges: context overload resulting from multiple rounds of retrieval, and over-planning and repetitive planning due to the lack of a recorded retrieval trajectory. In this paper, we propose a novel iterative RAG method called ReSP, equipped with a dual-function summarizer. This summarizer compresses information from retrieved documents, targeting both the overarching question and the current sub-question concurrently. Experimental results on the multi-hop question-answering datasets HotpotQA and 2WikiMultihopQA demonstrate that our method significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art, and exhibits excellent robustness concerning context length.
Read more7/19/2024