Multifidelity Surrogate Models: A New Data Fusion Perspective
0
📊
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Multifidelity surrogate modelling combines data of varying accuracy and cost from different sources
- It strategically uses low-fidelity models for rapid evaluations, saving computational resources, and high-fidelity models for detailed refinement
- It improves decision-making by addressing uncertainties and surpassing the limits of single-fidelity models, which either oversimplify or are computationally intensive
- Blending high-fidelity data for detailed responses with frequent low-fidelity data for quick approximations facilitates design optimisation in various domains
Plain English Explanation
Multifidelity surrogate modelling is a technique that combines data from different sources, some of which are more accurate but more costly to obtain, and others which are less accurate but faster and cheaper. It uses the low-fidelity, or less accurate, data for quick initial evaluations to save computational resources, and the high-fidelity, or more accurate, data for detailed refinement. This approach allows for better decision-making by accounting for uncertainties and overcoming the limitations of single-fidelity models, which either oversimplify things or are computationally intensive.
By blending the high-fidelity data, which provides detailed responses, with the frequent low-fidelity data, which gives quick approximations, multifidelity surrogate modelling enables more efficient design optimisation across a variety of domains. [This approach can be useful in applications like [object Object], [object Object], and [object Object].]
Technical Explanation
Despite progress in areas like interpolation, regression, enhanced sampling, error estimation, variable fidelity, and data fusion techniques, challenges persist in selecting appropriate fidelity levels and developing efficient data fusion methods for multifidelity surrogate modelling.
This study proposes a new fusion approach to construct multi-fidelity surrogate models by using only gradients to build regression surfaces, rather than relying on the full response data. [This gradient-only surrogate modelling technique is demonstrated on [object Object] that isolate and illustrate the efficacy of the fusion approach, avoiding the need for more complex examples that could obscure the main concept.]
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that while there have been advancements in various techniques related to multifidelity surrogate modelling, there are still challenges in selecting appropriate fidelity levels and developing efficient data fusion methods. The proposed gradient-only approach aims to address these challenges, but it is tested only on foundational example problems, which may limit the ability to fully evaluate its performance on more complex real-world applications.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into potential limitations or caveats of the gradient-only surrogate modelling technique, such as its sensitivity to noise in the gradient data or its applicability to problems with highly nonlinear responses. [Further research may be needed to explore the [object Object] of this approach and its suitability for a wider range of multifidelity modelling scenarios.]
Conclusion
This study presents a new fusion approach for constructing multifidelity surrogate models by using only gradients to build regression surfaces, rather than relying on the full response data. This technique aims to address the persistent challenges in selecting fidelity levels and developing efficient data fusion methods for multifidelity modelling. While the proposed approach is demonstrated on foundational example problems, further research may be needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and potential applications in more complex real-world scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
0
Multifidelity Surrogate Models: A New Data Fusion Perspective
Daniel N Wilke
Multifidelity surrogate modelling combines data of varying accuracy and cost from different sources. It strategically uses low-fidelity models for rapid evaluations, saving computational resources, and high-fidelity models for detailed refinement. It improves decision-making by addressing uncertainties and surpassing the limits of single-fidelity models, which either oversimplify or are computationally intensive. Blending high-fidelity data for detailed responses with frequent low-fidelity data for quick approximations facilitates design optimisation in various domains. Despite progress in interpolation, regression, enhanced sampling, error estimation, variable fidelity, and data fusion techniques, challenges persist in selecting fidelity levels and developing efficient data fusion methods. This study proposes a new fusion approach to construct multi-fidelity surrogate models by constructing gradient-only surrogates that use only gradients to construct regression surfaces. Results are demonstrated on foundational example problems that isolate and illustrate the fusion approach's efficacy, avoiding the need for complex examples that obfuscate the main concept.
Read more4/24/2024
0
Multi-fidelity Gaussian process surrogate modeling for regression problems in physics
Kislaya Ravi, Vladyslav Fediukov, Felix Dietrich, Tobias Neckel, Fabian Buse, Michael Bergmann, Hans-Joachim Bungartz
One of the main challenges in surrogate modeling is the limited availability of data due to resource constraints associated with computationally expensive simulations. Multi-fidelity methods provide a solution by chaining models in a hierarchy with increasing fidelity, associated with lower error, but increasing cost. In this paper, we compare different multi-fidelity methods employed in constructing Gaussian process surrogates for regression. Non-linear autoregressive methods in the existing literature are primarily confined to two-fidelity models, and we extend these methods to handle more than two levels of fidelity. Additionally, we propose enhancements for an existing method incorporating delay terms by introducing a structured kernel. We demonstrate the performance of these methods across various academic and real-world scenarios. Our findings reveal that multi-fidelity methods generally have a smaller prediction error for the same computational cost as compared to the single-fidelity method, although their effectiveness varies across different scenarios.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Practical multi-fidelity machine learning: fusion of deterministic and Bayesian models
Jiaxiang Yi, Ji Cheng, Miguel A. Bessa
Multi-fidelity machine learning methods address the accuracy-efficiency trade-off by integrating scarce, resource-intensive high-fidelity data with abundant but less accurate low-fidelity data. We propose a practical multi-fidelity strategy for problems spanning low- and high-dimensional domains, integrating a non-probabilistic regression model for the low-fidelity with a Bayesian model for the high-fidelity. The models are trained in a staggered scheme, where the low-fidelity model is transfer-learned to the high-fidelity data and a Bayesian model is trained for the residual. This three-model strategy -- deterministic low-fidelity, transfer learning, and Bayesian residual -- leads to a prediction that includes uncertainty quantification both for noisy and noiseless multi-fidelity data. The strategy is general and unifies the topic, highlighting the expressivity trade-off between the transfer-learning and Bayesian models (a complex transfer-learning model leads to a simpler Bayesian model, and vice versa). We propose modeling choices for two scenarios, and argue in favor of using a linear transfer-learning model that fuses 1) kernel ridge regression for low-fidelity with Gaussian processes for high-fidelity; or 2) deep neural network for low-fidelity with a Bayesian neural network for high-fidelity. We demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed strategies and contrast them with the state-of-the-art based on various numerical examples. The simplicity of these formulations makes them practical for a broad scope of future engineering applications.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Multi-Fidelity Residual Neural Processes for Scalable Surrogate Modeling
Ruijia Niu, Dongxia Wu, Kai Kim, Yi-An Ma, Duncan Watson-Parris, Rose Yu
Multi-fidelity surrogate modeling aims to learn an accurate surrogate at the highest fidelity level by combining data from multiple sources. Traditional methods relying on Gaussian processes can hardly scale to high-dimensional data. Deep learning approaches utilize neural network based encoders and decoders to improve scalability. These approaches share encoded representations across fidelities without including corresponding decoder parameters. This hinders inference performance, especially in out-of-distribution scenarios when the highest fidelity data has limited domain coverage. To address these limitations, we propose Multi-fidelity Residual Neural Processes (MFRNP), a novel multi-fidelity surrogate modeling framework. MFRNP explicitly models the residual between the aggregated output from lower fidelities and ground truth at the highest fidelity. The aggregation introduces decoders into the information sharing step and optimizes lower fidelity decoders to accurately capture both in-fidelity and cross-fidelity information. We show that MFRNP significantly outperforms state-of-the-art in learning partial differential equations and a real-world climate modeling task. Our code is published at: https://github.com/Rose-STL-Lab/MFRNP
Read more6/26/2024