The opportunities and risks of large language models in mental health
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Mental health concerns are rising globally, and existing models of care may not be enough to meet the demand.
- Large language models (LLMs) offer promise for creating new, large-scale solutions to support mental health.
- LLMs have already been applied to mental health-related tasks like education, assessment, and intervention.
- This paper summarizes the literature on using LLMs for mental health and highlights opportunities and risks.
Plain English Explanation
The number of people dealing with mental health issues is increasing around the world, and the current way of providing mental health care may not be able to keep up with the growing need. With the development of large language models (LLMs), there is a lot of hope that these powerful AI systems can be used to create new, large-scale solutions to support mental health.
Even though LLMs are relatively new, they have already been used for various mental health-related tasks, such as providing education, assessing mental health, and delivering mental health interventions. This paper summarizes the existing research on using LLMs for these purposes and highlights the key opportunities and risks associated with this approach.
The urgent need for better mental health support must be balanced with the responsible development, testing, and deployment of LLMs for mental health applications. It's crucial to ensure that these LLMs are specifically tailored for mental health, promote equity in mental health care, and follow ethical standards. Additionally, it's important to involve people with lived experience of mental health concerns at all stages, from the development to the deployment of these LLMs.
By prioritizing these efforts, the potential harms to mental health can be minimized, and the likelihood that LLMs will have a positive impact on mental health globally can be maximized.
Technical Explanation
The paper provides a comprehensive review of the current efforts to use large language models (LLMs) for mental health-related tasks, including education, assessment, and intervention. The authors highlight the key opportunities and risks associated with this approach.
One of the main opportunities identified is the potential for LLMs to create novel, large-scale solutions to support mental health care, which is crucial given the rising global rates of mental health concerns and the limitations of existing models of care.
The paper also discusses how LLMs have already been applied to various mental health-related tasks, such as providing educational content, assessing mental health symptoms, and delivering therapeutic interventions. The authors review the existing literature on these applications and discuss the potential benefits and limitations of each approach.
Regarding risks, the paper emphasizes the importance of ensuring that mental health LLMs are fine-tuned for mental health, enhance mental health equity, and adhere to ethical standards. The authors also highlight the need to involve people with lived experience of mental health concerns in all stages of the development and deployment of these LLMs.
The paper concludes by emphasizing the urgent need to balance the potential benefits of using LLMs for mental health support with the responsible development, testing, and deployment of these systems. The authors encourage the adoption of strategies to mitigate the risks and maximize the positive impact of LLMs on mental health globally.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and well-structured review of the current efforts to use large language models (LLMs) for mental health-related tasks. The authors have done an excellent job of highlighting the key opportunities and risks associated with this approach, which is crucial given the sensitive nature of mental health and the potential for both positive and negative impacts.
One potential limitation of the paper is that it does not delve deeply into the specific technical details of the LLM architectures, training methods, and evaluation approaches used in the reviewed studies. While the paper is primarily focused on the high-level implications and considerations, a more technical discussion of the underlying models and methodologies could provide additional insights for researchers and developers working in this field.
Additionally, the paper could have explored more of the potential challenges and limitations of using LLMs for mental health applications, such as issues related to data privacy, algorithmic bias, and the generalizability of these models across diverse populations and cultural contexts. Exploring these areas could help inform the development of more robust and ethical LLMs for mental health support.
Overall, the paper is a valuable contribution to the growing body of research on the use of large language models in healthcare and the medical domain. The authors have done an excellent job of highlighting the key considerations and encouraging the development of responsible and ethical LLMs for mental health applications.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the current efforts to use large language models (LLMs) for mental health-related tasks, including education, assessment, and intervention. The authors highlight the great potential of LLMs to create novel, large-scale solutions to support mental health care, which is crucial given the rising global rates of mental health concerns and the limitations of existing models of care.
However, the authors also emphasize the importance of responsible development, testing, and deployment of mental health LLMs, as well as the need to ensure that these models are fine-tuned for mental health, enhance mental health equity, and adhere to ethical standards. Involving people with lived experience of mental health concerns in all stages of the process is also critical.
By prioritizing these efforts, the paper suggests that the potential harms to mental health can be minimized, and the likelihood that LLMs will have a positive impact on mental health globally can be maximized. This balanced and thoughtful approach to the use of LLMs for mental health support is a valuable contribution to the ongoing discussion in this important field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
The opportunities and risks of large language models in mental health
Hannah R. Lawrence, Renee A. Schneider, Susan B. Rubin, Maja J. Mataric, Daniel J. McDuff, Megan Jones Bell
Global rates of mental health concerns are rising, and there is increasing realization that existing models of mental health care will not adequately expand to meet the demand. With the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has come great optimism regarding their promise to create novel, large-scale solutions to support mental health. Despite their nascence, LLMs have already been applied to mental health related tasks. In this paper, we summarize the extant literature on efforts to use LLMs to provide mental health education, assessment, and intervention and highlight key opportunities for positive impact in each area. We then highlight risks associated with LLMs' application to mental health and encourage the adoption of strategies to mitigate these risks. The urgent need for mental health support must be balanced with responsible development, testing, and deployment of mental health LLMs. It is especially critical to ensure that mental health LLMs are fine-tuned for mental health, enhance mental health equity, and adhere to ethical standards and that people, including those with lived experience with mental health concerns, are involved in all stages from development through deployment. Prioritizing these efforts will minimize potential harms to mental health and maximize the likelihood that LLMs will positively impact mental health globally.
Read more8/2/2024
0
Large Language Models in Mental Health Care: a Scoping Review
Yining Hua, Fenglin Liu, Kailai Yang, Zehan Li, Hongbin Na, Yi-han Sheu, Peilin Zhou, Lauren V. Moran, Sophia Ananiadou, Andrew Beam, John Torous
The integration of large language models (LLMs) in mental health care is an emerging field. There is a need to systematically review the application outcomes and delineate the advantages and limitations in clinical settings. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the use of LLMs in mental health care, assessing their efficacy, challenges, and potential for future applications. A systematic search was conducted across multiple databases including PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, arXiv, medRxiv, and PsyArXiv in November 2023. All forms of original research, peer-reviewed or not, published or disseminated between October 1, 2019, and December 2, 2023, are included without language restrictions if they used LLMs developed after T5 and directly addressed research questions in mental health care settings. From an initial pool of 313 articles, 34 met the inclusion criteria based on their relevance to LLM application in mental health care and the robustness of reported outcomes. Diverse applications of LLMs in mental health care are identified, including diagnosis, therapy, patient engagement enhancement, etc. Key challenges include data availability and reliability, nuanced handling of mental states, and effective evaluation methods. Despite successes in accuracy and accessibility improvement, gaps in clinical applicability and ethical considerations were evident, pointing to the need for robust data, standardized evaluations, and interdisciplinary collaboration. LLMs hold substantial promise for enhancing mental health care. For their full potential to be realized, emphasis must be placed on developing robust datasets, development and evaluation frameworks, ethical guidelines, and interdisciplinary collaborations to address current limitations.
Read more8/22/2024
💬
0
Large Language Model for Mental Health: A Systematic Review
Zhijun Guo, Alvina Lai, Johan Hilge Thygesen, Joseph Farrington, Thomas Keen, Kezhi Li
Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for potential applications in digital health, while their application in mental health is subject to ongoing debate. This systematic review aims to evaluate the usage of LLMs in mental health, focusing on their strengths and limitations in early screening, digital interventions, and clinical applications. Adhering to PRISMA guidelines, we searched PubMed, IEEE Xplore, Scopus, JMIR, and ACM using keywords: 'mental health OR mental illness OR mental disorder OR psychiatry' AND 'large language models'. We included articles published between January 1, 2017, and April 30, 2024, excluding non-English articles. 30 articles were evaluated, which included research on mental health conditions and suicidal ideation detection through text (n=15), usage of LLMs for mental health conversational agents (CAs) (n=7), and other applications and evaluations of LLMs in mental health (n=18). LLMs exhibit substantial effectiveness in detecting mental health issues and providing accessible, de-stigmatized eHealth services. However, the current risks associated with the clinical use might surpass their benefits. The study identifies several significant issues: the lack of multilingual datasets annotated by experts, concerns about the accuracy and reliability of the content generated, challenges in interpretability due to the 'black box' nature of LLMs, and persistent ethical dilemmas. These include the lack of a clear ethical framework, concerns about data privacy, and the potential for over-reliance on LLMs by both therapists and patients, which could compromise traditional medical practice. Despite these issues, the rapid development of LLMs underscores their potential as new clinical aids, emphasizing the need for continued research and development in this area.
Read more8/14/2024
💬
0
Applying and Evaluating Large Language Models in Mental Health Care: A Scoping Review of Human-Assessed Generative Tasks
Yining Hua, Hongbin Na, Zehan Li, Fenglin Liu, Xiao Fang, David Clifton, John Torous
Large language models (LLMs) are emerging as promising tools for mental health care, offering scalable support through their ability to generate human-like responses. However, the effectiveness of these models in clinical settings remains unclear. This scoping review aimed to assess the current generative applications of LLMs in mental health care, focusing on studies where these models were tested with human participants in real-world scenarios. A systematic search across APA PsycNet, Scopus, PubMed, and Web of Science identified 726 unique articles, of which 17 met the inclusion criteria. These studies encompassed applications such as clinical assistance, counseling, therapy, and emotional support. However, the evaluation methods were often non-standardized, with most studies relying on ad hoc scales that limit comparability and robustness. Privacy, safety, and fairness were also frequently underexplored. Moreover, reliance on proprietary models, such as OpenAI's GPT series, raises concerns about transparency and reproducibility. While LLMs show potential in expanding mental health care access, especially in underserved areas, the current evidence does not fully support their use as standalone interventions. More rigorous, standardized evaluations and ethical oversight are needed to ensure these tools can be safely and effectively integrated into clinical practice.
Read more8/22/2024