Note: Evolutionary Game Theory Focus Informational Health: The Cocktail Party Effect Through Werewolfgame under Incomplete Information and ESS Search Method Using Expected Gains of Repeated Dilemmas
2402.18598
0
0
🛸
Abstract
We explore the state of information disruption caused by the cocktail party effect within the framework of non-perfect information games and evolutive games with multiple werewolves. In particular, we mathematically model and analyze the effects on the gain of each strategy choice and the formation process of evolutionary stable strategies (ESS) under the assumption that the pollution risk of fake news is randomly assigned in the context of repeated dilemmas. We will develop the computational process in detail, starting with the construction of the gain matrix, modeling the evolutionary dynamics using the replicator equation, and identifying the ESS. In addition, numerical simulations will be performed to observe system behavior under different initial conditions and parameter settings to better understand the impact of the spread of fake news on strategy evolution. This research will provide theoretical insights into the complex issues of contemporary society regarding the authenticity of information and expand the range of applications of evolutionary game theory.This paper is partially an attempt to utilize Generative AI and was written with educational intent. There are currently no plans for it to become a peer-reviewed paper.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the impact of the "cocktail party effect" on information disruption in the context of non-perfect information games and evolutionary games with multiple "werewolves" (players trying to spread misinformation).
- The researchers mathematically model and analyze the effects of fake news on strategy choices and the formation of evolutionary stable strategies (ESS) under the assumption that the risk of misinformation is randomly assigned in repeated dilemmas.
- The paper aims to provide theoretical insights into the complex issues of information authenticity in contemporary society and expand the applications of evolutionary game theory.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers investigate how the "cocktail party effect" - the human ability to focus on one conversation while tuning out others - can disrupt the flow of information in certain game scenarios. They use mathematical modeling and simulations to understand how the spread of fake news can impact the choices people make and the strategies that become stable over time.
The key idea is that in situations where people have incomplete information, the presence of "werewolves" - individuals trying to spread misinformation - can lead to the formation of evolutionary stable strategies that may not be optimal for society as a whole. The researchers explore this by constructing gain matrices, modeling evolutionary dynamics, and identifying ESS.
Through their analysis, the researchers hope to provide insights into the challenges posed by the spread of fake news and the importance of maintaining the authenticity of information, especially in group decision-making scenarios and opinion leadership dynamics.
Technical Explanation
The researchers begin by mathematically modeling the effects of the "cocktail party effect" on information disruption in the context of non-perfect information games and evolutionary games with multiple "werewolves." They construct a gain matrix to represent the payoffs for different strategy choices and then use the replicator equation to model the evolutionary dynamics of the system.
Through this modeling process, the researchers are able to identify the evolutionary stable strategies (ESS) that emerge under different initial conditions and parameter settings. The key assumption is that the risk of fake news is randomly assigned in the context of repeated dilemmas, which allows the researchers to study the impact of information pollution on strategy evolution.
The computational simulations performed by the researchers provide further insights into the system's behavior, helping to understand the complex interplay between information authenticity, strategy choices, and evolutionary dynamics.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge the limitations of their approach, noting that the random assignment of fake news risk may not accurately reflect real-world scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential ethical implications of the research or the potential misuse of the insights gained.
While the mathematical modeling and computational simulations offer valuable theoretical insights, it would be beneficial for the researchers to explore the practical applications of their findings and how they could be translated into real-world solutions for addressing the challenges posed by information disruption and the spread of fake news.
Further research could also investigate the role of individual cognitive biases, social dynamics, and the impact of technological advancements (such as large language models) on the evolution of information authenticity in both online and offline environments.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to studying the impact of the "cocktail party effect" on information disruption by leveraging the tools of non-perfect information games and evolutionary game theory. The researchers' mathematical modeling and computational simulations provide valuable theoretical insights into the complex interplay between information authenticity, strategy choices, and evolutionary dynamics.
While the research has limitations and raises additional questions, it represents an important step towards understanding the challenges posed by the spread of fake news and the importance of maintaining the authenticity of information in contemporary society. The insights gained from this work could inform future research and the development of strategies to address these critical issues.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔄
Entanglement: Balancing Punishment and Compensation, Repeated Dilemma Game-Theoretic Analysis of Maximum Compensation Problem for Bypass and Least Cost Paths in Fact-Checking, Case of Fake News with Weak Wallace's Law
Yasuko Kawahata
0
0
This research note is organized with respect to a novel approach to solving problems related to the spread of fake news and effective fact-checking. Focusing on the least-cost routing problem, the discussion is organized with respect to the use of Metzler functions and Metzler matrices to model the dynamics of information propagation among news providers. With this approach, we designed a strategy to minimize the spread of fake news, which is detrimental to informational health, while at the same time maximizing the spread of credible information. In particular, through the punitive dominance problem and the maximum compensation problem, we developed and examined a path to reassess the incentives of news providers to act and to analyze their impact on the equilibrium of the information market. By applying the concept of entanglement to the context of information propagation, we shed light on the complexity of interactions among news providers and contribute to the formulation of more effective information management strategies. This study provides new theoretical and practical insights into issues related to fake news and fact-checking, and will be examined against improving informational health and public digital health.This paper is partially an attempt to utilize Generative AI and was written with educational intent. There are currently no plans for it to become a peer-reviewed paper.
4/30/2024
💬
Exploring Large Language Models for Communication Games: An Empirical Study on Werewolf
Yuzhuang Xu, Shuo Wang, Peng Li, Fuwen Luo, Xiaolong Wang, Weidong Liu, Yang Liu
0
0
Communication games, which we refer to as incomplete information games that heavily depend on natural language communication, hold significant research value in fields such as economics, social science, and artificial intelligence. In this work, we explore the problem of how to engage large language models (LLMs) in communication games, and in response, propose a tuning-free framework. Our approach keeps LLMs frozen, and relies on the retrieval and reflection on past communications and experiences for improvement. An empirical study on the representative and widely-studied communication game, ``Werewolf'', demonstrates that our framework can effectively play Werewolf game without tuning the parameters of the LLMs. More importantly, strategic behaviors begin to emerge in our experiments, suggesting that it will be a fruitful journey to engage LLMs in communication games and associated domains.
5/14/2024
📈
Plasmon Resonance Model: Investigation of Analysis of Fake News Diffusion Model with Third Mover Intervention Using Soliton Solution in Non-Complete Information Game under Repeated Dilemma Condition
Yasuko Kawahata
0
0
In this research note, we propose a new approach to model the fake news diffusion process within the framework of incomplete information games. In particular, we use nonlinear partial differential equations to represent the phenomenon of plasmon resonance, in which the diffusion of fake news is rapidly amplified within a particular social group or communication network, and analyze its dynamics through a soliton solution approach. In addition, we consider how first mover, second mover, and third mover strategies interact within this nonlinear system and contribute to the amplification or suppression of fake news diffusion. The model aims to understand the mechanisms of fake news proliferation and provide insights into how to prevent or combat it. By combining concepts from the social sciences and the physical sciences, this study attempts to develop a new theoretical framework for the contemporary problem of fake news.This paper is partially an attempt to utilize Generative AI and was written with educational intent. There are currently no plans for it to become a peer-reviewed paper.
5/1/2024
📉
Mutation-Bias Learning in Games
Johann Bauer, Sheldon West, Eduardo Alonso, Mark Broom
0
0
We present two variants of a multi-agent reinforcement learning algorithm based on evolutionary game theoretic considerations. The intentional simplicity of one variant enables us to prove results on its relationship to a system of ordinary differential equations of replicator-mutator dynamics type, allowing us to present proofs on the algorithm's convergence conditions in various settings via its ODE counterpart. The more complicated variant enables comparisons to Q-learning based algorithms. We compare both variants experimentally to WoLF-PHC and frequency-adjusted Q-learning on a range of settings, illustrating cases of increasing dimensionality where our variants preserve convergence in contrast to more complicated algorithms. The availability of analytic results provides a degree of transferability of results as compared to purely empirical case studies, illustrating the general utility of a dynamical systems perspective on multi-agent reinforcement learning when addressing questions of convergence and reliable generalisation.
5/29/2024